TL;DR
This paper introduces Power Expectation Propagation (Power EP), a novel framework that unifies various Gaussian Process (GP) approximation methods. By performing approximations at "inference time" rather than "modeling time," Power EP resolves philosophical issues and offers a more principled approach to handling the computational intractabilities of GPs, leading to improved performance on regression and classification tasks.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Gaussian Processes (GPs) are powerful tools for probabilistic modeling, offering flexibility and allowing for the encoding of prior knowledge about functions. However, their practical application is hindered by computational and analytical intractabilities, especially with large datasets or non-Gaussian likelihoods. To overcome this, many "sparse" GP approximation schemes have been developed, often by introducing a set of "pseudo data points" to summarize the full dataset. While these methods have been successful, they often involve modifying the generative model itself, leading to philosophical questions about the nature of the approximation and potential empirical issues like overfitting. This paper aims to provide a unifying framework for these pseudo-point approximations that addresses these limitations by focusing on approximate inference rather than modifying the model.
Methods
The core contribution of this paper is the introduction of Power Expectation Propagation (Power EP) as a unifying framework for sparse GP approximations. Unlike previous approaches that often modified the generative model, Power EP focuses on approximate inference. It generalizes Expectation Propagation (EP) by introducing a parameter $\alpha$ that controls the fraction of the likelihood function used in each update step. This allows for a spectrum of approximations, with $\alpha \to 0$ corresponding to Variational Free Energy (VFE) and $\alpha = 1$ corresponding to EP (and FITC in the regression case).
Key aspects of the Power EP framework include:
- Unified Inference: Power EP provides a single algorithmic framework that can recover and generalize existing methods like VFE, EP, FITC, and PITC.
- Inference-Time Approximation: Approximations are performed during the inference process, keeping the original generative model intact. This resolves philosophical concerns about modifying the model and allows for more flexible online learning scenarios.
- Power Parameter ($\alpha$): The parameter $\alpha$ allows for interpolation between VFE and EP, enabling the exploration of intermediate approximation strategies.
- Analytical Solutions for Regression: For Gaussian likelihoods (regression), Power EP yields closed-form analytical solutions for the approximate posterior and marginal likelihood, facilitating hyperparameter optimization.
- Generalization to Classification: While classification with non-Gaussian likelihoods requires iterative updates, the framework is still applicable.
Datasets
The paper evaluates its proposed methods on:
- Synthetic Regression Datasets: Thirty datasets were generated from a GP with an Automatic Relevance Determination squared exponential kernel, each with 1000 data points and five input dimensions.
- Real-world Regression Datasets: Eight UCI regression datasets were used.
- Real-world Classification Datasets: Six UCI classification datasets were used.
The paper also references standard datasets used in prior work for comparison.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Unifying Framework: The most significant insight is the demonstration that Power EP can unify a wide range of existing sparse GP approximation methods (VFE, EP, FITC, PITC) under a single, principled inference framework. This offers a more coherent understanding of these methods.
- Inference-Time vs. Model-Time Approximation: By shifting approximations to the inference stage, the paper provides a more philosophically sound approach that decouples modeling assumptions from computational tractability. This is crucial for online learning and avoiding issues like overfitting associated with modifying the model.
- The Power of Interpolation ($\alpha$): The introduction of the $\alpha$ parameter reveals that intermediate values between VFE and EP often yield superior performance, suggesting that a balance between their respective strengths can be beneficial. This challenges the notion that one extreme is always optimal.
- Pseudo-points as Variational Parameters: The paper emphasizes that pseudo-points are parameters of the approximate posterior, not part of the generative model. This perspective justifies their optimization and allows for more flexible adaptation.
Key Results
- Improved Performance: Experiments show that intermediate values of $\alpha$ (around 0.5) in Power EP often outperform both VFE ($\alpha \to 0$) and EP/FITC ($\alpha = 1$) on both regression and classification tasks, particularly for the SMSE metric in regression.
- Regression: For MSE loss, Power EP with $\alpha = 0.5$ was found to be the best performing approach, outperforming VFE and EP in a significant fraction of experiments. For SMLL, EP generally performed best, with performance monotonically decreasing with $\alpha$.
- Classification: In classification, no single method consistently outperformed others across all metrics. However, Power EP with $\alpha = 0.5$ showed a slight edge over EP for NLL and was comparable to VFE.
- Scalability: The Power EP framework maintains an $O(NM^2)$ complexity for training and $O(M^2)$ for prediction, making it scalable to large datasets.
Limitations and Future Work
- Convergence: While the authors did not observe convergence issues in their experiments, they acknowledge that Power EP is not guaranteed to converge in general.
- Hyperparameter Optimization: The paper notes that while type-II maximum likelihood fitting of hyperparameters can sometimes overfit, pseudo-point approximations might mitigate this. However, they do not believe this was a strong effect in their experiments.
- Inter-domain Transforms and Structured Approximations: The paper suggests extensions to incorporate inter-domain transforms and structured approximations, which could lead to more flexible and powerful models.
- Online Inference and Richer Models: The authors highlight directions for future work such as extensions to online inference, combinations with special structured matrices, Bayesian hyperparameter learning, and applications to richer models.
- Classification Nuances: The paper notes that for classification, analytical solutions are not generally available, and numerical integration (e.g., Gauss-Hermite quadrature) is required, which can introduce approximations. The relationship between Power EP and VFE in classification is also noted to be slightly different due to implementation details.
Summary updated