A Thought Experiment on Sustainable Management of the Earth System

Jobst Heitzig, Wolfram Barfuß, Jonathan F. Donges

TL;DR

This paper presents a simplified thought experiment to explore the ethical dilemma of intergenerational choices regarding climate change and sustainability. It reveals that different ethical frameworks (rationality, responsibility, sustainability paradigms) lead to conflicting recommendations, highlighting the crucial role of normative choices in policy decisions for global challenges.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Humanity faces a critical decision point regarding its impact on the Earth system, particularly concerning climate change. This decision involves choosing between immediate actions that might cause temporary suffering but secure long-term high well-being for future generations, versus maintaining the status quo with a persistent risk of catastrophic collapse. The authors aim to analyze this dilemma by exploring how different ethical perspectives and decision-making frameworks would approach this choice, and to understand why there isn't a single, universally agreed-upon "right" answer. They are particularly interested in the implications for achieving goals like the UN Sustainable Development Goals.

Methods

The core of the paper is a simplified formal thought experiment (TE) representing the intergenerational decision dilemma. This TE involves a sequence of generations, each facing a choice between two options:

  • Option A (Default): Continue on a path with a high probability of maintaining current high welfare, but with a non-zero chance of transitioning to a degraded state ("collapse").
  • Option B (Transformation): Sacrifice the welfare of one generation to ensure a high welfare state with minimal risk for all subsequent generations.

The authors then analyze this TE using various ethical and decision-making frameworks:

  • Rationality-based frameworks: Optimal control theory, welfare economics (including time preferences, inequality aversion, risk aversion), and game theory.
  • Other approaches: Notions of responsibility, safe operating spaces (SOS), and sustainability paradigms (standardization, optimization, pessimization, equitization, stabilization).

They also employ a verbal narrative (an island tribe analogy) to make the TE more accessible.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • No Single "Right" Answer: The most striking insight is the profound diversity of recommendations arising from different ethical frameworks. What is considered optimal under one framework can be suboptimal or even undesirable under another.
  • Long-Term vs. Equality Trade-off: A clear tension emerges between prioritizing long-term future well-being (favoring immediate sacrifice for future security) and intergenerational equality (favoring a more even distribution of welfare and risk across generations).
  • The Power of Normative Frameworks: The choice of normative framework (e.g., how to weigh future generations' welfare, how to account for risk and inequality) fundamentally shapes the policy recommendations. This implies that policy measures for sustainability are not purely technical but deeply normative.
  • Time Inconsistency and Probabilistic Policies: Even within seemingly rational frameworks, recommendations can lead to time-inconsistent policies (e.g., delaying a decision repeatedly) or require probabilistic choices, making practical implementation challenging.
  • Responsibility and "Worst-Case" Thinking: The concept of responsibility, particularly forward-looking responsibility, can lead to a "worst-case" approach, suggesting the choice that avoids the most catastrophic outcome, even if it involves immediate suffering.
  • Safe Operating Space (SOS) Ambiguity: Applying the SOS concept to the TE reveals that its utility depends heavily on how the "safe" states are defined and whether the current state is considered within the SOS. If the current state is already risky, the SOS concept might not offer clear guidance.

Key Results

  • Rationality Frameworks:
    • Long time horizons and risk aversion generally favor Option B (immediate sacrifice for long-term security).
  • Short time horizons and risk-seeking tend to favor Option A (maintaining current welfare with some risk).
  • Inequality aversion can lead to complex outcomes, sometimes favoring delayed choices or probabilistic policies, and can even result in time-inconsistent recommendations.
  • Game Theory: The multi-agent perspective reveals the possibility of multiple strategic equilibria, making it difficult to predict future generations' behavior and thus to make a definitive choice.
  • Responsibility Framework: A theory of responsibility that avoids diffusion of responsibility suggests that choosing Option B is the responsible action to avoid the worst-case scenario.
  • Sustainability Paradigms:
    • Pessimization strongly favors Option B ("avoiding the worst").
  • Equitization (fairness across generations) can favor Option A, as it preserves options for future generations, though this might come at the cost of increased risk.
  • Stabilization clearly favors Option B to reach a sustainable high-welfare state.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplification of the TE: The authors acknowledge that the TE is a radical simplification of reality, omitting aspects like overlapping generations, finer distinctions in states/options/welfare, multiple decision-makers, and explicit time dependencies. They suggest that adding these could make the model more "realistic" but might also obscure the core dilemma.
  • Probabilistic Uncertainties and Lock-ins: The TE's strong uncertainties and irreversible lock-in effects (once in state T or S, no return) are crucial but might be criticized as unrealistic. Future work could explore the impact of introducing small probabilities of returning to state L, exogenous/endogenous changes in welfare definitions, or status effects.
  • Intermediate Suffering: The paper notes that discussing intermediate suffering is somewhat unpopular in sustainability discourse, yet it is a key trade-off in the TE. Further debate on handling this trade-off is needed.
  • Finding a Convincing Ethical Principle: The authors conclude that despite exploring various frameworks, a single, convincing basic ethical principle that offers a clear recommendation and can be accepted as overriding all others remains elusive. Future research could focus on identifying such principles or exploring modifications to the TE that might yield clearer answers.

Summary updated

Abstract

We introduce and analyze a simple formal thought experiment designed to reflect a qualitative decision dilemma humanity might currently face in view of anthropogenic climate change. In this exercise, each generation can choose between two options, either setting humanity on a pathway to certain high wellbeing after one generation of suffering, or leaving the next generation in the same state as the current one with the same options, but facing a continuous risk of permanent collapse. We analyze this abstract setup regarding the question of what the right choice would be both in a rationality-based framework including optimal control, welfare economics, and game theory, and by means of other approaches based on the notions of responsibility, safe operating spaces, and sustainability paradigms. Across these different approaches, we confirm the intuition that a focus on the long-term future makes the first option more attractive while a focus on equality across generations favors the second. Despite this, we generally find a large diversity and disagreement of assessments both between and within these different approaches, suggesting a strong dependence on the choice of the normative framework used. This implies that policy measures selected to achieve targets such as the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals can depend strongly on the normative framework applied and specific care needs to be taken with regard to the choice of such frameworks.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{heitzig2018thought,
  author = {Jobst Heitzig and Wolfram Barfuß and Jonathan F. Donges},
  title = {{A Thought Experiment on Sustainable Management of the Earth System}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/su10061947},
}
Figure