Age-Related Differences in Structure and Function of Nasal Epithelial Cultures From Healthy Children and Elderly People

Anita Balázs, Pamela Millar-Büchner, Michael Mülleder, Vadim Farztdinov, Łukasz Szyrwiel, Annalisa Addante, Aditi Kuppe, Tihomir Rubil, Marika Drescher, K. Seidel, Sebastian Stricker, Roland Eils, Irina Lehmann, Birgit Sawitzki, Jobst Röhmel, Markus Ralser, Marcus MallFrontiers in Immunology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals intrinsic age-related differences in the structure and function of human nasal epithelial cells, using advanced culture and proteomic techniques. These findings highlight how aging impacts our first line of respiratory defense, potentially explaining age-specific susceptibilities to airway diseases.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The nasal epithelium acts as a critical barrier against inhaled pathogens and irritants, playing a vital role in lung health. While it's known that clinical outcomes related to airway diseases vary significantly with age, the underlying changes in the nasal epithelium itself due to aging remain poorly understood. This knowledge gap is significant because understanding these age-related alterations could lead to better strategies for preventing and treating respiratory illnesses that disproportionately affect children and the elderly.

Methods

The researchers utilized a sophisticated approach involving primary human nasal epithelial cell cultures grown at an air-liquid interface (ALI). This method allows the cells to mimic the in vivo airway environment, enabling the study of their structure and function. Key techniques included:

  • Immunofluorescence microscopy: To visualize and quantify different cell types (ciliated, secretory, basal) and protein expression (MUC5AC, KRT5, α-tubulin, ZO-1, TMEM16A).
  • Transepithelial Ion Transport Measurements (Ussing Chamber Experiments): To assess the electrical properties of the epithelium, specifically focusing on ion channels involved in fluid and mucus transport (ENaC, CFTR, TMEM16A).
  • RNA Extraction and RT-PCR: To measure the transcript levels of key genes like CFTR and TMEM16A.
  • Western Blotting: To quantify the protein levels of mucins (MUC5AC, MUC5B).
  • Liquid Chromatography-Tandem Mass Spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) with DIA-PASEF: This is a high-throughput proteomic technique used to identify and quantify thousands of proteins in the cell samples, providing a comprehensive molecular snapshot.
  • Bioinformatics Analysis: Including Principal Component Analysis (PCA) for sample clustering, linear modeling for differential expression analysis, and Gene Set Enrichment Analysis (GSEA) to identify biological pathways affected by age.

Datasets

The study utilized nasal brush samples from two distinct groups: 17 healthy children (aged ≤10 years) and 14 healthy non-smoking elderly people (aged ≥60 years). The proteomic data generated from these samples were deposited in the ProteomeXchange repository under accession number PXD030130. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing datasets and annotation databases (like UniProt) were used for analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Structural Differences Reflect Age: The most striking finding is that even in healthy individuals, the nasal epithelium's structure changes with age. Children have fewer ciliated cells but more MUC5AC-producing secretory cells compared to the elderly. This suggests a fundamental difference in how the airway lining is built and maintained across the lifespan.
  • Functional Differences in Chloride Secretion: While basic ion transport mechanisms (like sodium absorption via ENaC and CFTR-mediated chloride secretion) were similar, the elderly showed a significantly stronger response to calcium-activated chloride secretion, mediated by TMEM16A. This points to a specific age-related shift in how the epithelium regulates fluid balance, potentially impacting mucus hydration.
  • Proteomics Uncovers Age Signatures: The comprehensive proteomic analysis revealed distinct molecular profiles for children and the elderly. Notably, elderly samples showed enrichment in pathways related to mitochondrial function and cilia maintenance, while children's samples highlighted mucin glycosylation and immune-epithelial interactions. This provides a molecular basis for the observed structural and functional differences.
  • Implications for Disease Susceptibility: The observed age-related changes, particularly in ciliation and mucin production, could explain why certain respiratory infections or conditions manifest differently in children versus the elderly. For instance, altered mucin profiles might contribute to the distinct pathologies seen in childhood asthma versus adult COPD.

Key Results

  • Cell Composition: Children had significantly fewer ciliated cells (α-tubulin+) and more MUC5AC+ secretory cells compared to the elderly. Basal cell numbers were comparable.
  • Mucin Expression: MUC5AC transcript and protein levels were higher in children's cultures. MUC5B levels were similar between groups.
  • Ion Transport: No significant age-related differences were found in basal, ENaC-mediated, or CFTR-mediated ion transport. However, calcium-activated chloride secretion (UTP-induced) was approximately 50% lower in children compared to the elderly.
  • Proteomics: Over 7,000 proteins were identified. PCA showed clear age-based separation. 364 proteins were upregulated and 254 downregulated in the elderly compared to children. Key upregulated pathways in the elderly included mitochondrial function and cilia-related processes, while children showed enrichment in mucin glycosylation and immune responses.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model System Limitations: While ALI cultures are excellent models, they are still in vitro and may not perfectly replicate the complex in vivo environment. The study acknowledges that global proteomics might miss subtle post-translational modifications crucial for signaling.
  • Functional Relevance of TMEM16A: The study identified a functional difference in TMEM16A-mediated secretion but notes that its precise role in age-dependent airway disease phenotypes needs further investigation.
  • Mechanisms of Aging: The study identifies age-related differences but doesn't fully elucidate the underlying molecular mechanisms driving these changes (e.g., epigenetic factors, cellular senescence).
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest further research to explore the mechanisms behind these age-related differences, particularly the role of mitochondria and TMEM16A in airway homeostasis and disease. They also emphasize the need to connect these findings to specific age-dependent airway disease phenotypes and clinical outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

The nasal epithelium represents the first line of defense against inhaled pathogens, allergens, and irritants and plays a key role in the pathogenesis of a spectrum of acute and chronic airways diseases. Despite age-dependent clinical phenotypes triggered by these noxious stimuli, little is known about how aging affects the structure and function of the airway epithelium that is crucial for lung homeostasis and host defense. The aim of this study was therefore to determine age-related differences in structural and functional properties of primary nasal epithelial cultures from healthy children and non-smoking elderly people. To achieve this goal, highly differentiated nasal epithelial cultures were established from nasal brushes at air-liquid interface and used to study epithelial cell type composition, mucin (MUC5AC and MUC5B) expression, and ion transport properties. Furthermore, we determined age-dependent molecular signatures using global proteomic analysis. We found lower numeric densities of ciliated cells and higher levels of MUC5AC expression in cultures from children vs. elderly people. Bioelectric studies showed no differences in basal ion transport properties, ENaC-mediated sodium absorption, or CFTR-mediated chloride transport, but detected decreased calcium-activated TMEM16A-mediated chloride secretory responses in cultures from children vs. elderly people. Proteome analysis identified distinct age-dependent molecular signatures associated with ciliation and mucin biosynthesis, as well as other pathways implicated in aging. Our data identified intrinsic, age-related differences in structure and function of the nasal epithelium and provide a basis for further studies on the role of these findings in age-dependent airways disease phenotypes observed with a spectrum of respiratory infections and other noxious stimuli.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{balazs2022age,
  author = {Anita Balázs and Pamela Millar-Büchner and Michael Mülleder and Vadim Farztdinov and Łukasz Szyrwiel and Annalisa Addante and Aditi Kuppe and Tihomir Rubil and Marika Drescher and K. Seidel and Sebastian Stricker and Roland Eils and Irina Lehmann and Birgit Sawitzki and Jobst Röhmel and Markus Ralser and Marcus Mall},
  title = {{Age-Related Differences in Structure and Function of Nasal Epithelial Cultures From Healthy Children and Elderly People}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Immunology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fimmu.2022.822437},
}
Figure