A Spatial Distribution Equilibrium Evaluation of Health Service Resources at Community Grid Scale in Yichang, China

Jingyuan Chen, Yuqi Bai, Pei Zhang, Jingyuan Qiu, Yichun Hu, Tianhao Wang, Chengzhong Xu, Peng GongSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, fine-grained approach to evaluate the spatial distribution of health service resources within urban communities, using Yichang, China, as a case study. By integrating detailed community grid data with accessibility analysis and a comprehensive evaluation framework, the research provides a more precise understanding of resource availability and identifies areas needing improvement for better urban health planning.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developing "healthy cities" requires ensuring that essential services, particularly health services, are equitably distributed and accessible to all residents. Traditional urban planning data often aggregates resources at the administrative region level, masking significant disparities within communities. This coarse granularity makes it challenging to conduct precise evaluations of resource distribution and identify specific areas that are underserved. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a method for fine-scaled spatial distribution equilibrium evaluation of health service resources, which is crucial for effective urban planning and management.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Fine-grained Data Integration: The core innovation lies in using community grid data (1271 grids, each representing approximately 200 households) for Yichang. This level of detail allows for a much more granular analysis than traditional administrative regions.
  • Fifteen-Minute Pedestrian Accessibility: The researchers define accessibility based on a 15-minute walking distance from residential buildings. This metric serves as the primary "impedance factor," simulating how far residents can realistically travel on foot. Different walking speeds were used for general populations (1.39 m/s) and the elderly (1.20 m/s).
  • Attractiveness Factors: The "attractiveness" of health service resources is measured by their quantity and types within the 15-minute walking radius.
  • Comprehensive Evaluation Framework: A hierarchical evaluation system is established, using three types of indicators:
  • Third-grade indicators: Quantity ratio (proportion of a resource in a grid to the total), Richness ratio (proportion of resource types in a grid to the total types), and Per capita number (number of resources per resident).
  • Second-grade indicators: Aggregated values for public and private resources within each of the three main categories (preventative, therapeutic, elderly care).
  • First-grade indicators: Overall values for each of the three main resource categories.
  • Entropy Weight Method: This objective statistical method is used to assign weights to the 18 third-grade indicators, reflecting their relative importance based on the data's information entropy. This helps to avoid subjective biases in weighting.
  • Spatial Analysis: GIS tools are used to perform network analysis, spatial joins, and to calculate the average accessible resources per grid.

Datasets

  • Point-of-Interest (POI) Data: Obtained from Baidu Map API and Gaode Map API for the urban area of Yichang. This data includes 3243 POIs related to health service resources, classified into three grades.
  • Road Network Data: Obtained from Gaode Map API, used for network analysis and simulating walking distances.
  • Community Grid Data: Provided by Yichang's Smart City Construction Office, including demographic data (population, elderly population) and the longitude/latitude of residential buildings for 1271 community grids.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Granularity Matters: The study powerfully demonstrates that fine-grained data (community grids) reveals significant spatial inequalities in health resource distribution that are masked by coarser administrative-level data.
  • Pedestrian Accessibility as a Key Metric: Focusing on 15-minute walking distance provides a practical and resident-centric measure of accessibility, directly linking urban design to health service access.
  • Public vs. Private Resource Balance: The framework explicitly considers both public and private health service resources, offering a more holistic view of resource availability.
  • Uneven Distribution is the Norm: The results highlight a stark contrast in health service resource availability between the central districts (Xiling, Wujiagang) and the peripheral districts (Xiaoting, Dianjun) of Yichang, underscoring a common challenge in rapidly urbanizing areas.
  • Elderly Care Resources Show Greatest Disparity: The evaluation of elderly care resources revealed the most significant differences, indicating a critical need for targeted policy interventions in underserved areas.

Key Results

  • The overall health service resource values varied significantly across Yichang's grids, with mean values ranging from 0.0764 in Xiling district to 0.0083 in Xiaoting district for preventative resources.
  • The central districts (Xiling and Wujiagang) generally exhibited higher health service resource values due to higher population density and better resource allocation.
  • Peripheral districts (Xiaoting and Dianjun) showed significantly lower values, particularly for therapeutic and elderly care resources, indicating a critical lack of services.
  • The study identified specific grids (e.g., Grid A) with high resource availability due to a combination of sufficient resources and low population density, leading to high per-capita values. Conversely, grids with high population density and limited resources (e.g., Grid B) showed low per-capita values.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Resident Willingness and Preference: The study acknowledges that resident willingness and preference to walk were not considered, meaning the analysis is based on potential demand rather than actual demand, which could be influenced by factors like perceived safety or comfort.
  • Facility Size and Service Radius: Uniform data on facility size and service radius was difficult to obtain, limiting the ability to uniformly describe these aspects of accessibility.
  • Single Impedance Factor: The research primarily used a 15-minute walking distance as the sole impedance factor. Future work could explore other impedance elements (e.g., cost, time for motorized transport) and incorporate more complex accessibility models.
  • Objective Data Focus: The current methodology relies heavily on objective data. Future research could integrate subjective evaluations (e.g., expert opinions, resident surveys) to create a more comprehensive evaluation indicator system.
  • Data Integrity: The authors note that the method requires high data integrity for empirical studies.

The authors suggest that future research should focus on deepening the understanding of health service resources, scientifically formulating evaluation indicators, and improving accessibility evaluation methods, potentially by integrating more diverse data sources like processed resident demand surveys, pedestrian movement data, and land use information.

Summary updated

Abstract

Whether the supplies of health services and related facilities meet the demand is a critical issue when developing healthy cities. The importance of health services and related facilities in public health promotion has been adequately proved. However, since the community population and resource data are usually available at the scale of an administrative region; it is very difficult to perform further fine-scaled spatial distribution equilibrium evaluation studies. Such kinds of activities are highly expected for precise urban planning and management. Yichang is located in Hubei province, the central part of China, along the Yangzi River. It is leading both of China’s smart cities demonstration project and China’s healthy cities pilot project. Yichang has defined 1271 community grids for urban management and service, where each grid consists of 200 households generally with its population distribution data routinely updated. The research set the 15-min walking distances of the residents as impedance factors, and the numbers and the types of health service resources as attractiveness factors for accessibility evaluation. The resource ratio, richness and per capita number of various health service resources that can be reached within 15 min from the community grid building is used as spatial distribution equilibrium evaluation indicators. The entropy weight method is used to assign the indicator weight value. The obtained fine-scale evaluation results were analyzed. In this way, a community grid-scale spatial distribution equilibrium evaluation of health service resources in Yichang was performed. The proposed research could be of value for rapid and precise evaluation of spatial distribution equilibrium evaluation of a variety of healthy city resources, to support healthy city planning and management.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2019spatial,
  author = {Jingyuan Chen and Yuqi Bai and Pei Zhang and Jingyuan Qiu and Yichun Hu and Tianhao Wang and Chengzhong Xu and Peng Gong},
  title = {{A Spatial Distribution Equilibrium Evaluation of Health Service Resources at Community Grid Scale in Yichang, China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su12010052},
}
Figure