Abstract
We present a general importance sampling technique for approximating expected values based on samples from probabilistic finite tree automata. The algorithm uses the samples it produces to adapt rule probabilities for the automaton in order to improve sample quality.
Introduction
Estimating expected values over complex tree structures is a fundamental challenge in Natural Language Processing (NLP). Tasks such as calculating feature expectations for Conditional Random Fields (CRFs), computing KL divergence between models, or performing minimum risk decoding often require integrating over a vast space of possible trees. While exact algorithms like the semiring approach exist, they are frequently rendered impractical by non-local dependencies (e.g., in neural models) or the combinatorial explosion of the parse chart.
When exact computation fails, importance sampling offers a viable alternative. However, the efficiency of importance sampling depends heavily on the similarity between the proposal distribution and the target distribution. This paper introduces an adaptive importance sampling method that iteratively refines a proposal distribution represented as a Probabilistic Tree Automaton (pRTA).
Methodology
The proposed method utilizes a pRTA as a proposal distribution due to its ease of sampling and probability calculation. The core innovation lies in the adaptation mechanism: the algorithm treats the rule probabilities of the pRTA as parameters ($\theta$) and adjusts them using Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD) based on the generated samples.
The objective is to minimize the Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence between the pRTA and the target distribution. The authors derive a strictly convex objective function that avoids the need to compute the target distribution's normalization constant (partition function $Z$). Furthermore, a "lazy" implementation ensures that only the states and rules encountered during sampling are updated, allowing the method to scale to massive automata.
Experimental Setup
To validate the approach, the authors conducted experiments using synthetic pRTAs structured similarly to CKY parse charts. Target distributions were created by assigning rule probabilities via a symmetric Dirichlet distribution, with a concentration parameter $\gamma$ controlling the "peakiness" of the distribution. The primary evaluation metric was the estimation of a constant expected value $E[1]$, which should ideally equal 1.0.
Results and Discussion
The experimental results demonstrate that the adaptive sampler successfully "learns" the high-probability regions of the target distribution. As shown in Figure 1, for a standard distribution ($\gamma=0.5$), the estimated values quickly converge to the true value of 1.0 within approximately 40 estimation rounds.
The method also proves robust for "peaky" distributions ($\gamma=0.1$), where most probability mass is concentrated on a few trees. While these cases present a greater challenge for standard sampling, the adaptive mechanism eventually stabilizes the estimate, even with a larger sample size $k=2000$ as seen in Figure 2.
Key insights include:
- Efficiency: Adapting parameters is often more effective than increasing sample size. For instance, 500 samples with adaptation outperformed 2000 samples without it.
- Scalability: The lazy update mechanism handled automata representing over $10^9$ possible trees.
- Convexity: The strictly convex nature of the objective function guarantees convergence toward optimal rule probabilities.
Conclusion
This work provides a theoretical and synthetic proof of concept for adaptive importance sampling from pRTAs. By leveraging SGD to shape the proposal distribution, the method significantly improves the efficiency of expectation estimation in complex domains. Future work will focus on extending the framework to ambiguous automata and integrating it into real-world NLP tasks such as neural reranking and graph parsing.
Summary updated