Adaptive Spacecraft Attitude Tracking Control with Actuator Uncertainties

Hyungjoo Yoon, Panagiotis TsiotrasAIAA 2005 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel adaptive control strategy for spacecraft attitude tracking that robustly handles uncertainties in the orientation and gains of onboard actuators like Variable Speed Control Moment Gyros (VSCMGs). By employing a Lyapunov-based approach with a smooth projection algorithm, the controller ensures stable attitude control even when actuator characteristics are not precisely known, a common issue in real-world spacecraft.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Precise control of a spacecraft's orientation (attitude) is crucial for many missions, from scientific observation to space station operations. This control is typically achieved using actuators like reaction wheels or control moment gyros (CMGs). However, a significant challenge arises from uncertainties in these actuators. These uncertainties can stem from manufacturing tolerances, installation misalignments, or wear and tear, leading to deviations in the direction and effectiveness of the generated torques.

Traditional adaptive control methods often assume that actuator characteristics are perfectly known. This paper tackles the more realistic scenario where the precise spin axis directions and input gains of flywheel actuators (specifically VSCMGs, which offer advantages in energy storage and singularity-free operation) are uncertain. Such uncertainties can be particularly detrimental for high-speed flywheels, potentially causing unwanted torques that destabilize the spacecraft. The core problem is to design an adaptive controller that can compensate for these unknown actuator parameters while ensuring stable and accurate attitude tracking.

Methods

The authors develop an adaptive control algorithm based on Lyapunov stability theory. The spacecraft's equations of motion, including the VSCMGs, are first converted into a first-order state-space form. A key aspect of their approach is the use of Modified Rodrigues Parameters (MRPs) to represent the spacecraft's attitude, which are well-defined over the entire rotation range.

The control law is designed to cancel out the known parts of the system dynamics while adapting to the unknown actuator parameters. To prevent the parameter estimates from drifting into regions that could cause control singularities or "bursting" (where estimates become excessively large), a "smooth projection algorithm" is employed. This algorithm ensures that the estimated parameters remain within a predefined, safe convex set that is known to contain the true, unknown values. This projection mechanism is crucial for maintaining stability and robustness.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and simulation-based validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Actuator Uncertainty is a Real-World Problem: The paper highlights that assuming perfect actuator knowledge is unrealistic and can lead to performance degradation or instability, especially for advanced actuators like VSCMGs.
  • Smooth Projection for Robustness: The smooth projection algorithm is a critical innovation. It effectively bounds parameter estimates, preventing them from causing control law singularities and ensuring stable adaptation even with unknown actuator parameters.
  • MRPs for Comprehensive Attitude Representation: Using Modified Rodrigues Parameters simplifies the attitude kinematics and allows for a more general control design that covers the full range of spacecraft rotations.
  • Generalizability: While the controller is developed for VSCMGs, the underlying methodology is presented as being applicable to other MIMO dynamical systems, including spacecraft with different actuator types or multi-link robot manipulators.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates through numerical simulations that the proposed adaptive controller significantly reduces attitude tracking errors compared to a non-adaptive approach. The parameter estimates for the unknown actuator characteristics are shown to approach their true values, albeit with some "bursts" attributed to a lack of persistent excitation in the reference trajectory. Importantly, the square of the norms of the parameter estimates are kept within bounds by the projection algorithm, preventing them from diverging. The simulations also show that the gimbal angles and wheel speeds of the VSCMGs remain within acceptable limits.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the adaptive law does not guarantee a priori that parameter estimates will converge exactly to their true values. This is partly due to the complexity of the system and the potential for insufficient "persistency of excitation" in the reference trajectory, which can lead to intermittent bursts in parameter estimates.

A significant area for future improvement mentioned is reducing the number of parameters to be estimated, which would be extremely beneficial for computational efficiency and potentially improve convergence. The authors also note that while the controller was designed using simplified equations of motion, the simulations using the full nonlinear model showed good performance, suggesting that the simplifications made for design purposes were reasonable.

Summary updated

Abstract

An adaptive control algorithm for the spacecraft attitude tracking problem when the spin axis directions and/or the gains of the flywheel actuators are uncertain is developed. A smooth projection algorithm is applied to keep the parameter estimates inside a singularity-free region and avoid parameter bursting. Numerical examples show that the controller successfully deals with unknown misalignments of the axis directions as well as the unknown gains of the flywheel actuators.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yoon2005adaptive,
  author = {Hyungjoo Yoon and Panagiotis Tsiotras},
  title = {{Adaptive Spacecraft Attitude Tracking Control with Actuator Uncertainties}},
  booktitle = {AIAA},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.2514/6.2005-6392},
}
Figure