Abstract
Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) is among the most widely used deep reinforcement learning algorithms, yet its theoretical foundations remain incomplete. Most importantly, convergence and understanding of fundamental PPO advantages remain widely open. Under standard theory assumptions we show how PPO's policy update scheme (performing multiple epochs of minibatch updates on multi-use rollouts with a surrogate gradient) can be interpreted as approximated policy gradient ascent. We show how to control the bias accumulated by the surrogate gradients and use techniques from random reshuffling to prove a convergence theorem for PPO that sheds light on PPO's success. Additionally, we identify a previously overlooked issue in truncated Generalized Advantage Estimation commonly used in PPO. The geometric weighting scheme induces infinite mass collapse onto the longest $k$-step advantage estimator at episode boundaries. Empirical evaluations show that a simple weight correction can yield substantial improvements in environments with strong terminal signal, such as Lunar Lander.
Introduction
Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) has become the "workhorse" of modern reinforcement learning, powering everything from robotic control to the alignment of Large Language Models (LLMs) via RLHF. Despite its empirical dominance, a rigorous theoretical understanding of why PPO converges has been elusive. Most existing analyses treat PPO as a "Trust Region" method similar to TRPO, but this often ignores PPO's most distinctive features: the use of multiple epochs on the same data batch and the random shuffling of that data into minibatches. This paper bridges the "theory-implementation gap" by modeling PPO as a form of approximate gradient ascent and identifying a critical flaw in standard advantage estimation.
Theoretical Framework: PPO as Approximate Ascent
The authors propose a new perspective: PPO’s surrogate gradient updates are not just heuristic steps but are biased yet controllable approximations of the true policy gradient. By leveraging Random Reshuffling (RR) theory—traditionally used to analyze SGD in supervised learning—the researchers prove that PPO's multi-epoch, minibatch structure effectively performs a cyclic optimization process.
In this view, the multiple passes over the same data allow the agent to take "free" steps. These surrogate steps compensate for smaller, safer learning rates by effectively speeding up convergence without requiring additional environment interactions. The paper's primary theoretical contribution, Theorem 6.2, provides a formal proof that PPO converges to a stationary point under standard assumptions, validating the algorithm's data-reuse strategy.
Fixing the GAE "Tail-Mass Collapse"
Beyond convergence proofs, the paper identifies a significant implementation issue: tail-mass collapse in Generalized Advantage Estimation (GAE). GAE was originally designed for infinite-time horizons, but in practice, rollouts are truncated at episode boundaries.
Standard implementations accidentally dump all remaining mathematical weight onto the final, often most noisy, $k$-step estimate when an episode ends. This ruins the learning signal at the most critical moments—such as the final descent in a landing task. The authors propose "Finite-time GAE," a renormalized version that redistributes this weight across all available steps, ensuring stability near boundaries.
Empirical Results
The proposed "Finite-time GAE" was evaluated using the Stable-Baselines3 implementation on two benchmarks:
- LunarLander-v3: A task with a strong terminal signal. The modified GAE led to substantially faster learning and more reliable landings.
- Ant-v4 (MuJoCo): A high-dimensional continuous control task. The fix maintained performance, showing it generalizes beyond simple discrete tasks.
Furthermore, the modified GAE improved "critic stability," resulting in higher explained variance for the value function. This makes it easier for the agent to predict rewards and leads to more stable policy updates.
Discussion and Limitations
While this work provides a much-needed theoretical foundation for PPO, some limitations remain. The mathematical constants in the convergence proof are large, serving more as a structural proof than a hyperparameter guide. Additionally, the analysis focuses on a simplified version of PPO, omitting features like KL-regularization or asymmetric clipping. Future work will explore applying the Finite-time GAE fix to larger scales, such as LLM alignment (GRPO), where terminal signals and rollout truncations are equally prevalent.
Summary updated