Abstract
Electroencephalogram (EEG) power reductions in the aging brain have been described by numerous previous studies. However, the underlying mechanism for the observed brain signal power reduction remains unclear. One possible cause for reduced EEG signals in elderly subjects might be the increased distance from the primary neural electrical currents on the cortex to the scalp electrodes as the result of cortical atrophies. While brain shrinkage itself reflects age-related neurological changes, the effects of changes in the distribution of electrical conductivity are often not distinguished from altered neural activity when interpreting EEG power reductions. To address this ambiguity, we employed EEG forward models to investigate whether brain shrinkage is a major factor for the signal attenuation in the aging brain. We simulated brain shrinkage in spherical and realistic brain models and found that changes in the conductor geometry cannot fully account for the EEG power reductions even when the brain was shrunk to unrealistic sizes. Our results quantify the extent of power reductions from brain shrinkage and pave the way for more accurate inferences about deficient neural activity and circuit integrity based on EEG power reductions in the aging population.
Introduction
As the human brain ages, recorded electroencephalogram (EEG) signals exhibit significant attenuation. Previous research has noted reductions in alpha-band power of up to 20 dB in elderly subjects compared to younger cohorts. This phenomenon raises a critical question: is this reduction a direct reflection of declining neurophysiological activity, or is it an artifact of anatomical changes?
Cortical atrophy—the physical shrinking of the brain—increases the volume of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) between the cortex and the scalp. Because CSF is highly conductive, it may act as a "shunt," diverting electrical currents away from scalp electrodes. If this anatomical shunting is the primary driver of signal loss, EEG power would be a misleading biomarker for neural health. This study utilizes sophisticated EEG forward modeling to isolate the impact of head geometry from actual neural decline.
Methods
The researchers employed EEG forward modeling to calculate scalp potentials based on known current sources and head conductivity. A critical innovation was the use of a four-layer Boundary Element Method (BEM) model, incorporating skin, skull, CSF, and brain compartments. This contrasts with standard three-layer models that often omit the CSF layer, which is essential for simulating atrophy.
The study used a dual-modeling approach involving a simplified spherical model for theoretical verification and a realistic MRI-based model constructed from high-resolution T1-weighted scans of a healthy young subject.
Brain shrinkage was systematically simulated by reducing the brain compartment volume by 0% to 30% in 5% increments. For reference, 10% shrinkage represents severe clinical atrophy, while 30% is biologically extreme. Simulations were also run across varying conductivity values for the skull and CSF to ensure results were robust to physiological uncertainties.
Results
The simulations revealed that anatomical changes play only a minor role in EEG signal attenuation. In the realistic MRI-based model, a 5% brain shrinkage resulted in a 2.1 dB reduction, while a 10% shrinkage resulted in only a 3.7 dB reduction. Even at a biologically unrealistic 30% shrinkage, the power reduction reached only ~8.1 dB.
These findings contrast sharply with clinical observations of 15 to 20 dB reductions in the elderly. Since 10% atrophy explains less than 4 dB of loss, more than 75% of the observed decibel change in clinical settings must be attributed to neurophysiological factors, such as reduced neuronal synchronization or density. Furthermore, varying tissue conductivity across reported physiological ranges only impacted the results by approximately 0.5 dB, confirming the stability of these findings.
Discussion and Conclusion
This study demonstrates that the physical shunting effect of CSF due to cortical atrophy cannot account for the dramatic EEG power drops seen in aging. The results validate EEG power as a robust biomarker for functional neural decline rather than a mere reflection of head geometry.
While the study was limited by using a single-subject template for the realistic model, the consistency between the spherical and realistic models suggests high generalizability. Future work could involve using individual MRI data to calculate subject-specific "atrophy attenuation factors." This would allow researchers to "correct" EEG data, isolating the true neural activity and providing more precise diagnostic tools for monitoring brain aging and neurodegenerative diseases.
Summary updated