A Task-Driven Feedback Imager with Uncertainty Driven Hybrid Control

Burhan Ahmad Mudassar, Priyabrata Saha, Marilyn Wolf, Saibal Mukhopadhyay

TL;DR

This paper introduces an "uncertainty-driven hybrid control" system for active imagers, enhancing object detection and tracking by leveraging deep neural network (DNN) uncertainty alongside confidence scores. This approach allows the imager to intelligently focus its sensing resources, leading to improved accuracy and reduced false negatives, especially in challenging conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern active sensor systems often incorporate deep neural networks (DNNs) for tasks like object detection and tracking. However, DNNs are known to produce "overconfident" or uncalibrated outputs, meaning their confidence scores don't always accurately reflect their true reliability. This is problematic for feedback control systems that rely on these scores to decide where and how to sense. For instance, a low-confidence detection might be discarded, even if it's actually a critical object with high uncertainty, leading to missed detections (false negatives). Conversely, high-confidence but incorrect detections (false positives) can waste sensing resources. This paper addresses the challenge of making feedback control more robust and reliable by incorporating DNN uncertainty estimation into the decision-making process.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of an "uncertainty-driven hybrid control" system. The authors first characterize the uncertainty of DNN outputs using both sampling-based (e.g., MC Dropout) and non-sampling-based methods. They then propose a feedback control loop that uses this uncertainty information, in addition to the standard confidence score, to select Regions of Interest (ROIs) for further sensing.

The paper explores three control strategies:

  • Uncertainty-False Positive (Uncertainty-FP): Removes detections with low uncertainty and high confidence, aiming to filter out potentially incorrect high-confidence predictions.
  • Uncertainty-False Negative (Uncertainty-FN): Identifies detections with high uncertainty and low confidence, flagging them as potentially missed objects that require further attention.
  • Uncertainty-Hybrid: Combines the above two strategies to balance the removal of false positives and false negatives.

A novel aspect is the separation of spatial and temporal uncertainty, particularly for action detection tasks. This allows for a more nuanced understanding of where the uncertainty originates (e.g., from image features or temporal dynamics) and enables more targeted control.

Datasets

The study utilizes the following datasets:

  • CAMEL Dataset: A multi-modal dataset containing registered RGB-IR video sequences with annotations for pedestrians and cars. It features challenging lighting and occlusion conditions, making it suitable for evaluating object detection and tracking.
  • UCF101-24 Dataset: A widely used dataset for action detection, containing video clips of human actions.
  • MOVE Dataset: Another dataset for action detection, characterized by significant camera motion and off-center actors, posing a greater challenge.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Uncertainty as a Proxy for Reliability: The paper demonstrates that DNN uncertainty is strongly correlated with detection accuracy. In the absence of ground truth, uncertainty can serve as a valuable indicator of how reliable a detection is.
  • Beyond Confidence Scores: Relying solely on confidence scores for feedback control is insufficient and can lead to both false positives and false negatives. Incorporating uncertainty provides a more nuanced decision-making criterion.
  • Targeted Sensing: By understanding uncertainty, the imager can intelligently allocate its sensing resources. For example, high uncertainty in a low-confidence detection can prompt the system to maintain or switch sensing modalities (like IR) to improve detection.
  • Spatial vs. Temporal Uncertainty: For tasks like action detection, separating spatial and temporal uncertainty is crucial. This allows for a deeper understanding of the sources of error and can lead to more efficient control strategies, potentially achieving similar accuracy with reduced computational cost.
  • Hybrid Control is Key: The hybrid approach, which balances the removal of false positives and false negatives using uncertainty, yields the best overall performance.

Key Results

  • Object Detection and Tracking (CAMEL Dataset): The uncertainty-driven hybrid control improved Average Precision (AP) by 1.1% and Multiple Object Tracking Accuracy (MOTA) by 1.1% compared to a mixed-modality baseline. It also significantly reduced false negatives (FN) from 17,307 to 16,816.
  • Action Detection (UCF Sports Dataset): The hybrid approach improved frame mAP by 1.4% and reduced false negatives by 18.
  • Computational Efficiency: By separating spatial and temporal uncertainty, the system can achieve comparable accuracy metrics with a fraction of the computational cost (e.g., fewer Monte Carlo trials).
  • Robustness to Noise: Increasing noise levels in input images led to decreased accuracy (mAP) and increased uncertainty, highlighting the system's ability to adapt to degraded sensor data.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: The current method for obtaining uncertainty estimates is computationally expensive, requiring multiple inference passes (e.g., 40 Monte Carlo trials per image).
  • Tunable Thresholds: The thresholds used for determining ROIs based on score and uncertainty may not adapt well to changing input distributions. Future work could involve making these thresholds tunable based on error signals.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors suggest exploring methods for reducing compute complexity, such as distillation for smaller networks or one-pass uncertainty estimation. Investigating non-parametric models for trust scores and developing more adaptive thresholding mechanisms are also promising avenues.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{mudassar2021task,
  author = {Burhan Ahmad Mudassar and Priyabrata Saha and Marilyn Wolf and Saibal Mukhopadhyay},
  title = {{A Task-Driven Feedback Imager with Uncertainty Driven Hybrid Control}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=yjXDd6sG2Nu},
}
Figure