A subsystems approach for parameter estimation of ODE models of hybrid systems

Anastasis Georgoulas, Allan Clark, Andrea Ocone, Stephen Gilmore, Guido Sanguinetti

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "subsystems" approach to tackle the computationally intensive problem of parameter estimation in complex ordinary differential equation (ODE) models. By breaking down large systems into smaller, weakly coupled modules, the method significantly speeds up computation and allows for parallel processing, making it more feasible to analyze intricate biological systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Parameter estimation for ODE models, particularly in fields like systems biology, is a notoriously difficult problem. As the number of parameters in a model increases, the computational cost of finding the optimal parameter values that best fit experimental data grows exponentially. This "curse of dimensionality" often leads to algorithms failing to converge, making it challenging to build accurate predictive models. Existing methods struggle with high-dimensional parameter spaces and situations where multiple parameter sets can produce similar model outputs, especially in the presence of noisy data.

Methods

The core of this paper is a subsystems approach to parameter estimation. Instead of treating a large ODE system as a single monolithic problem, it's decomposed into smaller, interconnected "subsystems." Each subsystem is associated with a subset of species (or variables) in the original model.

Here's how it works:

  • Decomposition: The system is broken down into N subsystems, each focusing on a single species.
  • Inputs: The inputs to each subsystem are not direct measurements but rather Gaussian Process (GP) interpolations of the time-series data for other species that influence the subsystem's species. GPs are powerful non-parametric tools for interpolating noisy data and can provide a smoothed, denser representation of the system's behavior.
  • Independent Estimation: Parameter estimation for each subsystem is then performed independently using Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC). This is possible because the GP interpolation effectively creates a form of conditional independence, allowing each subsystem to be treated as a separate problem.
  • Iterative Refinement: The estimated time-series from each subsystem are then fed back as inputs to other subsystems, and the process is repeated iteratively until the results stabilize.

This approach leverages the strengths of GPs for data handling and MCMC for robust parameter inference, while crucially addressing the computational bottleneck by enabling parallelization.

Datasets

The paper evaluates its method on two benchmark systems:

  • Signalling Cascade Model: A model with five species, adapted from a previous study.
  • Gene Regulatory Network Model: A model from the DREAM6 parameter estimation challenge, involving seven species (proteins and mRNA).

The authors do not introduce new datasets but use these existing benchmarks to compare their method against state-of-the-art approaches.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decomposition as a Computational Accelerator: The most significant insight is that breaking down a complex ODE system into smaller, weakly coupled subsystems dramatically reduces the computational burden of parameter estimation. This is achieved by reducing the dimensionality of the search space for each individual estimation task.
  • GP Interpolation as a Decoupling Mechanism: Gaussian Processes are not just used for smoothing data; they act as a crucial mechanism to "decouple" the subsystems. By providing interpolated time-series as inputs, they create a conditional independence that allows for parallel processing of parameter estimation for each subsystem.
  • Parallelization is Key: The inherent parallelizability of the subsystems approach is highlighted as a major advantage, enabling significant computational speedups and allowing for more thorough exploration of the parameter space within each subsystem.
  • Quantifying Uncertainty: The use of MCMC naturally provides posterior distributions for parameters, allowing for a robust quantification of uncertainty in the estimates, which is often lacking in single-point estimation methods.

Key Results

  • Competitive Accuracy: The subsystems approach demonstrated competitive accuracy compared to state-of-the-art methods on the tested benchmark systems.
  • Significant Speedup: The method offers substantial computational speedups due to its parallelizable nature, making it feasible for larger and more complex models.
  • Improved Parameter Estimates: For the signalling cascade model, the subsystem-based MCMC yielded parameter estimates closer to the true values compared to a whole-system MCMC approach.
  • Confidence Assessment: The method allows for the assessment of confidence in parameter estimates, as demonstrated by the differing sharpness of posterior distributions for different parameters.
  • Handling Noisy Data: The GP interpolation component effectively handles noisy measurements, smoothing the data and providing a more robust input for parameter estimation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Non-Unique Estimates: The paper acknowledges that for parameters involved in multiple subsystems, unique estimates are not always obtained. This remains an open question, though the authors suggest that the posterior distributions offer room for reconciliation.
  • Subsystem Definition: The current method defines subsystems based on single species. The authors suggest that extending the size of subsystems might be necessary for cases where a single parameter influences multiple reactions (e.g., mass action cascades). However, automatically identifying optimal subsystem sizes is noted as a challenging problem.
  • Complex Measurement Types: The method currently assumes direct measurements of individual species. Future work could address scenarios where measurements are combinations of species (e.g., total protein levels) or where parameters control multiple reactions.

Summary updated

Abstract

:We present a new method for parameter identification of ODE system descriptions based on data measurements. Our method works by splitting the system into a number of subsystems and working on each of them separately, thereby being easily parallelisable, and can also deal with noise in the observations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{georgoulas2012subsystems,
  author = {Anastasis Georgoulas and Allan Clark and Andrea Ocone and Stephen Gilmore and Guido Sanguinetti},
  title = {{A subsystems approach for parameter estimation of ODE models of hybrid systems}},
  booktitle = {HSB},
  year = {2012},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=L6URdNe8Ij},
}
Figure