Active biomonitoring of heavy metal pollution level of Wulihu area, Lake Taihu using "standardized" <i>Anodonta woodiana</i>

Xiubao Chen, Yanping Su, Hongbo Liu, Yang JianJournal of Lake Sciences 2014 · DOI

Abstract

This study utilized artificially propagated, "standardized" Anodonta woodiana mussels to monitor heavy metal pollution in the Wulihu area of Lake Taihu over a nine-month period. Mussels were transplanted from a clean control site (Nanquan Aquatic Base) to Wulihu, with samples collected every three months to analyze 15 heavy metals using ICP-MS. Results indicated that while bioaccumulation occurred in both groups, concentrations of toxic metals (Cr, Cu, As, Cd, and Pb) remained significantly below national and international safety standards. Metal Pollution Indexes (MPI) and average synthetic pollution indices suggested that both Wulihu and the control site maintain normal background levels of heavy metals, indicating no significant pollution in the study areas.

Introduction

Monitoring heavy metal concentrations in aquatic ecosystems is critical for environmental health and food safety. Traditional water quality sampling often fails to capture intermittent pollution events or the long-term bioavailability of toxins. Biomonitoring, particularly using filter-feeding bivalves like mussels, offers a solution by integrating environmental exposure over time. However, the use of wild organisms introduces significant "noise" due to variations in age, genetics, and prior exposure. This study addresses these limitations by employing "standardized" mussels—lab-bred individuals of the same age and genetic background—to provide a consistent baseline for active biomonitoring in Lake Taihu.

Methods and Materials

The research team implemented an active biomonitoring strategy using one-year-old Anodonta woodiana mussels artificially reared at the Nanquan Aquatic Base. These standardized mussels were divided into two groups: a control group remaining at the Nanquan Base and an experimental group transplanted to the Wulihu area of Lake Taihu, historically known for higher pollution levels.

Map of the study area showing the transplantation site in Wulihu and the control site at Nanquan Base.

Sampling occurred at three-month intervals (3, 6, and 9 months). Soft tissues were analyzed using Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS) for 15 heavy metals. The overall environmental health was quantified using the Metal Pollution Index (MPI) and a Synthetic Pollution Index, comparing results against Chinese national standards (GB/T 2762-2005, NY 5073-2006) and international benchmarks from the EU and FAO.

Results

Safety and Regulatory Compliance

A primary finding of the study was that the concentrations of critical toxic metals—specifically Chromium (Cr), Copper (Cu), Arsenic (As), Cadmium (Cd), and Lead (Pb)—were consistently well below both domestic and international safety limits for aquatic products.

Comparison of heavy metal concentrations in mussel soft tissues with national and international safety standards.

The Synthetic Pollution Index for both sites remained below 0.2, classifying the environments as having "normal background levels." While the Metal Pollution Index (MPI) increased over time in both groups—reflecting natural bioaccumulation as the mussels aged—there were no statistically significant differences in the overall pollution indices between the "clean" control pond and the Wulihu area. This suggests that Wulihu is no longer a heavy metal "hotspot" compared to reference sites.

Temporal Variations

Interesting temporal anomalies were observed. For instance, after three months, transplanted mussels showed significantly higher Arsenic (As) levels than the control group, though these levels stabilized later. Conversely, levels of Manganese (Mn), Iron (Fe), Zinc (Zn), and Barium (Ba) were initially lower in the transplanted group. By the six and nine-month marks, Lead (Pb) concentrations in the Wulihu group were actually lower than those in the control group.

Discussion

The use of standardized mussels proved effective in reducing biological variance, allowing for a clearer interpretation of environmental data. The study highlights a significant historical recovery; Lead levels in Wulihu mussels are now a fraction of those recorded in 2003, indicating successful long-term remediation efforts in Lake Taihu.

However, biological factors still influence the data. The researchers noted that metabolic changes during spawning cycles in spring and summer can affect metal accumulation rates. Future studies might benefit from using juvenile mussels to minimize this reproductive "noise." Additionally, the lack of regulatory standards for metals like Aluminum (Al) and Barium (Ba) in aquatic life remains a challenge for comprehensive ecological risk assessment.

Conclusion

Active biomonitoring with standardized Anodonta woodiana confirms that heavy metal levels in the Wulihu area of Lake Taihu are within safe limits and comparable to unpolluted reference sites. This methodology provides a robust framework for ongoing environmental surveillance and highlights the effectiveness of recent pollution control measures in the region.

Summary updated

Abstract

将人工繁育的 标准化 背角无齿蚌(Anodonta woodiana)移殖至太湖五里湖,并以仍养殖在未受污染的中国水产科学研究院淡水渔业研究中心南泉基地的同批蚌作为对照,进行为期9个月的主动监测研究.每3个月回收一次蚌样,应用电感耦合等离子质谱仪(ICP-MS)测定15种重金属(Al、Cr、Mn、Fe、Co、Ni、Cu、Zn、As、Mo、Ag、Cd、Ba、Tl和Pb)的含量.结果表明,南泉基地对照组和五里湖移殖组的蚌样对重金属均产生了明显的生物积累.培养3个月的五里湖移殖组蚌样中As的含量显著高于同期南泉基地对照组,而前者Mn、Fe、Zn和Ba含量显著低于后者;培养6个月的五里湖移殖组蚌样中Al和Pb的含量显著低于同期南泉基地对照组;培养9个月的五里湖移殖组蚌样中Pb含量显著低于同期南泉基地对照组.然而,南泉基地对照组和五里湖移殖组蚌样中重金属(Cr、Cu、As、Cd和Pb)含量均低于我国及国际上的相关标准.培养3、6和9个月的南泉基地对照组及五里湖移殖组蚌样的重金属污染指数分别为1.8、1.8,2.4、2.1和8.3、16.8,均值综合污染指数分别为0.0218、0.0289,0.0337、0.0218和0.0560、0.0732,属于正常背景水平,并且两水体蚌样的重金属污染指数和均值综合污染指数无显著差异,提示五里湖和南泉基地均未受到明显的重金属污染.;A group of artificially propagated standardized Anodonta woodiana mussels were transplanted to Wulihu area of Lake Taihu for assessing the spatial and temporal trends of heavy metal pollution. Meanwhile, the same batch mussels were continually reared in an unpolluted pond of Nanquan Aquatic Base of Freshwater Fisheries Research Center, Chinese Academy of Fishery Sciences as a control group. The period of active biomonitoring by transplantation was over 9 months. Mussels from the transplanted and control groups were recollected, respectively, every 3 months to determine heavy metal (Al, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, As, Mo, Ag, Cd, Ba, Tl, and Pb) concentrations using an ICP-MS. The results showed that metal bioaccumulation were presented in both control and transplanted mussels. Arsenic concentration in mussels transplanted to Wulihu area for 3 months was significantly higher than that of control mussels in Nanquan Aquatic Base for 3 months, while concentrations of Mn, Fe, Zn, and Ba in the former were significantly lower than those of the latter;concentrations of Al and Pb in mussels transplanted to Wulihu area for 6 months were significantly lower than those of the same period control mussels of Nanquan Aquatic Base;and Pb concentration in mussels transplanted to Wulihu area for 9 months were significantly lower than that of the same period control mussels. However, concentrations of heavy metals (Cr, Cu, As, Cd, and Pb) in both control mussels and transplanted mussels were obviously lower than national and international limits. In addition, metal pollution indexes (MPI) of control mussels for 3, 6 and 9 months were 1.8, 2.4, and 8.3, respectively, and those of transplanted mussels were 1.8, 2.1, and 16.8, respectively. The MPI levels of them were consistent. Meanwhile, average synthetically pollution index of control mussels for 3, 6 and 9 months were 0.0218, 0.0337, and 0.0560, respectively, and those of transplanted mussels were 0.0289, 0.0218, and 0.0732, respectively. Their levels of average synthetically pollution index were without significantly different. The results indicated that the background concentrations of heavy metals in Wulihu area and Nanquan Aquatic Base were in the same levels, and both aquatic environments seemed to be without obvious metal pollution.
BibTeX
@article{chen2014active,
  author = {Xiubao Chen and Yanping Su and Hongbo Liu and YANG Jian},
  title = {{Active biomonitoring of heavy metal pollution level of Wulihu area, Lake Taihu using "standardized" \<i\>Anodonta woodiana\</i\>}},
  journal = {Journal of Lake Sciences},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.18307/2014.0607},
}
Figure