Introduction
Contextual bandits are a core framework for sequential decision-making, where an agent learns to map contexts to actions to maximize cumulative rewards. A common assumption in this field is realizability, where the true reward function is assumed to lie within a pre-specified model class. However, in real-world scenarios, models are often misspecified, leading to significant performance degradation. This paper introduces Safe-FALCON, a computationally efficient algorithm designed to remain robust under misspecification using standard offline regression oracles.
The Challenge of Misspecification
When a model is misspecified, standard bandit algorithms can become overly aggressive in exploitation. By focusing on a narrow region of the context space based on a flawed model, they collect biased data, which further degrades the model's accuracy. This often results in "oscillatory" behavior: performance improves initially but eventually crashes as the model's errors are compounded. The authors highlight that when a model is suspect, robustness requires curbing exploitation.
Methodology: The Safe-FALCON Algorithm
Safe-FALCON builds upon the FALCON+ framework, which operates in doubling epochs. It introduces a novel "safety test" to detect when misspecification is causing performance drops. The algorithm consists of four key components:
- Offline Regression Oracle: Unlike complex robust methods requiring online oracles, Safe-FALCON utilizes a standard "black box" offline regression tool, making it highly practical.
- The Safety Test: During each epoch, the algorithm monitors cumulative rewards against a theoretical lower bound of expected performance.
- The "Safe" Reversion: If performance falls below the threshold, the algorithm flags the situation as unsafe, stops updating the model, and reverts to a "safe policy"—the best-performing policy from a previous stable epoch.
- Action Selection: During safe periods, it uses a probability kernel to balance exploitation with sufficient exploration to maintain theoretical regret bounds.
Results and Discussion
The authors prove that Safe-FALCON achieves an optimal regret bound of $O(\epsilon \sqrt{KT} + \text{realizable regret})$, where $\epsilon$ represents the average misspecification error. This matches the established lower bound of $\Omega(\epsilon \sqrt{KT})$, proving the algorithm's theoretical optimality.
Empirically, the authors demonstrate Safe-FALCON's stability in a synthetic two-arm environment designed to trigger failures in linear models. While standard algorithms exhibit a regret spike after epoch 12 (as seen in Figure 1), Safe-FALCON successfully detects the misspecification and flattens the regret curve by sticking to its safe policy. This eliminates the need for complex "master-algorithm" frameworks previously used to manage unknown error levels.
Conclusion
Safe-FALCON provides a robust and efficient solution for contextual bandits under misspecification. By relying on simple safety checks and standard regression tools, it offers a practical path toward more reliable automated decision-making. Future work may explore adaptive experimentation strategies that continue learning even after misspecification is detected, potentially finding better policies than the static "safe" one without falling back into the oscillatory trap.
Summary updated