Abstract: A15 $Nb_3Si$ is, until now, the only 'high' temperature superconductor produced at high pressure (∼110 GPa) that has been successfully brought back to room pressure conditions in a metastable condition. Based on the current great interest in trying to create metastable-at-room-pressure high temperature superconductors produced at high pressure, we have restudied explosively compressed A15 $Nb_3Si$ and its production from tetragonal $Nb_3Si$. First, diamond anvil cell pressure measurements up to 88 GPa were performed on explosively compressed A15 $Nb_3Si$ material to trace $T_c$ as a function of pressure. $T_c$ is suppressed to ∼5.2 K at 88 GPa. Then, using these $T_c(P)$ data for A15 $Nb_3Si$, pressures up to 92 GPa were applied at room temperature (which increased to 120 GPa at 5 K) on tetragonal $Nb_3Si$. Measurements of the resistivity gave no indication of any A15 structure production, i.e. no indications of the superconductivity characteristic of A15 $Nb_3Si$. This is in contrast to the explosive compression (up to $P$ ∼ 110 GPa) of tetragonal $Nb_3Si$, which produced 50%-70% A15 material, $T_c$ = 18 K at ambient pressure, in a 1981 Los Alamos National Laboratory experiment. This implies that the accompanying high temperature (1000 °C) caused by explosive compression is necessary to successfully drive the reaction kinetics of the tetragonal → A15 $Nb_3Si$ structural transformation. Our theoretical calculations show that A15 $Nb_3Si$ has an enthalpy vs the tetragonal structure that is 70 meV atom⁻¹ smaller at 100 GPa, while at ambient pressure the tetragonal phase enthalpy is lower than that of the A15 phase by 90 meV atom⁻¹. The fact that 'annealing' the A15 explosively compressed material at room temperature for 39 years has no effect shows that slow kinetics can stabilize high pressure metastable phases at ambient conditions over long times even for large driving forces of 90 meV atom⁻¹.
Introduction
The search for room-temperature superconductors has recently focused on hydrides, such as lanthanum decahydride, which exhibit superconductivity at extreme pressures exceeding 150 GPa. A significant challenge remains: "quenching" these materials to maintain their superconducting properties at ambient pressure. This paper revisits A15 $Nb_3Si$, the only "high-temperature" superconductor synthesized at megabar pressures that has been successfully recovered in a metastable state at room pressure. By analyzing 40-year-old samples and conducting new high-pressure experiments, researchers demonstrate that high temperature, alongside high pressure, is essential for overcoming kinetic barriers to lock in these elusive states.
Experimental Approach
The study utilized a multi-faceted approach combining historical data with modern high-pressure techniques:
- High-Pressure Measurement: Diamond anvil cells (DAC) were used to apply static pressures up to 120 GPa. Resistivity measurements tracked the superconducting transition temperature ($T_c$) as a function of pressure.
- Historical Analysis: The researchers examined "Recovery 20," a sample of explosively compressed $Nb_3Si$ synthesized in 1981 at Los Alamos National Laboratory and stored for 39 years.
- Annealing and Stability: Samples were heated to temperatures up to 600°C to study the back-transformation from the metastable A15 phase to the stable tetragonal phase.
- Computational Modeling: Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations provided enthalpy-pressure curves to determine the thermodynamic stability of various $Nb_3Si$ phases across a wide pressure range.
Results and Discussion
A primary finding is the steady suppression of $T_c$ in A15 $Nb_3Si$ with increasing pressure. As shown in Figure 1, the transition temperature drops from approximately 18 K at near-ambient pressure to ~5.2 K at 88 GPa. This suppression rate is roughly 0.2 K/GPa, providing a baseline for identifying the A15 phase under extreme conditions.
The study also addressed the synthesis requirements for the A15 phase. While DFT calculations show that the A15 phase becomes thermodynamically more stable than the tetragonal phase above 50 GPa, static compression at room temperature up to 120 GPa failed to produce the A15 structure. Figure 2 illustrates the resistivity behavior during unloading from these high-pressure attempts, showing only low-temperature transitions (likely due to impurities or the tetragonal phase) rather than the characteristic 18 K transition of the A15 phase.
This discrepancy highlights the critical role of kinetics. The 1981 explosive compression provided both ~110 GPa of pressure and ~1000°C of heat, which was sufficient to drive the structural transformation. The 39-year stability of the recovered A15 phase at room temperature further proves that once the kinetic barrier is high enough, a metastable state can be practically permanent, even when it is no longer the lowest-energy state.
Conclusion
The study of A15 $Nb_3Si$ provides a vital lesson for the development of ambient-pressure hydride superconductors. While pressure can make a superconducting phase thermodynamically favorable, high temperatures are often required to overcome kinetic barriers during synthesis. However, the high mobility of hydrogen atoms in hydrides presents a unique challenge compared to the "stuck" niobium and silicon atoms. Future research must identify "chemical anchors" to increase kinetic barriers in hydrides, potentially allowing these record-breaking superconductors to be used in everyday applications.
Summary updated