Context-aware Computing in the Internet of Things: A Survey on Internet of Things From Industrial Market Perspective

Charith Perera, Chi Harold Liu, Srimal Jayawardena, Min Chen

Abstract

The Internet of Things (IoT) is a dynamic global information network consisting of Internet-connected objects, such as RFIDs, sensors, and actuators, as well as other instruments and smart appliances that are becoming an integral component of the Internet. Over the last few years, we have seen a plethora of IoT solutions making their way into the industry marketplace. Context-aware communication and computing has played a critical role throughout the last few years of ubiquitous computing and is expected to play a significant role in the IoT paradigm as well. In this article, we examine a variety of popular and innovative IoT solutions in terms of context-aware technology perspectives. More importantly, we evaluate these IoT solutions using a framework that we built around well-known context-aware computing theories. This survey is intended to serve as a guideline and a conceptual framework for context-aware product development and research in the IoT paradigm. It also provides a systematic exploration of existing IoT products in the marketplace and highlights a number of potentially significant research directions and trends.

Introduction

The Internet of Things (IoT) envisions a world where everyday objects are interconnected, enabling them to act intelligently based on their environment. This intelligence hinges on context-aware computing—the capacity to gather data regarding the "who, what, where, when, and why" of a situation to adapt behavior accordingly.

While academic research has long explored these concepts through prototypes, the commercial sector has rapidly outpaced lab environments, saturating the market with wearables, smart home devices, and industrial sensors. This survey addresses the gap in understanding how these commercial solutions actually implement context-aware technologies, identifying standard features and areas where industry practice diverges from theoretical ideals.

The rapid growth of internet-connected devices per person highlights the increasing scale of the IoT ecosystem.

Methodology and Taxonomy

To systematically analyze the commercial landscape, this study develops an evaluation framework rooted in classic context-aware computing theories. By modernizing Abowd et al.'s foundational definitions—specifically focusing on presentation, execution, and tagging—the authors established a 9-feature taxonomy to categorize over 100 commercial products.

The theoretical framework for context-aware computing, categorizing features into presentation, automatic execution, and tagging.

The taxonomy evaluates products based on:

  1. Primary Context: Raw sensor inputs (e.g., GPS, temperature).
  2. Secondary Context: Derived high-level insights (e.g., "user is sleeping").
  3. Visual Presentation: Data visualization methods.
  4. Presentation Channels: Delivery platforms (mobile, web, etc.).
  5. User Interaction: Input modalities (touch, voice, gesture).
  6. Processing: Real-time vs. archival analysis.
  7. Reaction Mechanism: The nature of the device's response (notification vs. actuation).
  8. Learning Ability: Reliance on Machine Learning (ML) vs. User-Defined (UD) rules.
  9. Notification Triggers: Temporal, spatial, or event-based conditions.

Key Insights from the Commercial Market

The survey revealed several critical trends and challenges within the current IoT marketplace:

  • The Notification Bottleneck: A major finding is that most commercial IoT products stop at notification (pinging a user's phone) rather than taking autonomous actuation (physically doing something about it). This is largely due to a lack of machine-to-machine (M2M) communication standards.
  • Data Reuse is King: The exact same primary context (e.g., 3-axis accelerometer data) is used to derive vastly different secondary contexts depending on the domain. In a Fitbit, it measures steps; in a Mimo baby monitor, it measures sleep respiration; in a ShockBox helmet, it measures concussion impact force.
  • The "Family" Problem: Most smart home devices treat a household as a single, monolithic entity. They fail to distinguish between individual users (e.g., a father vs. a child), meaning they cannot personalize context-aware actions to individual preferences in a shared space.
  • Legacy Hacks as a Bridge: The authors highlight clever products that add smarts to "dumb" legacy devices rather than replacing them. For example, the Leeo device simply listens for the specific audio frequency of a standard, non-smart smoke alarm and sends a push notification if it hears it.
  • Walled Gardens: To handle the heavy computational lifting that tiny sensors cannot do, the industry relies heavily on "Central Hubs" (like the SmartThings Hub). However, manufacturers build proprietary stacks for these hubs, severely crippling interoperability between different brands.

Results and Current State of the Art

The evaluation highlights that despite the potential for advanced interaction, most IoT products remain "screen-bound," relying heavily on traditional mobile and web interfaces. Furthermore, true predictive learning remains rare; the majority of devices rely on simple User-Defined "IF-THEN" rules rather than sophisticated machine learning. To bridge the interoperability gap, consumers often turn to third-party services like IFTTT (If This Then That) to connect disparate product ecosystems.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The IoT landscape is evolving rapidly, but several hurdles remain. Future research and development should focus on:

  • Deployment Planning Tools: Creating software to help optimize sensor placement in large-scale environments.
  • Standardized Interoperability: Moving away from proprietary hubs toward open standards (like the AllSeen Alliance/AllJoyn mentioned in the text).
  • Firmware-Level Privacy: Embedding privacy controls directly into device hardware to give users better control over their data.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Internet of Things (IoT) is a dynamic global information network consisting of Internet-connected objects, such as RFIDs, sensors, and actuators, as well as other instruments and smart appliances that are becoming an integral component of the Internet. Over the last few years, we have seen a plethora of IoT solutions making their way into the industry marketplace. Context-aware communication and computing has played a critical role throughout the last few years of ubiquitous computing and is expected to play a significant role in the IoT paradigm as well. In this article, we examine a variety of popular and innovative IoT solutions in terms of context-aware technology perspectives. More importantly, we evaluate these IoT solutions using a framework that we built around well-known context-aware computing theories. This survey is intended to serve as a guideline and a conceptual framework for contextaware product development and research in the IoT paradigm. It also provides a systematic exploration of existing IoT products in the marketplace and highlights a number of potentially significant research directions and trends.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{perera2014context,
  author = {Charith Perera and Chi Harold Liu and Srimal Jayawardena and Min Chen},
  title = {{Context-aware Computing in the Internet of Things: A Survey on Internet of Things From Industrial Market Perspective}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2014},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=nbtUCFe4LD8r},
}
Figure