Accurate Direct Measurements of Far-Field Thermal Infrared Emission and its Dynamics

Xiu Liu, Hakan Salihoglu, Xiao Luo, Hyeong Seok Yun, Jing Lin, Bowen Yu, Sheng ShenarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Accurate direct measurements of far-field thermal infrared emission are becoming increasingly critical as conventional indirect methods—relying on reflectance and transmittance—fail to characterize modern devices with novel spectra, directionalities, and polarizations. Characterizing these micro-scale devices is challenging due to their shrinking footprints and the overwhelming thermal noise from their surroundings. This paper demonstrates a microscopic lock-in Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) system that achieves a million-fold improvement in specific detectivity over commercial systems. By combining a microscope, a lock-in amplifier (LIA), and an FTIR, the system enables ultrasensitive detection that overcomes optical loss and background noise. We present an analytical model of the signal detection process, exploring how modulated Joule heating and global heating can be synchronized to maximize signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). Our results show that measurable signals can be captured at temperatures three times lower than previously possible, achieving an SNR of 23.7 at approximately 125 °C. Furthermore, the system records spectral-resolved dynamics at frequencies up to 175 kHz, with potential extensions into the MHz range.

Introduction

As electronic and optical devices shrink toward the nanoscale, managing and measuring their thermal emission becomes a fundamental challenge. Traditional emissivity measurements often rely on Kirchhoff’s Law, calculating emission indirectly from reflection and transmission data. However, this approach is frequently inaccurate for modern nanodevices that exhibit high scattering, non-reciprocity, or operate under non-equilibrium conditions.

Directly measuring far-field thermal radiation from these tiny footprints is notoriously difficult because the signal is easily drowned out by environmental thermal noise. Historically, researchers had to heat devices to extreme temperatures (often exceeding 480 °C) to generate a detectable signal, a process that risks damaging temperature-sensitive materials or destroying the microdevice itself. There is a clear need for a high-sensitivity, non-destructive method to characterize thermal emission at lower operating temperatures.

The Microscopic Lock-in FTIR System

To address these challenges, we developed a hybrid system integrating three core components:

  1. Microscopy: A reflective objective focuses specifically on the active region of the microdevice. This spatial filtering reduces optical loss and blocks thermal noise from surrounding structures.
  2. Step-Scan FTIR: The system utilizes Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy in "step-scan" mode to capture the full infrared spectrum with high precision.
  3. Lock-in Amplifier (LIA): The LIA acts as an ultra-precise filter. By electrically modulating the device's temperature via Joule heating at a specific frequency, the LIA "locks onto" the modulated signal, effectively ignoring unmodulated background radiation.

This combination achieves a specific detectivity of $8.0 \times 10^{15}$ Jones—roughly $10^6$ times higher than standard commercial detectors.

Analytical Modeling and Optimization

We developed an equivalent thermal circuit model using a lumped capacitance approach to mathematically describe the translation of electrical voltage into temperature changes and subsequent infrared emission. This model allowed for the optimization of several key parameters:

  • DC Bias Synergy: Counterintuitively, adding a steady DC bias to the AC modulation voltage increases the detected signal. Due to the nonlinear relationship in Joule heating ($V^2/R$), an external DC source can boost signal strength without exceeding the power limits of signal generators.
  • Global Heating: While global heating (heating the entire stage) is unmodulated, it enhances the modulated signal because the rate of change in blackbody radiation increases sharply with temperature ($\partial I_{BB}/\partial T$).
  • Waveshape Selection: The analysis demonstrated that using a square wave for modulation instead of a sine wave provides a $4/\pi$ (approximately 1.27x) boost in the output signal.

Experimental Results

The system was evaluated using a custom-fabricated gold nanorod metasurface. The results represent a significant leap over previous state-of-the-art direct-emission measurements:

  • Lower Operating Temperatures: The system generates clear signals at just 125 °C, whereas previous methods required temperatures nearly four times higher. Even at room temperature (25 °C), the system maintained an SNR of 7.9, well above the true-signal threshold of 3.0.
  • High-Speed Dynamics: The system recorded spectral dynamics at frequencies up to 175 kHz. This capability allowed for the extraction of the device's thermal time constant ($R_tC_t = 4.78\ \mu\text{s}$), a vital metric for designing high-speed thermal modulators.

Discussion and Limitations

While the system represents a major advancement, certain bottlenecks remain. The current 175 kHz frequency limit is imposed by the detector's preamplifier; bypassing this could potentially unlock the detector's native bandwidth of ~20 MHz. Additionally, atmospheric interference from water vapor and $CO_2$ reduces SNR in the 3–4 $\mu\text{m}$ and 6–7 $\mu\text{m}$ ranges, suggesting that future iterations should utilize a nitrogen-purged optical path.

Conclusion

The microscopic lock-in FTIR system provides a robust framework for the direct characterization of thermal infrared materials and devices. By significantly lowering the required operating temperature and providing high-speed dynamic resolution, this system is poised to accelerate the development of next-generation technologies in infrared sensing, imaging, and energy harvesting.

Summary updated

Abstract

Accurate direct measurements of far-field thermal infrared emission become increasingly important because conventional methods, relying on indirect assessments, such as reflectance/transmittance, are inaccurate or even unfeasible to characterize state-of-art devices with novel spectra, directionalities, and polarizations. The direct collection of the far-field emission from these tiny devices is also challenging because of their shrinking footprints and uncontrollable radiation noises from their surroundings. Here, we demonstrate a microscopic lock-in FTIR system that realizes significant improvement in signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) by combining a microscope and a lock-in amplifier with an FTIR. The lock-in FTIR is ultrasensitive, with a specific detectivity 10^6 times higher than commercial ones, to overcome the optical loss and background noise during the emission light collection. Based on an analytical model of the signal detection process, we also explore the combination of modulated Joule heating and global heating to fulfill the potential of our system for noise reduction. Our findings show that, compared to previous studies, more than 3 times lower temperatures are sufficient to generate a measurable signal. Under a heating temperature of around 125 °C, we can achieve an SNR of about 23.7, which is far above the true-signal-threshold (SNR of about 3.0). Furthermore, the system can respond fast enough (up to 175kHz) to record spectral-resolved dynamics of microdevices in the frequency domain. The measurable frequency range can be extended up to MHz or even GHz level by a high-speed circuit model. We believe the system together with the analytical signal processing can be beneficial for next-generation thermal infrared material and device exploration, boosting the applications in lighting, sensing, imaging, and energy harvesting on a small scale.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2022accurate,
  author = {Xiu Liu and Hakan Salihoglu and Xiao Luo and Hyeong Seok Yun and Jing Lin and Bowen Yu and Sheng Shen},
  title = {{Accurate Direct Measurements of Far-Field Thermal Infrared Emission and its Dynamics}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2209.00001},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2209.00001},
}
Figure