A witness for coherent electronic vs vibronic-only oscillations in ultrafast spectroscopy

Joel Yuen-Zhou, Jacob J. Krich, Alán Aspuru‐GuzikThe Journal of Chemical Physics 2012 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We report a conceptually straightforward witness that distinguishes coherent electronic oscillations from their vibronic-only counterparts in nonlinear optical spectra of molecular aggregates. Coherent oscillations as a function of waiting time in broadband pump/broadband probe spectra correspond to coherent electronic oscillations in the singly excited manifold. Oscillations in individual peaks of 2D electronic spectra do not necessarily yield this conclusion. Our witness is simpler to implement than quantum process tomography and potentially resolves a long-standing controversy on the character of oscillations in ultrafast spectra of photosynthetic light harvesting systems.

Introduction: The Challenge of Electronic Coherence

In the study of photosynthetic light-harvesting complexes, such as the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) complex, researchers frequently observe rhythmic oscillations, or "beats," in two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy (2D-ES). For over a decade, a central controversy has persisted: are these beats evidence of long-lived electronic coherences—quantum superpositions of excitons that might optimize energy transport—or are they merely vibronic coherences representing the vibrations of the surrounding protein and pigment scaffold?

The ambiguity arises because standard 2D-ES is not uniquely sensitive to electronic states; both electronic and vibrational dynamics can produce similar oscillatory signatures in specific spectral peaks. While advanced techniques like Quantum Process Tomography (QPT) can differentiate between them, they are prohibitively complex to implement. There is a critical need for a "witness"—a straightforward experimental signature that uniquely identifies electronic coherence.

Methods: The Broadband Witness

The proposed witness relies on the theoretical framework of the Condon approximation, where the transition dipole moment is assumed to be independent of nuclear coordinates. By analyzing the system in the broadband limit—where laser pulses are extremely short in time and broad in frequency—the authors derive a new spectroscopic signature.

The core of the method is the total Pump-Probe (PP’) signal, which can be obtained by integrating a 2D-ES spectrum over both frequency axes. Mathematically, in the broadband limit, the PP’ signal becomes a linear combination of elements from the reduced electronic density matrix. This implies that if the integrated signal oscillates, those oscillations must originate from electronic dynamics. The broadband probe effectively "averages out" purely nuclear (vibrational) contributions that would otherwise clutter the signal.

Simulated pump-probe (PP') signals and density matrix elements for monomer, coherent dimer, and incoherent dimer systems.

To validate this, the researchers simulated three distinct systems: a monomer, a coherent dimer (with electronic coupling), and an incoherent dimer. These simulations incorporated realistic experimental factors, including inhomogeneous broadening, thermal averaging, and site disorder.

Key Insights: Why 2D-ES Peaks are Deceptive

A fundamental insight of this work is that oscillations in individual 2D-ES peaks—the current standard for analysis—are "the wrong witness." As shown in the simulations, even a monomer (which lacks electronic coherence by definition) can exhibit strong oscillations in its 2D-ES cross-peaks due to purely vibrational effects. However, its integrated PP' signal remains flat.

2D electronic spectra and cross-peak amplitudes showing deceptive oscillations in the monomer system.

The broadband probe acts as a universal observer. Using a double-slit analogy, the probe opens interference pathways between different excitons. If electronic coherence exists, these pathways interfere and produce oscillations in the total signal. Pure vibrations do not survive this spectral integration, making the PP' signal a robust filter for electronic effects.

Results and Quantitative Protocol

The simulations demonstrate that the witness correctly identifies electronic coherence in the coherent dimer while remaining negative for the monomer and incoherent dimer. To account for finite pulse widths in real experiments, the authors suggest a protocol of collecting data at varying pulse durations and extrapolating to the ideal broadband limit.

Limitations and Future Outlook

The witness's reliance on the impulsive limit requires technically demanding short pulses (10–20 fs). Additionally, if the transition dipole varies significantly with nuclear position (non-Condon effects), the witness may become less clear. In large, spectrally congested complexes, the authors suggest focusing on specific exciton pairs using narrow-band pump pulses combined with broadband probes. The next logical step is applying this witness to experimental data from systems like the FMO complex to finally settle the debate on the nature of their quantum oscillations.

Summary updated

Abstract

We report a conceptually straightforward witness that distinguishes coherent electronic oscillations from their vibronic-only counterparts in nonlinear optical spectra of molecular aggregates. Coherent oscillations as a function of waiting time in broadband pump/broadband probe spectra correspond to coherent electronic oscillations in the singly excited manifold. Oscillations in individual peaks of 2D electronic spectra do not necessarily yield this conclusion. Our witness is simpler to implement than quantum process tomography and potentially resolves a long-standing controversy on the character of oscillations in ultrafast spectra of photosynthetic light harvesting systems.
BibTeX
@article{yuenzhou2012witness,
  author = {Joel Yuen-Zhou and Jacob J. Krich and Alán Aspuru‐Guzik},
  title = {{A witness for coherent electronic vs vibronic-only oscillations in ultrafast spectroscopy}},
  journal = {The Journal of Chemical Physics},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1063/1.4725498},
}
Figure