Abstract
This study provides important information on who is publishing research in the epidemiological criminology field. This has implications for promoting research diversity, independence, funding equity, and partnerships between universities and government departments that control access to incarcerated and offending populations.
Introduction
Epidemiological criminology, or "epicriminology," represents the critical intersection of public health and criminal justice. Researching health within justice-involved populations is inherently difficult due to ethical complexities, restricted access to subjects, and the marginalized nature of the populations involved.
Despite these challenges, understanding the landscape of who produces this research is vital. It helps identify potential biases, ensures research independence, and highlights global disparities in funding and interest. This study maps 75 years of this field by analyzing over 21,000 PubMed articles to determine which stakeholders are driving the evidence base.
Methodology
The researchers utilized a semiautomated bibliometric analysis pipeline to process decades of data. The process began with querying PubMed for English-language articles published between 1946 and 2021 using keywords related to epidemiology and correctional settings (e.g., "remandee," "gaol," "delinquent").
The pipeline involved several key stages:
- Data Extraction: Identifying relevant abstracts from PubMed.
- Affiliation Processing: Using Python scripts to extract first-author affiliations from the metadata.
- Classification: Categorizing affiliations into eight distinct groups to understand the distribution of research leadership.
- Normalization: Manually cleaning data, expanding acronyms, and translating institution names.
- Contextual Mapping: Adjusting output based on national prisoner populations (via the World Prison Brief) and correlating findings with the World Justice Project Rule of Law Index.
Key Findings
The Dominance of Academia
Universities are the primary drivers of epidemiological criminology, accounting for 73.3% of all publications. In stark contrast, prison-affiliated groups authored only 1% of the research. While university involvement ensures a degree of independence, the low output from correctional departments suggests a significant missed opportunity for these agencies to engage in peer-reviewed research.
Global Trends and the "Nordic Excellence"
While the United States produces the highest raw volume of research (43.2% of the total), its ranking drops significantly when adjusted for its large incarcerated population, falling to 15th place globally. Conversely, Nordic countries (Sweden, Finland, Norway, and Denmark) lead the world in publication rates relative to prison populations. This likely reflects a rehabilitative justice model where health research is deeply integrated into the system.
Justice System Functionality
A strong correlation (–0.82) was found between a country's publication rate rank and its performance in the Rule of Law Index, specifically regarding criminal justice. Countries with more effective, transparent, and rights-respecting justice systems tend to produce significantly more health research in this field.
Results and Growth
The field has seen explosive growth, with a 95% increase in articles published between 1990 and 2021. Leading institutions include the Karolinska Institute (Sweden) and the University of New South Wales (Australia). Among government agencies, the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) was the most prolific in raw numbers, while the Norwegian Institute of Public Health led in population-adjusted publication rates.
Limitations and Future Directions
The study's reliance on PubMed may overlook "grey literature" (internal government reports) and sociologically focused studies found in other databases. Additionally, the focus on English-language publications introduces an Anglophone bias. Using the first author's affiliation as a proxy for the entire project might also obscure cross-sector collaborations. Future research should incorporate non-English publications and analyze senior author affiliations to better understand research leadership and funding.
Conclusion
This 75-year map of epidemiological criminology highlights the critical role of universities and the influence of national justice systems on research output. By identifying these patterns, stakeholders can better promote diversity and equity in research, ultimately improving health outcomes for justice-involved populations.
Summary updated