A Study on Characteristics of Lincomycin Degradation by Optimized TiO2/HAP/Ge Composite using Mixture Analysis

Dongwoo Kim, Soon Woong ChangJournal of the Korean Geoenvironmental Society 2014 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the photocatalytic degradation of the antibiotic lincomycin (LM) using a ternary composite of titanium dioxide (TiO₂), hydroxyapatite (HAP), and germanium (Ge) under UV-A irradiation. Initial comparisons established that the ternary TiO₂/HAP/Ge composite significantly outperformed binary and single-component catalysts. To maximize efficiency, a statistical mixture analysis was employed to determine the optimal ratio of the three components. The resulting model demonstrated high predictive accuracy ($R^2 > 98.9%$). Under optimized conditions, the system achieved 99.2% removal of LM and 49.3% mineralization (TOC removal), aligning closely with theoretical predictions.

Introduction

The accumulation of pharmaceutical compounds like lincomycin (LM) in aquatic environments poses a significant ecological threat, contributing to the development of antibiotic-resistant bacteria. Traditional wastewater treatment often fails to remove these recalcitrant pollutants. While TiO₂ is a widely used photocatalyst, its efficiency is limited by high electron-hole recombination rates. This research explores the synergy of adding HAP to enhance adsorption and Ge to extend light-absorption capabilities, creating a highly efficient ternary composite.

Comparative Performance of Catalyst Composites

Initial experiments compared the degradation potential of various catalyst combinations. The results indicated a clear hierarchy in removal efficiency: TiO₂/HAP/Ge > TiO₂/Ge > TiO₂/HAP. The inclusion of HAP acts as a trap for LM molecules, increasing their concentration on the catalyst surface, while Ge facilitates broader light utilization and the generation of reactive hydroxyl radicals.

Comparison of photocatalytic degradation rates for various catalyst compositions over 300 minutes.

Statistical Optimization via Mixture Analysis

Rather than relying on trial-and-error, the researchers used Mixture Analysis—a form of Response Surface Methodology (RSM)—to identify the ideal proportions of TiO₂ ($X_1$), HAP ($X_2$), and Ge ($X_3$). A 10-run experimental design was used to model two primary outcomes: LM removal ($Y_1$) and Total Organic Carbon (TOC) removal ($Y_2$).

Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) confirmed that the quadratic models were statistically significant ($p < 0.05$). The optimization focused on TOC removal to ensure not just the disappearance of the parent antibiotic, but the mineralization of organic intermediates into harmless substances.

Optimized Degradation and Mineralization

The statistical model identified an optimal coded composition of $X_1=0.6913$, $X_2=0.2313$, and $X_3=0.0756$. Validation experiments using this specific ratio confirmed the model's robustness.

Time-course degradation of Lincomycin (LM) and Total Organic Carbon (TOC) using the optimized TiO₂/HAP/Ge catalyst under UV-A irradiation.

As shown in the results, the system achieved near-total degradation of the antibiotic (99.2%) within 240 minutes. However, the TOC removal reached approximately 49.3%, indicating that while the antibiotic molecule is effectively broken down, roughly half of the organic carbon remains as intermediate byproducts. This distinction is critical for environmental applications, suggesting that further optimization or longer irradiation times may be necessary for full mineralization.

Conclusion

The study successfully demonstrates that a statistically optimized TiO₂/HAP/Ge composite is a highly effective tool for removing lincomycin from water. The use of mixture analysis provided a precise mathematical framework for catalyst design, achieving high experimental agreement with predicted models. Future work should focus on identifying the toxicity of remaining organic intermediates and testing the system's performance in complex, real-world wastewater matrices.

Summary updated

Abstract

본 연구에서는 UV-A 조사를 통해 titanium dioxide(<TEX>$TiO_2$</TEX>), hydroxyapatite(HAP)와 germanium(Ge)의 다양한 복합촉매를 통한 항생제(lincomycin, LM)의 광촉매 제거를 조사하였다. 우선, 다양한 복합촉매의 향상된 광촉매능을 비교하였고, 도출된 제거효율은 <TEX>$TiO_2/HAP/Ge$</TEX> > <TEX>$TiO_2/Ge$</TEX> > <TEX>$TiO_2/HAP$</TEX> 순으로 관찰되었다. <TEX>$TiO_2/HAP/Ge$</TEX>의 조성은 반응표면법의 하나인 혼합물분석(mixture analysis)에 기초하여 통계적 방안이 수행되었다. 각 인자별 6개의 조건을 포함하도록 설정한 독립변수 <TEX>$TiO_2(X_1)$</TEX>, HAP(<TEX>$X_2$</TEX>)와 Ge(<TEX>$X_3$</TEX>)의 LM(<TEX>$Y_1$</TEX>)과 TOC(<TEX>$Y_2$</TEX>) 제거에 대한 영향을 살펴보았다. 분산분석(ANOVA)의 회귀분석항은 유의한 p값(p<0.05)과 높은 결정계수 값(<TEX>$R^2$</TEX> of <TEX>$Y_1=99.28%$</TEX> and <TEX>$R^2$</TEX> of <TEX>$Y_2=98.91%$</TEX>)을 나타냈다. 등고선도와 반응곡선을 통해 UV-A 조사조건에서 <TEX>$TiO_2$</TEX>/HAP/Ge 조성에 따른 LM의 제거를 나타냈다. TOC(<TEX>$Y_2$</TEX>) 제거를 기준으로 도출된 최적조성비는 코드화 값으로 <TEX>$X_1=0.6913$</TEX>, <TEX>$X_2=0.2313$</TEX>과 <TEX>$X_3=0.0756$</TEX>으로 나타났다. 실제 적용에 따른 비교 실험 결과는 LM과 TOC의 평균제거율이 각각 99.2%와 49.3%로 나타나 모델의 예측과 잘 부합하였다. In this study, it was found that determined the photocatalytic degradation of antibiotics (lincomycin, LM) with various catalyst composite of titanium dioxide (<TEX>$TiO_2$</TEX>), hydroxyapatite (HAP) and germanium (Ge) under UV-A irradiation. At first, various type of complex catalysts were investigated to compare the enhanced photocatalytic potential. It was observed that in order to obtain the removal efficiencies were <TEX>$TiO_2/HAP/Ge$</TEX> > <TEX>$TiO_2/Ge$</TEX> > <TEX>$TiO_2/HAP$</TEX>. The composition of <TEX>$TiO_2/HAP/Ge$</TEX> using a statistical approach based on mixture analysis design, one of response surface method was investigated. The independent variables of <TEX>$TiO_2$</TEX> (<TEX>$X_1$</TEX>), HAP (<TEX>$X_2$</TEX>) and Ge (<TEX>$X_3$</TEX>) which consisted of 6 condition in each variables was set up to determine the effects on LM (<TEX>$Y_1$</TEX>) and TOC (<TEX>$Y_2$</TEX>) degradation. Regression analysis on analysis of variance (ANOVA) showed significant p-value (p < 0.05) and high coefficients for determination value (<TEX>$R^2$</TEX> of <TEX>$Y_1=99.28%$</TEX> and <TEX>$R^2$</TEX> of <TEX>$Y_2=98.91%$</TEX>). Contour plot and response curve showed that the effects of <TEX>$TiO_2/HAP/Ge$</TEX> composition for LM degradation under UV-A irradiation. And the estimated optimal composition for TOC removal (<TEX>$Y_2$</TEX>) were <TEX>$X_1=0.6913$</TEX>, <TEX>$X_2=0.2313$</TEX> and <TEX>$X_3=0.0756$</TEX> by coded value. By comparison with actual applications, the experimental results were found to be in good agreement with the model's predictions, with mean results for LM and TOC removal of 99.2% and 49.3%, respectively.
BibTeX
@article{kim2014study,
  author = {Dongwoo Kim and Soon Woong Chang},
  title = {{A Study on Characteristics of Lincomycin Degradation by Optimized TiO<sub>2</sub>/HAP/Ge Composite using Mixture Analysis}},
  journal = {Journal of the Korean Geoenvironmental Society},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.14481/jkges.2014.15.1.63},
}
Figure