A Survey and Taxonomy of Urban Traffic Management: Towards Vehicular Networks

Hany Kamal, Marco Picone, Michele Amoretti

Abstract

Urban Traffic Management (UTM) topics have been tackled since long time, mainly by civil engineers and by city planners. The introduction of new communication technologies - such as cellular systems, satellite positioning systems and inter-vehicle communications - has significantly changed the way researchers deal with UTM issues. In this survey, we provide a review and a classification of how UTM has been addressed in the literature. We start from the recent achievements of "classical" approaches to urban traffic estimation and optimization, including methods based on the analysis of data collected by fixed sensors (e.g., cameras and radars), as well as methods based on information provided by mobile phones, such as Floating Car Data (FCD). Afterwards, we discuss urban traffic optimization, presenting the most recent works on traffic signal control and vehicle routing control. Then, after recalling the main concepts of Vehicular Ad-Hoc Networks (VANETs), we classify the different VANET-based approaches to UTM, according to three categories ("pure" VANETs, hybrid vehicular-sensor networks and hybrid vehicular-cellular networks), while illustrating the major research issues for each of them. The main objective of this survey is to provide a comprehensive view on UTM to researchers with focus on VANETs, in order to pave the way for the design and development of novel techniques for mitigating urban traffic problems, based on inter-vehicle communications.

Introduction

Urban traffic congestion is a global economic and environmental crisis. In 2011, congestion cost the U.S. economy $121 billion in wasted time and fuel. Beyond economics, the transportation sector is a primary source of greenhouse gas emissions; vehicles in stop-and-go traffic emit significantly more CO2 than those at steady speeds. Traditionally a civil engineering domain, Urban Traffic Management (UTM) has evolved into a data and communication challenge. This paper provides a structured roadmap for this evolution, bridging the gap between classical methods and modern Information and Communication Technology (ICT), specifically Vehicular Ad-Hoc Networks (VANETs).

Taxonomy of Urban Traffic Management

The core of UTM is divided into two main pillars: Estimation and Optimization. Estimation focuses on collecting and interpreting data to understand the current state of traffic, while Optimization uses this data to improve flow and reduce congestion.

Taxonomy of Urban Traffic Management

Urban Traffic Estimation (UTE)

Estimation methods have transitioned from purely physical sensors to data-driven analytical models and mobile-sourced data.

  • Fixed Sensors: Traditional infrastructure like loop detectors, radars, and CCTV.
  • Mobile/GPS Data: Leveraging cellular signaling and Floating Car Data (FCD) from GPS-equipped "probe" vehicles.
  • Analytical Models: These models are categorized by their level of detail, ranging from individual vehicle dynamics to aggregate traffic flow.
Taxonomy of Analytical Models for Urban Traffic Estimation

As shown in Figure 2, analytical models are classified into Microscopic (modeling individual vehicle dynamics using Graph Theory), Macroscopic (treating traffic as a fluid using Computational Fluid Dynamics or Neural Networks), and Mesoscopic models which act as a hybrid, utilizing tools like Queueing Theory and Petri Nets.

Urban Traffic Optimization (UTO)

Optimization focuses on two primary control mechanisms:

  1. Traffic Signal Control: Shifting from fixed-time cycles to adaptive, decentralized systems that respond to real-time demand.
  2. Vehicle Routing Control: Implementing algorithms for individual navigation (e.g., Dijkstra) and complex fleet management.

The Role of Vehicular Ad-Hoc Networks (VANETs)

VANETs represent the next frontier in UTM, where vehicles act as nodes communicating via On-Board Units (OBUs). This enables Vehicle-to-Vehicle (V2V) and Vehicle-to-Infrastructure (V2I) communication. The paper classifies VANET-based UTM into three architectures: "Pure" VANETs, Hybrid Vehicular-Sensor Networks (VANET+WSN), and Hybrid Vehicular-Cellular Networks (VANET+3G/LTE).

Key Insights and Results

  • Hybridization: Combining mobile phone data with high-precision GPS provides the most accurate traffic state estimation.
  • Decentralization: VANETs allow for "edge" processing, enabling rapid local propagation of incident reports faster than centralized Traffic Management Centers (TMC).
  • Environmental Impact: Optimizing flow to maintain speeds around 60 km/h can reduce carbon emissions by up to 40% compared to congested 20 km/h traffic.
  • Performance: Studies show that Neural Networks can forecast traffic flow with errors below 13%, while SVM-based algorithms in VANET nodes can achieve a 100% accident detection rate in simulations.

Limitations and Future Directions

Despite the potential, several hurdles remain. High-accuracy models like Bayesian networks can be computationally expensive for large urban grids. Additionally, collecting trajectory data raises significant privacy concerns, necessitating solutions like P2P overlays. Finally, VANETs require a critical mass of equipped vehicles to be effective, making hybrid models essential in the interim until full deployment is reached.

Summary updated

Abstract

Urban Traffic Management (UTM) topics have been tackled since long time, mainly by civil engineers and by city planners. The introduction of new communication technologies - such as cellular systems, satellite positioning systems and inter-vehicle communications - has significantly changed the way researchers deal with UTM issues. In this survey, we provide a review and a classification of how UTM has been addressed in the literature. We start from the recent achievements of "classical" approaches to urban traffic estimation and optimization, including methods based on the analysis of data collected by fixed sensors (e.g., cameras and radars), as well as methods based on information provided by mobile phones, such as Floating Car Data (FCD). Afterwards, we discuss urban traffic optimization, presenting the most recent works on traffic signal control and vehicle routing control. Then, after recalling the main concepts of Vehicular Ad-Hoc Networks (VANETs), we classify the different VANET-based approaches to UTM, according to three categories ("pure" VANETs, hybrid vehicular-sensor networks and hybrid vehicular-cellular networks), while illustrating the major research issues for each of them. The main objective of this survey is to provide a comprehensive view on UTM to researchers with focus on VANETs, in order to pave the way for the design and development of novel techniques for mitigating urban traffic problems, based on inter-vehicle communications.
BibTeX
@misc{kamal2014survey,
  author = {Hany Kamal and Marco Picone and Michele Amoretti},
  title = {{A Survey and Taxonomy of Urban Traffic Management: Towards Vehicular Networks}},
  year = {2014},
  eprint = {1409.4388},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1409.4388},
}
Figure