A Vision to Enhance Trust Requirements for Peer Support Systems by Revisiting Trust Theories

Yasaman Gheidar, Lysanne Lessard, Yao Yao

Abstract

This vision paper focuses on the mental health crisis impacting healthcare workers (HCWs), which exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic, leads to increased stress and psychological issues like burnout. Peer Support Programs (PSP) are a recognized intervention for mitigating these issues. These programs are increasingly being delivered virtually through Peer Support Systems (PSS) for increased convenience and accessibility. However, HCWs perception of these systems results in fear of information sharing, perceived lack of safety, and low participation rate, which challenges these systems ability to achieve their goals. In line with the rich body of research on the requirements and properties of trustworthy systems, we posit that increasing HCWs trust in PSS could address these challenges. However, extant research focuses on objectively defined trustworthiness rather than perceptual trust because trustworthy requirements are viewed as more controllable and easier to operationalize. This study proposes a novel approach to elicit perceptual trust requirements by proposing a trust framework anchored in recognized trust theories from different disciplines that unpacks trust into its recognized types and their antecedents. This approach allows the identification of trust requirements beyond those already proposed for trustworthy systems, providing a strong foundation for improving the effectiveness of PSS for HCWs.

Introduction

Healthcare workers (HCWs) are currently navigating a global mental health crisis, with burnout rates reaching staggering levels—up to 66% among nurses and physicians. While Peer Support Programs (PSP) have proven effective as interventions, the transition to digital platforms, or Peer Support Systems (PSS), has introduced significant friction. The primary barrier to adoption is not necessarily a lack of technical security, but a lack of perceptual trust.

Even when a system is objectively "trustworthy" (e.g., utilizing robust encryption and maintaining high uptime), HCWs often harbor subjective fears regarding information leaks, social stigma, or professional repercussions. Traditional Requirements Engineering (RE) tends to focus on these objective metrics. This paper addresses the critical gap between technical properties and the subjective "trust" attitude of the user, which is deeply influenced by social dynamics and personal history.

The Integrated Trust Framework

To bridge this gap, the authors propose an Integrated Trust Framework for Digitally-enabled Contexts. This framework synthesizes theories from computer science (system trust), management (organizational trust), and psychology (dispositional trust). It organizes trust into three core constructs: Trust Antecedents, Trust Types, and Trust Outcomes.

Figure 1: The Integrated Trust Framework, illustrating the flow from antecedents to trust types and eventual outcomes.

As shown in Figure 1, the framework posits that various antecedents influence specific types of trust (such as interpersonal or system trust), which in turn drive outcomes like knowledge adoption and continued participation.

Eliciting Requirements from Trust Antecedents

The most innovative aspect of this approach is the use of "trust antecedents" as a primary source for eliciting software requirements. By identifying the factors that lead to trust, designers can create features that directly address user concerns.

The framework categorizes these antecedents into three main groups:

  1. Individual Factors: Including trustor characteristics (propensity to trust) and trustee characteristics (perceived ability/benevolence).
  2. Group Factors: Such as group composition, relationship structure, and climate.
  3. Technology-related Factors: Including structural assurance and human-technology interaction factors like perceived ease of use.
Figure 2: Detailed breakdown of Trust Antecedents, providing a taxonomy for requirements elicitation.

For instance, understanding that "Group Composition" (Figure 2, 2.1.1) is a major antecedent in a healthcare context reveals that nurses may hesitate to share struggles if senior administrators are present. This leads to a specific requirement for hierarchical filtering in group matching algorithms.

Key Insights: Trust vs. Trustworthiness

A central theme of this vision is that trust and trustworthiness are not synonymous. Trustworthiness is an objective property of the system that designers can control. Trust, however, is a subjective attitude held by the user, influenced by their mindset and prior experiences.

By focusing on antecedents like "perceived benevolence" or "social presence," the framework justifies requirements that go beyond standard security:

  • Anonymity via Avatars: Addressing professional stigma by allowing emotional expression without revealing identity.
  • Transparency of Access: Providing explicit "transparency of access rights" so users know exactly who can see their data.
  • Social Presence Features: Incorporating non-verbal feedback (emojis, likes) to foster a sense of "being together," which enhances perceived usefulness in a peer support context.

Conclusion and Future Work

This framework provides a structured methodology for translating abstract trust theories into concrete software requirements. While current work focuses on individual, group, and technology factors, the authors acknowledge that organizational trust (trust in hospital administration) remains a significant, albeit less controllable, factor.

Future efforts will focus on expert validation of the framework, developing functional prototypes with HCW input, and releasing open-source tools—including a requirements elicitation glossary—to the broader research community.

Summary updated

Abstract

This vision paper focuses on the mental health crisis impacting healthcare workers (HCWs), which exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic, leads to increased stress and psychological issues like burnout. Peer Support Programs (PSP) are a recognized intervention for mitigating these issues. These programs are increasingly being delivered virtually through Peer Support Systems (PSS) for increased convenience and accessibility. However, HCWs perception of these systems results in fear of information sharing, perceived lack of safety, and low participation rate, which challenges these systems ability to achieve their goals. In line with the rich body of research on the requirements and properties of trustworthy systems, we posit that increasing HCWs trust in PSS could address these challenges. However, extant research focuses on objectively defined trustworthiness rather than perceptual trust because trustworthy requirements are viewed as more controllable and easier to operationalize. This study proposes a novel approach to elicit perceptual trust requirements by proposing a trust framework anchored in recognized trust theories from different disciplines that unpacks trust into its recognized types and their antecedents. This approach allows the identification of trust requirements beyond those already proposed for trustworthy systems, providing a strong foundation for improving the effectiveness of PSS for HCWs. Keywords: Trust Requirements, Requirements elicitation, Peer support systems, Healthcare workers
BibTeX
@misc{gheidar2024vision,
  author = {Yasaman Gheidar and Lysanne Lessard and Yao Yao},
  title = {{A Vision to Enhance Trust Requirements for Peer Support Systems by Revisiting Trust Theories}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2407.11197},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.11197},
}
Figure