A Study on Translation Methods of American Humor Subtitles—Take the American Sitcom 2 Broke Girls for Example

Yi ZhangJournal of Humanities Arts and Social Science 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Subtitle translation is a vital component of film and television, serving as a bridge for Sino-US cultural exchange. As American TV series increasingly penetrate the Chinese market, the challenge of helping Chinese audiences understand American humor—often deeply rooted in specific cultural backgrounds—becomes paramount. This paper examines the translation of humorous lines in the American sitcom 2 Broke Girls through the lens of Eugene Nida’s Functional Equivalence Theory. By analyzing specific applications of literal translation, free translation, amplification, transliteration, and entertainment-oriented rewriting, this study demonstrates how translators can better convey cultural connotations and provide a functional equivalent of the original comedic experience for the target audience.

Introduction

Humor is notoriously difficult to translate because it is embedded in a nation’s underlying aspirations, concerns, and social conflicts. For a Chinese audience, a joke about Brooklyn’s crime rate or an American Idol runner-up might fall flat without significant context. While subtitle translation in China has grown significantly since 2006, it remains an under-studied field, particularly regarding the "untranslatability" of comedy. The core problem lies in maintaining the "humorous function" of a line when a literal translation would be obscure, rigid, or simply not funny to the target audience.

Theoretical Framework: Functional Equivalence

This study utilizes Eugene Nida’s Functional Equivalence Theory as its primary analytical framework. This theory posits that translation should prioritize the "reader’s response" over formal correspondence. The goal is for the target audience to experience the text in a way that is functionally equivalent to how the original audience experienced it. In the context of 2 Broke Girls, this means the translator's success is measured by whether the Chinese viewer laughs at the same moments and for the same reasons as the American viewer.

Analysis of Translation Strategies

Through a qualitative analysis of dialogue from 2 Broke Girls, five specific translation methods emerge as essential for bridging the cultural divide:

1. Literal and Free Translation

Literal translation is most effective for simple, visual metaphors. For instance, describing a character as a "human mustard packet" translates well directly because the visual image is universal. However, when jokes involve complex American social structures, such as specific types of financial fraud, translators often employ free translation. By abandoning the original linguistic form to prioritize the underlying meaning, they ensure the audience understands the stakes of the joke without getting bogged down in technicalities.

2. Amplification and Transliteration

Amplification involves adding brief annotations or explanatory words to bridge cultural gaps. In 2 Broke Girls, a joke referencing Adam Lambert was amplified by identifying him as a "public gay singer" to explain the context of his popularity and the specific nature of the joke. In fast-paced subtitles, these additions must be succinct to avoid distracting the viewer.

Transliteration is used creatively to maintain puns. A notable example is the character Han, the restaurant owner. When other characters tease him using the word "haning," the translator used the Chinese word han (meaning stupid or clumsy). This achieved a "double equivalence" of both sound and comedic effect, preserving the character-based humor.

3. Entertainment-oriented Rewriting

The most creative approach is entertainment-oriented rewriting. Here, translators replace English jokes with Chinese internet buzzwords (tu cao), ancient poetry, or local proverbs. For example, a line about searching for a "hipster" was translated using a famous line from a poem by Xin Qiji. This "breaks the rigidity" of traditional translation and creates a sense of intimacy and cultural relevance for the viewer.

Key Insights and Results

The study concludes that successful humor translation requires a flexible, method-oriented approach. Literal translation is often insufficient for comedy, as it can make the content seem obscure and rigid. Instead, functional equivalence serves as the key to expressing the same effect as the source language. Appropriate rewriting actually improves the "performance effect" of the comedy, compensating for the fact that English dialogue may be less vivid to a non-native speaker than a well-chosen Chinese idiom or cultural reference.

Conclusion and Future Work

While this study highlights effective strategies for translating American humor, it also acknowledges limitations. The analysis is qualitative and based on specific examples; future research could benefit from quantitative data, such as audience surveys, to measure the actual enjoyment levels of viewers. Furthermore, while these strategies work well for sitcoms, future work should explore their efficacy in other genres, such as political dramas or stand-up specials, to further enrich the field of film and television translation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Subtitle is an important part of film and television. With a large number of American TV series in the Chinese market, in order to help Chinese audiences to understand the content and American cultural background, especially American humor culture, subtitle translation has become a vital bridge for Sino-US cultural exchanges. Subtitle translation is a method-oriented science. Then, this paper mainly discusses humorous lines on TV series and introduces the causes of American humor and its main themes. This paper combines the functional equivalence theory and studies the translation methods and skills of humorous lines in the sitcom. The subtitle translation of the American sitcom 2 Broke Girls is taken as the research object, and the translation of a large number of lines in the sitcom is taken as an example. It mainly analyzes the specific application of literal translation, free translation, amplification, transliteration, and entertainment rewriting in subtitle translation. It is expected to better convey the connotation and cultural information of film and television works to the audience and provide references to translators and researchers in this field.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2024study,
  author = {Yi Zhang},
  title = {{A Study on Translation Methods of American Humor Subtitles—Take the American Sitcom <i>2 Broke Girls</i> for Example}},
  journal = {Journal of Humanities Arts and Social Science},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.26855/jhass.2024.10.015},
}
Figure