Abstract
This paper introduces a near-linear time algorithm to compute a "canonical form" for finite sets of points in the integer lattice $\mathbb{Z}^d$. Two sets are equivalent under affine transformations if and only if their canonical forms are identical. By leveraging arithmetic properties of integers—specifically congruence classes modulo 2—the algorithm achieves a complexity of $O(n \log^2 n)$ for a fixed dimension $d$, making it significantly faster than traditional geometric point-matching methods.
The Affine Point-Set Matching Problem
The core challenge addressed is affine point-set matching in an integer lattice. Given two finite sets of points in $\mathbb{Z}^d$, the goal is to determine if one can be transformed into the other using an affine automorphism. An affine automorphism of $\mathbb{Z}^d$ consists of a linear transformation (represented by a matrix with integer entries and determinant $\pm 1$) followed by a translation by an integer vector.
This problem has significant implications in algebra, particularly in determining if two Alexander polynomials (used to study knots and groups) are equivalent. Since these polynomials are defined up to a "change of basis" and multiplication by monomials, comparing them reduces to comparing the sets of their exponent vectors under affine transformations. Existing geometric approaches, such as computing the convex hull, become computationally expensive as the dimension $d$ increases. This research seeks a more efficient, "arithmetic-first" approach.
Methodology: Arithmetic-First Canonicalization
The algorithm shifts the strategy from direct matching to "canonicalization." Instead of comparing Set A to Set B, it transforms any set into a unique "canonical" version. The process relies on three main components:
- Frames: A "frame" is a set of affinely independent points that defines a coordinate system. A frame allows the rest of the set to be "standardized" relative to it.
- Hermite Normal Form (HNF): To handle linear algebra over integers without division, the algorithm uses the HNF to provide a unique, triangular basis for an integer lattice.
- Equivariant Recursive Partitioning: This is the core innovation. To find a canonical frame without checking every possible combination of points (which would be $O(n^d)$), the algorithm recursively partitions points based on their coordinates modulo 2. If all points are in the same congruence class mod 2, the set is scaled down and the process repeats. If they fall into different classes, the set is split. This "divide and conquer" approach ensures the choice of frame is "equivariant," meaning it moves predictably with the set under transformation.
Key Results and Complexity
The algorithm achieves a worst-case complexity of $O(n \log^2 n \cdot s \cdot \mu(s))$, where $n$ is the number of points and $s$ is the bit-size of the coordinates. Crucially, while the constant factor grows rapidly with the dimension $d$, for any fixed $d$, the algorithm scales almost linearly with the number of points. This is a significant improvement over the $O(n^{d/2})$ or $O(n^{d-2} \log n)$ bounds found in some continuous geometric matching algorithms.
Furthermore, the author extends the logic to "weighted" sets, allowing the algorithm to handle Laurent polynomials where each point (exponent vector) has an associated coefficient (weight). The paper provides a rigorous proof that the algorithm satisfies the requirements of a canonical form: it is invariant under the group action and returns a representative within the same orbit.
Conclusion and Future Work
By prioritizing arithmetic over geometry, this algorithm provides a practical and efficient solution for lattice point-set matching. While the dependence on dimension $d$ is likely doubly exponential, the near-linear scaling in $n$ makes it highly effective for low-dimensional applications. Future work may involve optimizing the number of frames considered in the recursive step or applying this tool to the isomorphism problem for specific classes of finitely presented groups.
Summary updated