A weight-adjusted discontinuous Galerkin method for the poroelastic wave equation: Penalty fluxes and micro-heterogeneities

Khemraj Shukla, Jesse Chan, Maarten V. de Hoop, Priyank Jaiswal

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel numerical method, the Weight-Adjusted Discontinuous Galerkin (WADG) method, for simulating wave propagation in porous materials. It addresses the challenge of accurately and efficiently modeling complex material properties and heterogeneities, offering a stable and high-order accurate solution for poroelastic wave phenomena.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Simulating wave propagation in porous media is crucial for various fields like oil and gas exploration, CO2 storage monitoring, and even medical imaging. These simulations are governed by the poroelastic wave equation, which describes the coupled behavior of fluid and solid phases within the porous material. A major challenge in these simulations is accurately capturing the effects of material heterogeneities, especially at sub-element scales (micro-heterogeneities), and ensuring numerical stability and accuracy, particularly for high-order methods. Existing methods often struggle with computational cost, complexity in handling material discontinuities, or limitations in dealing with anisotropic properties. This paper aims to provide a robust and efficient numerical framework that overcomes these limitations.

Methods

The authors propose a Weight-Adjusted Discontinuous Galerkin (WADG) method. Key aspects of their approach include:

  • Energy-Stable Penalty Flux: They derive a novel penalty-based numerical flux that is energy-stable and provides high-order accuracy even across material discontinuities. This flux avoids the computationally expensive diagonalization of Jacobian matrices required by upwind fluxes.
  • Micro-heterogeneity Treatment: The WADG method incorporates sub-element variations in material properties using "weight-adjusted" mass matrices. These approximations are designed to be easily invertible, reducing computational cost and storage requirements compared to exact weighted mass matrices.
  • Symmetric Formulation: The poroelastic wave equations are cast into a symmetric hyperbolic form, which is well-suited for discontinuous Galerkin methods and aids in proving energy stability.
  • High-Order Accuracy: The use of discontinuous Galerkin methods with polynomial basis functions of degree N allows for high-order accuracy, reducing numerical dissipation and dispersion.
  • Unstructured Meshes: The method is developed for unstructured tetrahedral meshes, making it suitable for complex geometries.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors use synthetic material properties from existing literature (e.g., Table 1) and analytical solutions for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Treatment of Heterogeneities: The WADG method's penalty flux is independent of material stiffness tensors, allowing for a unified treatment of both isotropic and anisotropic media, as well as micro-heterogeneities, without needing to re-derive fluxes for different material properties.
  • Efficient Handling of Micro-heterogeneities: The "weight-adjusted" mass matrices offer a computationally efficient way to incorporate sub-element material variations, which is crucial for realistic simulations where material properties are not constant within elements. This is a significant improvement over methods that assume piecewise constant properties.
  • Energy Stability: The development of an energy-stable formulation is critical for ensuring the long-term stability and reliability of numerical simulations, especially for wave propagation problems.
  • High-Order Accuracy on Complex Geometries: The combination of DG with unstructured meshes and high-order polynomials provides a powerful tool for accurate wave simulations in complex geological settings.

Key Results

  • Stability and Accuracy: The WADG method is shown to be energy stable and achieves high-order accuracy, as verified by convergence studies against analytical plane wave solutions. Rates of convergence close to $O(h^{N+1})$ were observed.
  • Comparison with Existing Methods: The numerical results demonstrate good agreement with solutions obtained from spectral element methods and pseudo-spectral methods, validating the proposed WADG approach.
  • Micro-heterogeneity Impact: Simulations highlight the spurious reflections that can arise when micro-heterogeneities are not properly accounted for, underscoring the importance of the WADG method's approach.
  • 3D Simulations: The paper presents successful application of the WADG method to complex 3D problems, including a synthetic reservoir model with undulating topography, showcasing its practical applicability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost for High Orders: While the WADG method is efficient, high-order approximations (large N) and fine meshes can still lead to significant computational demands, especially in 3D.
  • Time Step Restriction: The choice of penalty parameters (ατ, αν) influences the time step restriction, and finding optimal values for complex media can require careful consideration.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest extending the formulation to the broad-band Biot model and to coupled acousto-poroelastic media. Further investigation into efficient techniques for handling constant-coefficient terms at high orders is also mentioned.

Summary updated

Abstract

We introduce a high-order weight-adjusted discontinuous Galerkin (WADG) scheme for the numerical solution of three-dimensional (3D) wave propagation problems in anisotropic porous media. We use a coupled first-order symmetric stress-velocity formulation. Careful attention is directed at (a) the derivation of an energy-stable penalty-based numerical flux, which offers high-order accuracy in presence of material discontinuities, and (b) proper treatment of micro-heterogeneities (sub-element variations) in the numerical scheme. The use of a penalty-based numerical flux avoids the diagonalization of Jacobian matrices into polarized wave constituents necessary when solving element-wise Riemann problems. Micro-heterogeneities are accurately and stably incorporated in the numerical scheme using easily-invertible weight-adjusted mass matrices. The convergence of the proposed numerical scheme is proven and verified by using convergence studies against analytical plane wave solutions. The proposed method is also compared against an existing implementation using the spectral element method to solve the poroelastic wave equation.
BibTeX
@article{shukla2020weight,
  author = {Khemraj Shukla and Jesse Chan and Maarten V. de Hoop and Priyank Jaiswal},
  title = {{A weight-adjusted discontinuous Galerkin method for the poroelastic wave equation: Penalty fluxes and micro-heterogeneities}},
  journal = {Journal of Computational Physics},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=uh_rP5Pq4DU},
}
Figure