Accelerating MRI Uncertainty Estimation with Mask-Based Bayesian Neural Network

Fan Hongxiang, Zehuan Zhang, Matej Genci, Hongxiang Fan, Andreas Wetscherek, Wayne Luk

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of accelerating uncertainty estimation in MRI analysis for adaptive radiotherapy. They introduce a novel algorithm-hardware co-design flow that transforms a standard deep neural network (IVIM-NET) into a mask-based Bayesian Neural Network (BayesNN) and implements it on an FPGA accelerator, achieving significant speedups and power reductions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Adaptive radiotherapy, a cutting-edge cancer treatment, relies heavily on accurate MRI analysis to precisely target tumors and minimize damage to healthy tissue. While deep learning models like IVIM-NET have shown promise in improving MRI analysis accuracy and speed, they often lack crucial uncertainty estimation capabilities. This uncertainty information is vital for clinicians to trust predictions and make informed treatment decisions. Existing Bayesian Neural Networks (BayesNNs) can provide this uncertainty but are computationally expensive, hindering real-time applications. Furthermore, conventional BayesNNs introduce randomness that complicates hardware implementation. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a high-performance, hardware-efficient solution for uncertainty estimation in MRI analysis that meets the demands of adaptive radiotherapy.

Methods

The core of this work lies in an algorithm-hardware co-optimization flow.

Algorithm Level: * Masksembles for BayesNN: Instead of traditional BayesNNs that require multiple forward passes and introduce randomness, the authors adopt Masksembles. This approach uses pre-defined, fixed masks to selectively enable or disable neurons/channels. This eliminates runtime randomness, making it more amenable to hardware acceleration. * IVIM-NET to uIVIM-NET Transformation: They propose a specific transformation flow to convert the existing IVIM-NET architecture into a mask-based BayesNN, termed uIVIM-NET. This involves replacing dropout layers with the Masksembles masks. * Synthetic Data Generation: To address the lack of ground truth for uncertainty in real medical data, they generate synthetic datasets by simulating the IVIM physical equation and injecting varying levels of Gaussian noise (controlled by Signal-to-Noise Ratio - SNR). This allows for comprehensive evaluation of uncertainty estimation under different noise conditions.

Hardware Level: * FPGA Accelerator: A custom FPGA accelerator is designed for the uIVIM-NET. * Mask-Zero Skipping: Leveraging the fixed masks from Masksembles, this optimization allows the hardware to skip computations involving zeroed-out weights offline, significantly reducing computation and power. * Batch-Level Scheme: To further reduce power consumption, they introduce a batch-level scheme for weight loading. Instead of reloading weights for each sampling of each voxel (sampling-level scheme), weights for a given sampling are loaded once per batch of voxels, drastically reducing weight loading operations. * Parallelism and Pipelining: The accelerator utilizes input and output parallelism, and fine-grained pipelining within processing units (PUs) to maximize throughput and clock speeds.

Datasets

  • Synthetic Datasets: The paper emphasizes the generation and use of synthetic datasets for training and evaluation. These datasets are created by simulating the IVIM physical equation and injecting Gaussian noise at five different SNR levels (5, 15, 20, 30, and 50). Each dataset contains 10,000 synthetic data points. This approach allows for controlled evaluation of uncertainty estimation and accuracy under varying noise conditions, which is crucial given the absence of ground truth uncertainty in real medical data.
  • Published IVIM Dataset: A published IVIM dataset with 104 b-values is mentioned as being supported by the accelerator, indicating its applicability to real-world data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Masksembles as a Hardware-Friendly BayesNN: The key insight is that by using fixed masks (Masksembles), the inherent randomness of traditional BayesNNs can be eliminated. This makes the model predictable and optimizable for hardware, a significant advantage over methods relying on runtime random number generation.
  • Algorithm-Hardware Co-Design is Crucial: The paper demonstrates the power of a holistic approach. Optimizing the algorithm (Masksembles) directly enables specific hardware optimizations (mask-zero skipping, batch-level scheme), leading to synergistic performance gains.
  • Synthetic Data for Uncertainty Evaluation: The use of synthetically generated data with controlled noise levels is a clever way to rigorously evaluate uncertainty estimation capabilities, a common challenge in medical AI research.
  • Mask-Zero Skipping for Efficiency: The ability to pre-determine and skip zeroed weights offline is a direct consequence of the Masksembles approach and a major contributor to the efficiency gains.

Key Results

  • Speedup: The FPGA accelerator achieves a speedup of 7.5 times compared to GPU implementations and 32.5 times compared to CPU implementations.
  • Power Efficiency: The proposed design offers significant energy cost savings, approximately 34.4x compared to GPU and 82.8x compared to CPU per batch. The accelerator consumes 11.78W of power.
  • Accuracy: The framework successfully converts IVIM-NET to uIVIM-NET, enabling uncertainty estimation while maintaining accuracy. Figures 6 and 7 show that as evaluation SNR increases (less noise), RMSE decreases (higher accuracy) and uncertainty (sigma/mu) also decreases, demonstrating the model's ability to provide more confident predictions on cleaner data.
  • Resource Utilization: With 32 processing elements (PEs), the accelerator consumes 67% of available DSPs.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The paper primarily evaluates on synthetic data, and while it provides valuable insights, direct validation on real medical data with ground truth uncertainty would strengthen the findings.
  • The current design prioritizes input and output parallelism due to resource constraints, meaning sub-network and sample parallelism are handled serially.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest integrating the accelerator into a real-time system for image-guided treatment, which would involve combining it with dose calculation functionalities.
  • They also propose extending the framework to other applications beyond MRI analysis, such as intelligent robots and autonomous driving, where uncertainty estimation is crucial for decision-making in uncertain environments.
  • Further exploration of other mainstream neural networks with this co-design methodology is also envisioned.

Summary updated

Abstract

Accurate and reliable Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) analysis is particularly important for adaptive radiotherapy, a recent medical advance capable of improving cancer diagnosis and treatment. Recent studies have shown that IVIM-NET, a deep neural network (DNN), can achieve high accuracy in MRI analysis, indicating the potential of deep learning to enhance diagnostic capabilities in healthcare. However, IVIM-NET does not provide calibrated uncertainty information needed for reliable and trustworthy predictions in healthcare. Moreover, the expensive computation and memory demands of IVIM-NET reduce hardware performance, hindering widespread adoption in realistic scenarios. To address these challenges, this paper proposes an algorithm-hardware co-optimization flow for high-performance and reliable MRI analysis. At the algorithm level, a transformation design flow is introduced to convert IVIM-NET to a mask-based Bayesian Neural Network (BayesNN), facilitating reliable and efficient uncertainty estimation. At the hardware level, we propose an FPGA-based accelerator with several hardware optimizations, such as mask-zero skipping and operation reordering. Experimental results demonstrate that our co-design approach can satisfy the uncertainty requirements of MRI analysis, while achieving 7.5 times and 32.5 times speedup on an Xilinx VU13P FPGA compared to GPU and CPU implementations with reduced power consumption.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hongxiang2024accelerating,
  author = {Fan Hongxiang and Zehuan Zhang and Matej Genci and Hongxiang Fan and Andreas Wetscherek and Wayne Luk},
  title = {{Accelerating MRI Uncertainty Estimation with Mask-Based Bayesian Neural Network}},
  booktitle = {Asap},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/asap61560.2024.00030},
}
Figure