An aircraft case study of the spatial transition from closed to open mesoscale cellular convection over the Southeast Pacific

Robert Wood, Christopher S. Bretherton, David A. Leon, Andrew Clarke, Paquita Zuidema, Grant Allen, Hugh Coe

TL;DR

This study uses aircraft data to investigate the transition zone between closed-cell stratocumulus and open-cell convection over the Southeast Pacific. It reveals that while precipitation rates are similar, the fate of drizzle and the aerosol microphysics differ dramatically, with open cells characterized by ultra-clean air and efficient drizzle removal.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Marine stratocumulus clouds cover vast areas of the ocean and play a crucial role in Earth's climate. These clouds can exist in two main forms: a continuous, overcast layer of closed mesoscale cellular convection, or a more broken pattern of open mesoscale cellular convection (POC). Understanding the transition between these two states is vital for accurately modeling cloud cover, precipitation, and their impact on climate. While it's known that precipitation plays a role, the exact mechanisms driving the formation of POCs and the differences in cloud structure and microphysics between these regimes have remained unclear. This paper aims to document these differences and explore the factors that might lead to the breakdown of closed-cell stratocumulus into open cells.

Methods

The study utilizes data from two research aircraft, the BAe-146 and the NSF C-130, which sampled the same airmass approximately 12 hours apart over the Southeast Pacific. The aircraft conducted long, straight-and-level flight legs at multiple altitudes within the marine boundary layer (MBL) and the lower free troposphere. This allowed for detailed sampling of the closed-cell stratocumulus, the POC, and the transition zone between them. A suite of instruments measured atmospheric state variables, winds, cloud liquid water content, drizzle characteristics (size distribution, concentration), and aerosol properties (size distribution, concentration) at high temporal resolution. Derived data products, such as cloud top height, radar reflectivity, and precipitation rates, were also analyzed. The research team also used satellite imagery to provide a broader context and track the evolution of the cloud features.

Datasets

  • Aircraft Data:
    • Facility for Airborne Atmospheric Measurements (FAAM) BAe-146 flight B409 (October 27, 2008)
    • National Science Foundation (NSF) C-130 flight RF06 (October 28, 2008)
    • Instruments included: standard atmospheric state and wind sensors, cloud liquid water content sensors (PVM, Johnson-Williams/Nevzorov), drizzle liquid water content and drop size distribution probes (2DC), cloud droplet concentration and size distribution probes (CDP), various aerosol size distribution instruments (PCASP, RDMA, LDMA, OPC, APS), CN counters (TSI 3025/3010), radar (WCR), lidar (WCL), and microwave radiometer (GVR).
  • Satellite Data:
    • GOES-10 visible and infrared imagery
    • MODIS visible imagery
  • Reanalysis Data:
    • NCEP GFS analysis and short-range forecast fields for trajectory estimation.
  • QuikSCAT wind data.
  • Reynolds SST data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Precipitation is not the sole driver of POC formation: Despite similar cloud-base precipitation rates in both closed-cell and open-cell regions, much of the drizzle in the closed-cell region evaporates below cloud, while significant surface precipitation occurs in the POC. This suggests that the fate of precipitation, not just its rate, is critical.
  • Ultra-clean air in POCs: The POC region is characterized by an "ultra-clean layer" with extremely low aerosol concentrations (as low as 0.1-1 cm⁻³), indicating highly efficient scavenging and sedimentation of aerosols.
  • Dramatic microphysical differences: Cloud droplet concentrations are an order of magnitude lower in the POC compared to the overcast region, leading to larger effective radii in the POC.
  • Aerosol gradients are key: Significant differences in aerosol concentrations, particularly in the accumulation mode, are observed between the POC and overcast regions, with lower concentrations in the POC subcloud layer.
  • MBL depth is surprisingly similar: Despite the stark differences in cloud structure and microphysics, the MBL depth remains remarkably consistent between the POC and overcast regions.

Key Results

  • A sharp spatial transition zone (20-30 km wide) was observed between closed-cell stratocumulus and a pocket of open cells (POC).
  • Cloud-base precipitation rates were similar (several mm d⁻¹) in both regions, but over 90% evaporated below cloud in the overcast region, while significant surface precipitation occurred in the POC.
  • The POC region exhibited an "ultra-clean layer" with aerosol concentrations as low as 0.1-1 cm⁻³.
  • Cloud droplet concentrations in the POC were approximately an order of magnitude lower (1-10 cm⁻³) than in the overcast region (typically 70 cm⁻³).
  • Subcloud aerosol concentrations were about three times higher in the overcast region (∼100 cm⁻³) compared to the POC (∼30 cm⁻³).
  • The MBL depth was nearly identical in both regions and increased uniformly over the 12-hour period between flights.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Observational limitations: The study acknowledges that high clouds can mask satellite observations, and aircraft sampling strategies can make it difficult to definitively separate diurnal variability from feature evolution. The exact boundaries of the transition zone were sometimes difficult to define precisely.
  • POC formation mechanism: The study did not directly observe the formation of the POC, making it difficult to pinpoint the exact trigger. The authors hypothesize that high cloud liquid water path (LWP) might lead to unsustainable CCN loss rates via coalescence scavenging, potentially making POC formation more likely under such conditions.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that cloud-resolving models are needed to further investigate the mesoscale dynamics and aerosol-cloud interactions that drive these transitions. Further analysis of other POC cases from the VOCALS-REx campaign and numerical modeling are required to fully understand POC formation mechanisms. The role of broad-scale ascent in maintaining drizzle in quiescent cells also warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Aircraft measurements are presented from the 27/28 October 2008 case study of the VOCALS Regional Experiment (REx) over the remote subtropical southeast Pacific (18° S, 80° W). Data from two aircraft that took measurements approximately twelve hours apart but in the same advected airmass are used to document a remarkably sharp spatial transition in marine boundary layer (MBL), cloud, and aerosol structure across the boundary between a well-mixed MBL containing overcast closed mesoscale cellular stratocumulus, and a pocket of open cells (POC) with significantly lower cloud cover. Long (~190–250 km) straight and level flight legs at three levels in the marine boundary layer and one level in the lower free troposphere permit sampling of the closed cells, the POC, and a 20–30 km wide transition zone with distinctly different structure from the two airmasses on either side. The POC region consists of intermittent active and strongly precipitating cumulus clouds rising and detraining into patches of drizzling but quiescent stratiform cloud which is optically thin especially toward its edges. Mean cloud-base precipitation rates inside the POC are several mm d−1, but rates in the closed cell region are not greatly lower than this. This latter finding suggests that precipitation is not a sufficient condition for POC formation from overcast stratocumulus. Despite similar cloud-base precipitation rates in the POC and overcast region, much of the precipitation (>90%) evaporates below cloud in the overcast region, while there is significant surface precipitation inside the POC. In the POC and transition region, although the majority of the condensate is in the form of drizzle, the integrated liquid water path is remarkably close to that expected for a moist adiabatic parcel rising from cloud base to top. The transition zone between the POC and the closed cells often consists of thick "boundary cell" clouds producing mean surface precipitation rates of 10–20 mm d−1, a divergent quasi-permanent cold/moist pool below cloud, a convergent inflow region at mid-levels in the MBL, and a divergent outflow near the top of the MBL. The stratiform clouds in the POC exist within an ultra-clean layer that is some 200–300 m thick. Aerosol concentrations (Na) measured by a PCASP in the diameter range 0.12–3.12 μm in the center of the ultra-clean layer are as low as 0.1–1 cm−3. This suggests that coalescence scavenging and sedimentation is extremely efficient, since Na in the subcloud layer, and droplet concentration Nd in the active cumuli are typically 20–60 cm−3. The droplet concentrations in the quiescent stratiform clouds are extremely low (typically 1–10 cm−3), and most of their liquid water is in the form of drizzle, which mainly evaporates before reaching the surface. The cloud droplet concentration in the overcast region decreases strongly as the transition region is approached, as do subcloud accumulation mode aerosol concentrations, suggesting that coalescence scavenging is impacting regions in the overcast region as well as inside the POC. Both flights show lower accumulation mode aerosol concentration in the subcloud layer of the POC (Na ∼ 30 cm−3) compared with the overcast region (Na ∼ 100 cm−3), but elevated (and mostly volatile) total aerosol concentrations are observed in the POC at all levels around 20–50 km from the transition zone, perhaps associated with some prior nucleation event. Despite the large differences in cloud and MBL structure across the POC-overcast boundary, the MBL depth is almost the same in the two regions, and increases in concert over the 12 h period between the flights.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wood2011aircraft,
  author = {Robert Wood and Christopher S. Bretherton and David A. Leon and Andrew Clarke and Paquita Zuidema and Grant Allen and Hugh Coe},
  title = {{An aircraft case study of the spatial transition from closed to open mesoscale cellular convection over the Southeast Pacific}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-11-2341-2011},
}
Figure