β-Amino Acids Reduce Ternary Complex Stability and Alter the Translation Elongation Mechanism

F. Aaron Cruz-Navarrete, Wezley C. Griffin, Yuk‐Cheung Chan, Maxwell I. Martin, José Luís Pérez Alejo, Ryan A. Brady, S. Kundhavai Natchiar, Isaac J. Knudson, Russ B. Altman, Alanna Schepartz, Scott J. Miller, Scott C. Blanchard

TL;DR

This study investigates how non-natural amino acids (nnAAs) with altered backbones affect the crucial ternary complex formation step in protein synthesis. They found that certain β-amino acid isomers significantly destabilize this complex, leading to inefficient or failed incorporation into proteins, highlighting a major bottleneck for expanding the genetic code.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The ability to synthesize proteins with non-natural amino acids (nnAAs) holds immense promise for creating novel therapeutics and materials. However, current methods for incorporating these nnAAs into proteins are often inefficient. This inefficiency stems from a lack of understanding of how these nnAAs interact with the cellular machinery responsible for protein synthesis, particularly the ribosome. A key step in this process is the formation of a "ternary complex" between an aminoacylated transfer RNA (aa-tRNA), a protein called elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu), and a GTP molecule. This complex delivers the correct amino acid to the ribosome. This paper aims to elucidate how nnAAs with modified backbones, specifically β-amino acids, impact the stability and formation of this essential ternary complex, and consequently, their utilization during protein translation.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of sophisticated biophysical techniques to probe the dynamics of ternary complex formation and ribosome interaction:

  • Ensemble Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET): This technique uses fluorescent dyes attached to EF-Tu and tRNA. When the ternary complex forms, the proximity of these dyes leads to a measurable change in fluorescence, allowing the researchers to track the rate and extent of complex formation and dissociation.
  • Single-Molecule Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer (smFRET): This advanced method allows for the observation of individual molecular events. By tethering ribosomes to a surface and observing the FRET signals from single aa-tRNAs interacting with them, the researchers could dissect the step-by-step process of tRNA selection, accommodation, and translocation.
  • Stopped-flow kinetics: This technique enables rapid mixing of reactants and immediate monitoring of fluorescence changes, providing high temporal resolution to capture fast kinetic events.
  • Kinetic simulations: Computational modeling was used to interpret the experimental data and predict ternary complex behavior under cellular conditions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental measurements using purified components and synthesized nnAAs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The ternary complex is a critical bottleneck: The stability and efficient formation of the ternary complex are not just important, but represent a major hurdle for incorporating many nnAAs, especially those with altered backbones.
  • Chirality and backbone matter significantly: The specific stereochemistry (R vs. S) and the position of the amino group in the amino acid backbone (α vs. β) have profound effects on ternary complex stability.
  • β²-amino acids are "deal breakers": (R)- and (S)-β²-phenylalanine (Phe) isomers completely disrupted ternary complex formation to the point of being undetectable in vitro. This suggests they are effectively excluded from the translation process.
  • β³-amino acids are "inefficient players": (R)- and (S)-β³-Phe isomers significantly reduced ternary complex stability, leading to inefficient utilization by the ribosome.
  • Proofreading bypass: The reduced stability of β³-Phe ternary complexes appears to cause the ribosome to bypass its normal proofreading steps, potentially leading to errors or premature termination.
  • Translocation is also affected: (R)-β³-Phe, in particular, showed significant defects in the rate of translocation after incorporation, further hindering protein synthesis.

Key Results

  • (R)- and (S)-β²-Phe: Disrupted ternary complex formation to below detection limits.
  • (R)- and (S)-β³-Phe: Reduced ternary complex stability by approximately one order of magnitude.
  • Ribosome Utilization:
    • (R)- and (S)-β²-Phe-charged tRNAs were not utilized by the ribosome.
  • (R)- and (S)-β³-Phe stereoisomers were utilized inefficiently (10-fold less than L-a-Phe).
  • (R)-β³-Phe: Exhibited order-of-magnitude defects in the rate of translocation.
  • Kinetic parameters: (S)-β³-Phe showed a significantly reduced affinity for EF-Tu (KD ~1 µM) compared to L-a-Phe (KD ~40 nM), indicating a much less stable ternary complex.

Limitations and Future Work

  • In vitro vs. In vivo: While the study provides crucial mechanistic insights using in vitro systems, the direct translation of these findings to cellular environments requires further investigation. The authors acknowledge that cellular concentrations of EF-Tu might partially alleviate some deficiencies, but complex instability remains a concern.
  • Broader nnAA scope: The study focused on specific β-amino acid isomers of phenylalanine. Future work could explore a wider range of nnAAs with different backbone modifications and side chains to build a more comprehensive understanding.
  • Engineering solutions: The authors suggest that engineering EF-Tu and tRNA components could compensate for the negative impacts of nnAAs on ternary complex formation and stability, paving the way for improved genetic code expansion technologies.
  • Mechanistic details of translocation defects: While (R)-β³-Phe showed translocation defects, further detailed studies are needed to pinpoint the exact molecular mechanisms behind these delays.
  • Cellular context: The authors emphasize the need for parallel in vitro and in cellulo investigations to fully understand the impact of ribosome drop-offs and quality control mechanisms on nnAA incorporation efficiency and yield.

Summary updated

Abstract

Templated synthesis of proteins containing non-natural amino acids (nnAAs) promises to expand the chemical space available to biological therapeutics and materials, but existing technologies are still limiting. Addressing these limitations requires a deeper understanding of the mechanism of protein synthesis and how it is perturbed by nnAAs. Here we examine the impact of nnAAs on the formation and ribosome utilization of the central elongation substrate: the ternary complex of native, aminoacylated tRNA, thermally unstable elongation factor, and GTP. By performing ensemble and single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer measurements, we reveal that both the (<i>R</i>)- and (<i>S</i>)-β<sup>2</sup> isomers of phenylalanine (Phe) disrupt ternary complex formation to levels below in vitro detection limits, while (<i>R</i>)- and (<i>S</i>)-β<sup>3</sup>-Phe reduce ternary complex stability by 1 order of magnitude. Consistent with these findings, (<i>R</i>)- and (<i>S</i>)-β<sup>2</sup>-Phe-charged tRNAs were not utilized by the ribosome, while (<i>R</i>)- and (<i>S</i>)-β<sup>3</sup>-Phe stereoisomers were utilized inefficiently. (<i>R</i>)-β<sup>3</sup>-Phe but not (<i>S</i>)-β<sup>3</sup>-Phe also exhibited order of magnitude defects in the rate of translocation after mRNA decoding. We conclude from these findings that non-natural amino acids can negatively impact the translation mechanism on multiple fronts and that the bottlenecks for improvement must include the consideration of the efficiency and stability of ternary complex formation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cruznavarrete2024amino,
  author = {F. Aaron Cruz-Navarrete and Wezley C. Griffin and Yuk‐Cheung Chan and Maxwell I. Martin and José Luís Pérez Alejo and Ryan A. Brady and S. Kundhavai Natchiar and Isaac J. Knudson and Russ B. Altman and Alanna Schepartz and Scott J. Miller and Scott C. Blanchard},
  title = {{β-Amino Acids Reduce Ternary Complex Stability and Alter the Translation Elongation Mechanism}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1021/acscentsci.4c00314},
}
Figure