Accuracy and Precision of Three-Dimensional Low Dose CT Compared to Standard RSA in Acetabular Cups: An Experimental Study

Cyrus Brodén, Henrik Olivecrona, Gerald Q. Maguire, Marilyn E. Noz, Michael P. Zeleznik, Olof SköldenbergBioMed 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces and validates a low-dose 3D CT technique as a potential alternative to the gold-standard Radiostereometric Analysis (RSA) for measuring hip implant migration. The 3D CT method demonstrates comparable precision and acceptable accuracy to RSA, offering a more accessible and potentially faster option for monitoring implant stability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Monitoring the migration of acetabular cups in total hip arthroplasty (THA) is crucial for detecting early signs of implant loosening, which can lead to revision surgery. The current gold standard for this precise measurement is Radiostereometric Analysis (RSA). However, RSA requires specialized stereoradiographic equipment that is not available in all hospitals. This limitation hinders widespread adoption and timely patient monitoring. The paper addresses this gap by investigating whether a three-dimensional computed tomography (3D CT) technique, using low radiation doses, can provide a comparable and more accessible alternative for measuring acetabular cup migration.

Methods

The researchers developed an experimental setup using a plastic pelvic model with implanted cemented and uncemented acetabular cups. These cups were marked with tantalum beads, mimicking the markers used in standard RSA. The model allowed for controlled, incremental translations and rotations of the cups to simulate implant migration.

The core of the study involved comparing measurements obtained from:

  • Standard RSA: Using a uniplanar calibration cage and digital radiographs from two X-ray sources.
  • 3D CT: Employing a clinical CT scanner with a low-dose protocol (120 kVp, 10 mAs).

For each simulated migration step, both RSA and 3D CT examinations were performed twice to assess precision. The 3D CT data underwent a semiautomated image registration process, described as a volume image processing tool, to align paired CT volumes. This process involved manually designating initial landmarks on the tantalum beads, followed by an automated calculation of bead centroids for precise spatial alignment. Accuracy was then determined by comparing the 3D CT measurements against the standard RSA measurements, which were considered the "gold standard."

Datasets

The study utilized an experimental setup with a plastic pelvic model (Sawbones, Vashon, WA, USA) and two types of acetabular cups: a cemented (Müller Exceed™) and an uncemented (T.O.P.®). These were marked with tantalum beads. No patient data or pre-existing datasets were used; the study generated its own experimental data through repeated imaging of the model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Accessibility is Key: The primary motivation is to overcome the accessibility limitations of RSA, making precise implant migration monitoring available to more institutions.
  • Low-Dose CT is Viable: The study demonstrates that a low-dose CT protocol can achieve sufficient resolution and accuracy for this task, making it a safer option for patients.
  • Image Registration is Crucial: The success of the 3D CT method hinges on robust image registration techniques that can accurately align multiple CT scans and identify the precise location of tantalum beads.
  • Marker Occlusion is a Challenge for RSA: Even in this controlled experimental setting, standard RSA faced challenges with marker occlusion, particularly for the uncemented cup, highlighting a practical limitation of the gold standard.
  • Visual Feedback Advantage: The 3D nature of CT data allows for interactive visualization and arbitrary viewing angles, potentially aiding in marker identification and assessment compared to 2D radiographs.

Key Results

  • Precision: The precision of the 3D CT method was comparable to standard RSA.
  • Translations: 3D CT ranged from 0.01 to 0.09 mm; RSA ranged from 0.04 to 0.09 mm.
  • Rotations: 3D CT ranged from 0.06 to 0.29°; RSA ranged from 0.08 to 0.32°.
  • Accuracy: The accuracy of the 3D CT method was acceptable.
  • Translations: Ranged from 0.07 to 0.32 mm.
  • Rotations: Ranged from 0.21 to 0.82°.
  • The accuracy for the uncemented cup was less satisfactory, attributed to fewer visualized markers in standard RSA.
  • Radiation Dose: The effective radiation dose for the 3D CT method was estimated at approximately 0.33 mSv per scan, which is comparable to RSA (estimated at 0.1 mSv).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Model: The study was conducted using a phantom model, not actual patients. The direct measurement of implant migration was not performed; instead, RSA was used as the gold standard.
  • Uncemented Cup Accuracy: The accuracy for the uncemented cup was lower due to marker occlusion issues in the standard RSA comparison.
  • Newness of Method: The 3D CT method is relatively new and not yet widely validated or commercially available as a software solution.
  • User Interaction: The method requires user interaction, which could introduce variability between operators.

The authors suggest that further clinical studies are necessary to validate the 3D CT method in patients before it can be widely adopted as an alternative to RSA. They also highlight the potential for 3D CT to simultaneously evaluate other aspects like osteolysis in clinical cases.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background and Purpose. The gold standard for detection of implant wear and migration is currently radiostereometry (RSA). The purpose of this study is to compare a three-dimensional computed tomography technique (3D CT) to standard RSA as an alternative technique for measuring migration of acetabular cups in total hip arthroplasty. Materials and Methods. With tantalum beads, we marked one cemented and one uncemented cup and mounted these on a similarly marked pelvic model. A comparison was made between 3D CT and standard RSA for measuring migration. Twelve repeated stereoradiographs and CT scans with double examinations in each position and gradual migration of the implants were made. Precision and accuracy of the 3D CT were calculated. Results. The accuracy of the 3D CT ranged between 0.07 and 0.32 mm for translations and 0.21 and 0.82° for rotation. The precision ranged between 0.01 and 0.09 mm for translations and 0.06 and 0.29° for rotations, respectively. For standard RSA, the precision ranged between 0.04 and 0.09 mm for translations and 0.08 and 0.32° for rotations, respectively. There was no significant difference in precision between 3D CT and standard RSA. The effective radiation dose of the 3D CT method, comparable to RSA, was estimated to be 0.33 mSv. Interpretation. Low dose 3D CT is a comparable method to standard RSA in an experimental setting.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{broden2016accuracy,
  author = {Cyrus Brodén and Henrik Olivecrona and Gerald Q. Maguire and Marilyn E. Noz and Michael P. Zeleznik and Olof Sköldenberg},
  title = {{Accuracy and Precision of Three-Dimensional Low Dose CT Compared to Standard RSA in Acetabular Cups: An Experimental Study}},
  booktitle = {BioMed},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1155/2016/5909741},
}
Figure