An Information Bottleneck Approach to Secrecy-Preserving Gaussian Mixture Classification

Yi Song, Kai Wan, Yuan Zhang, Di Xie, Zhengyu Liao, Giuseppe Caire

Abstract

The information bottleneck (IB) approach, initially introduced to assess the "compression--relevance" tradeoff for remote source coding, has gained significant popularity in modern machine learning. Despite its conceptual simplicity, solutions for the IB problem in Gaussian mixture models (GMMs) have remained largely numerical. This paper derives the first set of analytic, closed-form achievable bounds for the IB problem under GMM settings by combining hard quantization and soft nonlinear transformations. These bounds demonstrate near-optimal performance compared to the Blahut-Arimoto (BA) algorithm on both synthetic and real-world datasets, suggesting broad applicability for efficient communication and privacy-preserving machine learning.

Introduction: The Information Bottleneck Problem

The Information Bottleneck (IB) is a fundamental framework used to find the optimal tradeoff between compression (complexity) and predictive power (relevance). In a communication context, this can be visualized as a relay receiving a noisy signal $X^n$ from a source $Y^n$. The relay must compress $X^n$ into a message $f_n(X^n)$ within a certain rate $R$ to save bandwidth, while ensuring a final receiver can still accurately estimate the original source $\hat{Y}^n$.

The remote source coding problem framework, illustrating the Information Bottleneck setup.

While closed-form solutions exist for purely Gaussian or binary cases, many real-world scenarios involve Gaussian Mixtures (GMMs)—such as binary signals sent over noisy channels. Until now, solving the IB for GMMs required computationally intensive iterative methods like the Blahut-Arimoto (BA) algorithm. This research provides the first analytic solutions for these complex scenarios, which is crucial for both efficient communication system design and understanding privacy-preserving machine learning.

Proposed Analytic Methods

The authors propose a unified achievable scheme for the single-letter IB problem $Y \to X \to T$, where $T$ is the bottleneck variable that compresses $X$ while retaining information about $Y$.

The single-letter Information Bottleneck model where $X$ is compressed into $T$ while preserving information about $Y$.

The scheme integrates three distinct quantization strategies, each excelling in different regimes of the complexity-relevance tradeoff:

  1. Two-level Random Quantization: This treats the problem as a Doubly Symmetric Binary Source (DSBS). It uses a simple indicator function combined with a Bernoulli random variable to control the compression rate.
  2. Multi-level Deterministic Quantization: This maps the continuous observation into $L$ discrete "bins." The authors analytically determine the quantization points and probabilities to satisfy the bottleneck constraint.
  3. Soft Quantization with Tanh: Inspired by the fact that the Minimum Mean Square Error (MMSE) estimator for a binary source in Gaussian noise is a hyperbolic tangent function, the authors apply a tanh non-linearity followed by additive Gaussian noise.

By taking the maximum of these three approaches, they create a "unified" lower bound that remains near-optimal across all signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs).

Experimental Evaluation and Results

The researchers evaluated their methods using both synthetic Gaussian mixtures and the MNIST dataset. For MNIST, they focused on binary classification tasks (e.g., distinguishing '7' from '9'), using random projections to reduce high-dimensional images to a 3D space before applying their IB schemes.

Key findings include:

  • Near-Optimality: The proposed analytic scheme achieves performance almost identical to the numerical Blahut-Arimoto (BA) algorithm, the numerical gold standard, but with significantly lower computational complexity.
  • Outperforming Deep Learning: Their method consistently outperformed Information Dropout, a popular neural-network-based approach, achieving higher classification accuracy for the same "information budget."
  • Privacy as a Bottleneck: The paper frames machine learning classification with "information leakage" as an IB problem. Here, "complexity" is the amount of private information leaked, and "relevance" is the classification accuracy. Their analytic solutions provide a way to guarantee privacy levels while maintaining high accuracy.

Limitations and Future Work

Current work focuses primarily on binary (BPSK) sources. Extending these analytic solutions to M-ary modulation (like 16-QAM) or continuous sources remains an open challenge. Additionally, developing a way to apply these analytic IB solutions directly to high-dimensional raw data without a pre-processing step (like random projections) would be a significant leap forward. Finally, finding the optimal input distribution $Y$ that maximizes the bottleneck remains a subject of ongoing research.

Summary updated

Abstract

The information bottleneck (IB) approach, initially introduced by Tishby et al. to assess the "compression--relevance" tradeoff for a remote source coding problem in communications, gains popularity recently in its application to modern machine learning (ML). Despite its seemingly simple form, the solution to IB problem remains largely unknown, and can only be assessed numerically even in the simple setting of Gaussian mixture model that is of fundamental significance in ML. In this paper, by combining ideas of hard quantization and soft nonlinear transformation, we derive closed-form achievable bounds for the IB problem under the above setting. The derived bounds establish surprisingly close behavior to the (numerically) optimal IB solution obtained by Blahut--Arimoto (BA) algorithm, on both synthetic and real-world (so non-Gaussian mixture) datasets, suggesting possibly wider applicability of our results.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2024information,
  author = {Yi Song and Kai Wan and Yuan Zhang and Di Xie and Zhengyu Liao and Giuseppe Caire},
  title = {{An Information Bottleneck Approach to Secrecy-Preserving Gaussian Mixture Classification}},
  booktitle = {ISIT},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=VFO9mrT1jw},
}

Loading related content...

Figure