An Early Diagnostic Clue for COL18A1- and LAMA1-Associated Diseases: High Myopia With Alopecia Areata in the Cranial Midline

Panfeng Wang, Xiaoyun Jia, Xueshan Xiao, Shiqiang Li, Yuxi Long, Mengchu Liu, Yongyu Li, Jun Li, Yan Xu, Qingjiong ZhangFrontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies a novel diagnostic clue for rare genetic disorders: early-onset high myopia combined with midline alopecia areata. Researchers found that mutations in either the COL18A1 gene (linked to Knobloch syndrome) or the LAMA1 gene (linked to Poretti-Boltshauser syndrome) can cause this combination of symptoms, suggesting a broader diagnostic net for ophthalmologists.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Diagnosing rare genetic syndromes can be challenging, especially when early symptoms are common or non-specific. High myopia, while prevalent, can also be an early indicator of underlying systemic or neurological disorders. Knobloch syndrome (KNO), caused by COL18A1 mutations, is known to present with high myopia and occipital skull defects. However, the authors observed similar presentations in patients with midline alopecia areata who did not have COL18A1 mutations, prompting an investigation into other genetic causes. This research aims to expand the understanding of genetic conditions associated with high myopia and scalp defects, particularly focusing on identifying new genetic links and providing a more comprehensive diagnostic approach.

Methods

The study employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Patient Recruitment: Six unrelated probands with early-onset high myopia and midline alopecia areata were recruited.
  • Genetic Analysis: Targeted high-throughput sequencing (including whole-exome sequencing and targeted exome sequencing) was performed on the probands' DNA to identify potential pathogenic variants. Cosegregation analysis was conducted with available family members to confirm the inheritance patterns of identified variants.
  • Variant Validation: Minigene assays and RNA sequencing were used to validate the functional impact of identified variants, particularly those affecting gene splicing or leading to gross deletions.
  • Clinical Assessment: Ophthalmological examinations and neuroimaging (MRI, CT, X-ray) were performed to thoroughly characterize the patients' phenotypes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Midline Alopecia as a Broad Diagnostic Clue: The study reveals that midline alopecia areata, in conjunction with early-onset high myopia, is not exclusive to COL18A1 mutations (Knobloch syndrome) but can also be indicative of LAMA1 mutations (Poretti-Boltshauser syndrome). This expands the diagnostic utility of this physical sign.
  • Novel LAMA1 Association with Scalp Defects: This research is the first to report scalp defects in patients with LAMA1 mutations, a significant finding that broadens the known phenotypic spectrum of Poretti-Boltshauser syndrome.
  • RNA Sequencing's Power in Detecting Complex Variants: The study highlights the crucial role of RNA sequencing in uncovering complex genetic alterations, such as gross deletions and aberrant splicing events, that might be missed by standard exome sequencing or Sanger sequencing alone. This was particularly evident in family 14518, where RNA sequencing revealed a complex biallelic mutation in COL18A1.
  • Phenotypic Overlap and Differentiation: While both COL18A1 and LAMA1 mutations can lead to high myopia and scalp defects, the specific location of the alopecia (occipital for COL18A1, parietal for LAMA1) and associated neurological findings (more pronounced in LAMA1-related PBS) help differentiate between the two syndromes.

Key Results

  • Eight novel and one known loss-of-function mutations were identified across six patients.
  • Three patients with COL18A1 mutations were diagnosed with Knobloch syndrome, presenting with occipital alopecia.
  • Three patients with LAMA1 mutations were diagnosed with Poretti-Boltshauser syndrome, presenting with parietal alopecia.
  • A gross deletion in COL18A1 was identified using RNA sequencing in family 14518, which was missed by other methods.
  • All identified mutations were predicted to result in a complete loss of function for the respective proteins.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small Cohort Size: The study is based on a small cohort of six unrelated probands. The authors acknowledge that the power of the association between the observed manifestations and the syndromes needs further evaluation in a larger cohort.
  • Functional Studies for LAMA1 and Alopecia: While the study establishes a link between LAMA1 mutations and alopecia areata, further functional studies are needed to elucidate the precise pathogenic mechanisms connecting LAMA1 mutations to this specific scalp phenotype.
  • Identifying Phenotypic Modifiers: The authors note that similar to previous observations, the exact position of mutations may not fully explain the phenotypic variability, suggesting the need to identify possible phenotypic modifiers.
  • Broader Screening: The study suggests that a simple physical examination of the scalp could serve as an early diagnostic clue for ophthalmologists when encountering children with high myopia, prompting further investigation for these rare syndromes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our study found that early onset high myopia with midline alopecia areata could be caused not only by mutations of the <i>COL18A1</i> gene but also by mutations in the <i>LAMA1</i> gene. To our knowledge, we are the first to observe scalp defects in patients with <i>LAMA1</i> mutations. High myopia with alopecia areata in the cranial midline could be treated as an early diagnostic clue for ophthalmologists to consider the two kinds of rare diseases.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2021early,
  author = {Panfeng Wang and Xiaoyun Jia and Xueshan Xiao and Shiqiang Li and Yuxi Long and Mengchu Liu and Yongyu Li and Jun Li and Yan Xu and Qingjiong Zhang},
  title = {{An Early Diagnostic Clue for COL18A1- and LAMA1-Associated Diseases: High Myopia With Alopecia Areata in the Cranial Midline}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fcell.2021.644947},
}
Figure