A Systematic Review of Bio-Cyber Interface Technologies and Security Issues for Internet of Bio-Nano Things

Sidra Zafar, Mohsin Nazir, Taimur Bakhshi, Hasan Ali Khattak, Sarmadullah Khan, Muhammad Bilal, Kim-Kwang Raymond Choo, Kyung-Sup Kwak, Aneeqa Sabah

Abstract

Advances in synthetic biology and nanotechnology have contributed to the design of tools that can be used to control, reuse, modify, and re-engineer cells' structure, as well as enabling engineers to effectively use biological cells as programmable substrates to realize Bio-Nano Things (biological embedded computing devices). Bio-NanoThings are generally tiny, non-intrusive, and concealable devices that can be used for in-vivo applications such as intra-body sensing and actuation networks, where the use of artificial devices can be detrimental. Such (nano-scale) devices can be used in various healthcare settings such as continuous health monitoring, targeted drug delivery, and nano-surgeries. These services can also be grouped to form a collaborative network (i.e., nanonetwork), whose performance can potentially be improved when connected to higher bandwidth external networks such as the Internet. However, to realize the IoBNT paradigm, it is also important to seamlessly connect the biological environment with the technological landscape by having a dynamic interface design to convert biochemical signals from the human body into an equivalent electromagnetic signal (and vice versa). This paper comprehensively reviews bio-cyber interface for IoBNT architecture, focusing on bio-cyber interfacing options like biologically inspired bio-electronic devices, RFID enabled implantable chips, and electronic tattoos. This study also identifies known and potential security and privacy vulnerabilities and mitigation strategies for consideration in future IoBNT designs and implementations.

Introduction: The Language Gap

Biological systems and digital systems speak fundamentally different languages. Biology operates through chemical concentrations and molecular signals, while the cyber world relies on electromagnetic waves and binary code. The Internet of Bio-Nano Things (IoBNT) aims to bridge this gap, creating a "translator" known as the bio-cyber interface. This interface is essential for realizing the vision of real-time health monitoring, targeted drug delivery, and nano-surgeries.

However, this bridge introduces a massive new attack surface. If a device can trigger a biological response based on a remote command, a security breach is no longer just a data leak; it is a direct threat to the patient's life. This paper provides a unified framework for understanding these interface technologies and the specific security vulnerabilities they introduce.

Taxonomy of Interfacing Technologies

The systematic review categorizes the bio-cyber interface into three primary technological domains: Electronic Tattoos, RFID-based sensors, and Biologically Inspired interfaces.

Taxonomy and scope of the systematic review on IoBNT components and security.
  1. Electronic Tattoos and Transdermal Patches: These are flexible, skin-mounted sensors that monitor sweat glands or epidermal information, transmitting data via Bluetooth or NFC.
  2. RFID-based Sensors: These passive, battery-less chips can be embedded in the body to sense parameters like glucose or temperature, powered by an external reader.
  3. BioFETs (Biologically Sensitive Field-Effect Transistors): These highly sensitive devices use biological receptors on a transistor gate to detect specific molecules (like proteins or DNA), immediately converting binding events into electrical signals.

The interface must manage a "Two-Way Gate": Electro-bio conversion (digital commands to chemical releases) and Bio-electro conversion (chemical concentrations to digital data).

Security Modeling and Bio-Cyber Terrorism

Applying the STRIDE threat model (Spoofing, Tampering, Repudiation, Information Disclosure, Denial of Service, and Elevation of Privilege) to the IoBNT context reveals unique vulnerabilities. The authors warn of "Bio-Cyber Terrorism," where attackers could manipulate human body functionality or exfiltrate private biological data remotely.

Specific attack vectors include:

  • Blackhole Attacks: Malicious nodes that drop all molecular signals, disrupting communication.
  • Sentry Attacks: Malicious nodes that repel legitimate messenger molecules, preventing them from reaching their destination.

A significant "Power Paradox" exists: devices must be tiny and non-intrusive, limiting battery life and computational power. This renders traditional cryptographic standards like RSA impossible, necessitating the development of "lightweight" security solutions. One novel approach is "Bio-inspired Security," using biological principles—like the human immune system—as a model for detecting malicious signals within a nanonetwork.

Limitations and Future Directions

Despite the promise of IoBNT, several hurdles remain:

  • Theory vs. Reality: Much current research is confined to "wet lab" simulations; in-vivo testing is the next major challenge.
  • Biocompatibility and Biofouling: The body’s immune system may identify the interface as a foreign object, leading to "biofouling" (plaque buildup) that blinds sensors.
  • Standardization: The lack of a unified protocol stack for IoBNT complicates the development of universal security frameworks.

Conclusion

The IoBNT represents a paradigm shift in healthcare, but its success depends on the secure and seamless integration of biological and cyber systems. By identifying current interface technologies and their inherent risks, this review sets the stage for future designs that prioritize both medical efficacy and patient safety.

Summary updated

Abstract

Advances in synthetic biology and nanotechnology have contributed to the design of tools that can be used to control, reuse, modify, and re-engineer cells' structure, as well as enabling engineers to effectively use biological cells as programmable substrates to realize Bio-Nano Things (biological embedded computing devices). Bio-NanoThings are generally tiny, non-intrusive, and concealable devices that can be used for in-vivo applications such as intra-body sensing and actuation networks, where the use of artificial devices can be detrimental. Such (nano-scale) devices can be used in various healthcare settings such as continuous health monitoring, targeted drug delivery, and nano-surgeries. These services can also be grouped to form a collaborative network (i.e., nanonetwork), whose performance can potentially be improved when connected to higher bandwidth external networks such as the Internet, say via 5G. However, to realize the IoBNT paradigm, it is also important to seamlessly connect the biological environment with the technological landscape by having a dynamic interface design to convert biochemical signals from the human body into an equivalent electromagnetic signal (and vice versa). This, unfortunately, risks the exposure of internal biological mechanisms to cyber-based sensing and medical actuation, with potential security and privacy implications. This paper comprehensively reviews bio-cyber interface for IoBNT architecture, focusing on bio-cyber interfacing options for IoBNT like biologically inspired bio-electronic devices, RFID enabled implantable chips, and electronic tattoos. This study also identifies known and potential security and privacy vulnerabilities and mitigation strategies for consideration in future IoBNT designs and implementations.
BibTeX
@article{zafar2021systematic,
  author = {Sidra Zafar and Mohsin Nazir and Taimur Bakhshi and Hasan Ali Khattak and Sarmadullah Khan and Muhammad Bilal and Kim-Kwang Raymond Choo and Kyung-Sup Kwak and Aneeqa Sabah},
  title = {{A Systematic Review of Bio-Cyber Interface Technologies and Security Issues for Internet of Bio-Nano Things}},
  journal = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2021.3093442},
}
Figure