Aerial-Aided mmWave VANETs Using NOMA: Performance Analysis, Comparison, and Insights

Abdullah Abu Zaid, Baha Eddine Youcef Belmekki, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

This academic paper, titled "Aerial-Aided mmWave VANETs Using NOMA: Performance Analysis, Comparison, and Insights," explores a hybrid communication architecture designed to solve the connectivity challenges of modern "smart" cities. By combining tethered drones, high-frequency millimeter waves, and advanced multiple-access techniques, the authors provide a roadmap for the next generation of vehicular networks.

TL;DR

The paper proposes using Networked Tethered Flying Platforms (NTFPs) to enhance vehicular networks, overcoming the line-of-sight blockages common in urban environments. By leveraging mmWave frequencies and Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA), the study demonstrates that aerial platforms significantly outperform traditional roadside units for long-distance communication and as primary data sources.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As cities become more crowded, Vehicular Ad Hoc Networks (VANETs) face two major hurdles:

  1. Physical Blockage: Buildings and other vehicles block signals, especially at high frequencies like millimeter-wave (mmWave), which require a clear Line-of-Sight (LOS).
  2. Spectrum Congestion: The explosion of smart devices and the rise of Urban Air Mobility (UAM)—like delivery drones and air taxis—mean more devices are fighting for limited bandwidth.

Traditional solutions like Roadside Units (RSUs) are limited by their low height, while free-flying drones suffer from short battery lives and weak backhaul connections. This paper investigates whether tethered drones (NTFPs), which have continuous power and a wired data link to the ground, can bridge this gap.

Methods

The authors employ stochastic geometry to model the messy, random nature of urban traffic. Key methodological components include:

  • Spatial Modeling: Vehicles are modeled using a Poisson Line Cox Process (PCP), while UAVs are modeled with a Binomial Point Process (BPP).
  • Access Scheme: They use NOMA, which allows multiple users to share the same frequency and time slot by using different power levels, compared against the standard Orthogonal Multiple Access (OMA).
  • Channel Modeling: The study incorporates a sectored beamforming model for mmWave, accounting for beam steering errors and different LOS probabilities for terrestrial vs. aerial links.
  • Transmission Schemes: They analyze and derive closed-form expressions for three modes: Direct Transmission (DT), Relay Transmission (RT), and Hybrid Transmission (HT).

Datasets

The paper does not use a real-world empirical dataset. Instead, it utilizes Monte Carlo simulations to validate its theoretical derivations. The simulation environment is a 20 km x 20 km urban area with parameters (vehicle density, building blockage factors, etc.) derived from established literature in the field of vehicular communications.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Altitude Advantage: NTFPs are superior to RSUs primarily because their high altitude (500m in the study) allows them to "see" over buildings, maintaining a stable LOS link that terrestrial units cannot.
  • Distance-Dependent Performance: RSUs actually outperform drones for very short distances (<100m) because the path loss is lower. However, as the distance between vehicles increases, the RSU's performance plummets due to blockages, while the NTFP remains stable.
  • NOMA’s Sweet Spot: NOMA is highly effective for low-to-medium data rates, providing better spectral efficiency than OMA. However, at very high data rate requirements, OMA can sometimes be better because NOMA requires a portion of the power to be dedicated to interference cancellation, which becomes a bottleneck.
  • Direct vs. Relay: In many high-rate scenarios, direct transmission is actually preferred over relaying, provided a LOS exists. Relaying is most useful as a fallback when the direct path is completely obstructed.

Key Results

  • Outage Probability: NTFPs using Hybrid Transmission provide the lowest outage probability for data rates below 1.1 bits/s.
  • Relay Superiority: For source-destination distances greater than 100m, NTFPs acting as relays consistently provide higher achievable rates than RSUs.
  • Interference Resilience: While increasing the number of interfering UAVs hurts all ground units, NTFPs are more resilient to this interference than RSUs because of their superior main-lobe gain and LOS probability.
  • Cross-over Points: The authors successfully derived "cross-point" values—specific data rates and power coefficients where NOMA begins to outperform OMA, providing a practical tool for network designers.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Imperfect SIC: The authors acknowledge that Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC) in NOMA is rarely perfect in the real world. While they modeled "imperfect SIC," higher error rates significantly degrade the gains of NOMA.
  • Interference-Limited Assumption: The study assumes an interference-limited environment (ignoring thermal noise). While common in dense urban studies, this might not hold in suburban or rural settings.
  • Static Positioning: The analysis assumes the NTFP is at a fixed optimal location. Future research could explore the impact of drone mobility or the dynamic optimization of the tether length and drone altitude in real-time.
  • Hardware Constraints: The complexity of implementing sectored beamforming and NOMA on high-speed vehicles remains a significant practical challenge not fully explored here.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we propose the integration of tethered flying platforms in cooperative vehicular ad hoc networks (VANETs) to alleviate the problems of rapid urbanization. In this context, we study the performance of VANETs by deriving approximate outage probability and average achievable rate expressions using tools from stochastic geometry. We compare between the usage of networked tethered flying platforms (NTFPs) and traditional roadside units (RSUs). On the other hand, the rapid increase of smart devices in vehicles and the upcoming urban air mobility (UAM) vision will congest the spectrum and require increased data rates. Hence, we use non-orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) to improve spectral efficiency and compare its performance to orthogonal access schemes. Furthermore, we utilize millimeter-wave (mmWave) frequencies for high data rates and implement a sectored beamforming model. We extensively study the system using three transmission schemes: direct, relay, and hybrid transmission. The results show that when acting as relays, NTFPs outperform RSUs for larger distances between the transmitting and the receiving vehicles, while RSUs outperform NTFPs for short distances. However, NTFPs are the best solution when acting as a source. Moreover, we find that, in most cases, direct transmission is preferred to achieve a high rate compared to other schemes. Finally, the results are summarized in two tables that provide insights into connecting VANETs by selecting the most suitable platform and type of communication for a given set of parameters, configurations, and requirements.
BibTeX
@article{zaid2024aerial,
  author = {Abdullah Abu Zaid and Baha Eddine Youcef Belmekki and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Aerial-Aided mmWave VANETs Using NOMA: Performance Analysis, Comparison, and Insights}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Vehicular Technology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/tvt.2023.3330306},
}

Loading related content...

Figure