A Study on Development of Acquisition Policy for Establishing Private and Community Archive: Focused on Daegu Yakjeon Alley

So-Young Um, Hye-Young Kim, Hyun Myung, Yong KimJournal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science 2017 · DOI

Abstract

As rapid urbanization and commercialization threaten local heritage, traditional top-down record management often fails to capture the unique cultural and social fabric of private citizens and local communities. This study proposes a structured framework for building community archives, using the 400-year-old Daegu Yakjeon (Oriental Medicine) Alley as a primary case study. By developing a step-by-step acquisition policy, the research aims to empower residents to transition from passive record-keepers to active curators of their own history.

Introduction: The Crisis of Locality

Since the late 1990s, South Korea has significantly improved its public record management systems. However, these advancements have primarily focused on government institutions, often neglecting the "locality"—the unique records of private citizens and communities. The Daegu Yakjeon Alley, a historic hub for oriental medicine, exemplifies this challenge. Despite its centuries-long history, the area faces an identity crisis driven by rising rents, the influx of modern commercial developments, and shifting consumer habits. Without a proactive strategy to preserve its unique records—ranging from ancient medical texts to the oral histories of shopkeepers—the community's collective memory is at risk of permanent loss.

Methodology and Comparative Analysis

The researchers employed a multi-pronged qualitative approach to develop a robust acquisition policy. This included a documentation strategy framework that analyzes community functions to identify what must be recorded to represent identity accurately.

A critical component of the research involved analyzing successful community archives to identify best practices. These included the Chongneung Village Records and the Shiheung Varagi Archive, the latter of which serves as a model for physical community memory preservation.

The Shiheung Varagi Archive, a physical manifestation of community memory preservation.

In addition to case studies, the authors conducted field interviews with stakeholders in Daegu Yakjeon Alley, specifically targeting shop owners who had initiated "private museums." This helped identify the current state of record-keeping and the practical challenges of community-led preservation.

Key Insights: Records as Community Activation

The study identifies several core principles for effective community archiving:

  • Locality as Activity: Locality records are defined not just as static objects, but as the diverse activities of regional actors and the resulting changes. This includes oral histories, which capture the experiences of marginalized groups or informal traditions.
  • Community Activation: Archiving is presented as a tool for rebuilding a sense of belonging and shared identity among residents.
  • Professional-Citizen Hybridity: Since community archives often lack professional archivists, policies must be simple enough for residents to execute while maintaining the authenticity and integrity of the records.
  • Categorization: Records are categorized into five types: Administrative (agencies), Festival (events), Person (residents/merchants), History (events/changes), and Building (historic architecture).

The 5-Step Acquisition Execution Model

The paper culminates in a practical model designed for community implementation:

  1. Recruitment: Identifying and gathering residents and organizations interested in preservation.
  2. Education: Training participants in basic archival concepts and the importance of community identity.
  3. Meeting: Collaborative sessions to determine the priority and scope of collection (e.g., prioritizing oral histories of elder pharmacists).
  4. Acquisition: The actual gathering, digitizing, and cataloging of records, including the creation of "Lead Files" to track potential donors.
  5. Evaluation & Utilization: Assessing the collection against community goals and developing services like exhibitions or digital portals to ensure accessibility.

Conclusion and Future Work

While the proposed policy provides a theoretical framework for preserving the "pulse" of the city, its success depends heavily on the voluntary participation of communities under economic stress. Future work should focus on implementing this model in pilot projects within Yakjeon Alley to identify practical bottlenecks, expanding stakeholder input to include younger generations, and exploring sustainable funding models for long-term digital and physical infrastructure.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{um2017study,
  author = {So-Young Um and Hye-Young Kim and Hyun Myung and Yong Kim},
  title = {{A Study on Development of Acquisition Policy for Establishing Private and Community Archive: Focused on Daegu Yakjeon Alley}},
  journal = {Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.4275/kslis.2017.51.2.179},
}
Figure