An adaptive hybrid stress transition quadrilateral finite element method for linear elasticity

Feiteng Huang, Xiaoping Xie, Chen-Song Zhang

Abstract

In this paper, we discuss an adaptive hybrid stress finite element method on quadrilateral meshes for linear elasticity problems. To deal with hanging nodes arising in the adaptive mesh refinement, we propose new transition types of hybrid stress quadrilateral elements with 5 to 7 nodes. In particular, we derive a priori error estimation for the 5-node transition hybrid stress element to show that it is free from Poisson-locking, in the sense that the error bound in the a priori estimate is independent of the Lame constant $\lambda$. We introduce, for quadrilateral meshes, refinement/coarsening algorithms, which do not require storing the refinement tree explicitly, and give an adaptive algorithm. Finally we provide some numerical results.

Introduction

In finite element analysis (FEA), quadrilateral meshes are often preferred over triangular ones for their superior accuracy in many engineering applications. However, they are notoriously difficult to refine adaptively. When a single quadrilateral is split into four, "hanging nodes" are created where new vertices meet the edges of unrefined neighbors. Standard practices typically involve either propagating refinement unnecessarily to maintain mesh conformity or using complex constraints to "tie" nodes together.

Furthermore, many standard elements suffer from Poisson-locking. As a material's Poisson’s ratio approaches 0.5 (becoming nearly incompressible, like rubber), numerical models often become artificially stiff, leading to significant errors. This research presents a unified solution: an adaptive framework that handles hanging nodes naturally via specialized transition elements while remaining immune to locking.

Methodology

The proposed method utilizes the Hybrid Stress Finite Element Method, based on the Hellinger-Reissner variational principle. Unlike standard displacement-based methods, hybrid methods treat both displacement and stress as independent variables, providing a more robust framework for avoiding locking.

Coordinate Mapping and Transition Elements

The core of the method involves mapping a reference square in the $(\xi, \eta)$ plane to a physical quadrilateral in the $(x, y)$ plane.

Mapping from the reference square to a physical quadrilateral element.

To handle hanging nodes without over-refining the mesh, the authors introduce 5-node, 6-node, and 7-node quadrilateral elements. These "transition elements" incorporate hanging nodes directly into their geometry and interpolation functions.

A 5-node transition element in the reference domain.

Locking-Free Performance

A significant technical contribution is the mathematical derivation of a priori error estimates for the 5-node element. The authors prove that the error bound is independent of the Lamé constant $\lambda$, confirming that the method is "locking-free." This is achieved through careful optimization of stress modes—using a 7-parameter mode for the 5-node element—to satisfy the "inf-sup" stability condition, the mathematical standard for ensuring mixed finite element stability.

Non-Recursive AMR Algorithm

Most adaptive algorithms rely on a memory-intensive "refinement tree" to store parent-child relationships. This paper adapts a non-recursive approach to quadrilaterals, utilizing a data structure that only requires vertex coordinates and connectivity. This simplifies implementation in high-level languages like MATLAB and achieves linear computational complexity.

Key Results and Discussion

The method was evaluated against several benchmarks:

  • Efficiency: In L-shaped domain tests, the quadrilateral algorithm reached target accuracy in approximately half the time (35s vs 79s) compared to standard triangular bisection methods in the iFEM library.
  • Locking Resistance: In cantilever beam tests with Poisson’s ratios as high as 0.49999999999, relative displacement errors remained stable at approximately 1%, whereas standard elements typically fail or show massive error spikes.
  • Optimal Convergence: For crack problems with high-stress singularities, the adaptive method demonstrated a significantly steeper error reduction curve than uniform refinement, effectively targeting the singularity at the crack tip.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates that treating hanging nodes as features of transition elements, rather than constraints to be eliminated, allows for efficient and robust adaptive mesh refinement. While currently limited to 2D plane elasticity and requiring shape-regular quadrilaterals, the method provides a powerful framework for simulating nearly incompressible materials without the penalties of Poisson-locking. Future work may explore extending these transition elements to 3D hexahedral meshes.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we discuss an adaptive hybrid stress finite element method on quadrilateral meshes for linear elasticity problems. To deal with hanging nodes arising in the adaptive mesh refinement, we propose new transition types of hybrid stress quadrilateral elements with 5 to 7 nodes. In particular, we derive a priori error estimation for the 5-node transition hybrid stress element to show that it is free from Poisson-locking, in the sense that the error bound in the a priori estimate is independent of the Lame constant $λ$. We introduce, for quadrilateral meshes, refinement/coarsening algorithms, which do not require storing the refinement tree explicitly, and give an adaptive algorithm. Finally we provide some numerical results.
BibTeX
@article{huang2016adaptive,
  author = {Feiteng Huang and Xiaoping Xie and Chen-Song Zhang},
  title = {{An adaptive hybrid stress transition quadrilateral finite element method for linear elasticity}},
  journal = {Journal of Computational Mathematics},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.4208/jcm.1511-m4496},
}
Figure