A Small Step from Price Competition to Price War: Understanding Causes, Effects and Possible Countermeasures

Andreas Krämer, Martin H. Jung, Thomas BurgartzInternational Business Research 2016 · DOI

Abstract

This paper describes the characteristics of price wars, pointing to recent examples that have caused a stir among the public as well as in the respective industries. A new, concise definition of the term price war is suggested. Drivers for price wars are discussed and explained based on behavioral economics, particularly focusing on how misestimating price elasticities can lead to unintended price competition. A case study of the German intercity bus market following its 2013 liberalization illustrates these dynamics, showing how market entry and competitive reactions from incumbents like Deutsche Bahn created a ruinous environment. Finally, measures to avoid or terminate an ongoing price war are presented.

Introduction

While price competition is a fundamental mechanic of healthy markets, "price wars" represent a failure of managerial rationality that can destroy industry value. This paper addresses the lack of a functional definition distinguishing the two and explores why rational managers often initiate cycles leading to sub-cost pricing. By examining psychological and structural drivers—such as excess capacity and the "commodity trap"—the research highlights the volatile transition from competition to conflict.

Defining the Price War

The authors propose a new definition of a price war based on three specific criteria:

  1. Strategic Priority: Competitors prioritize market share and capacity utilization over short-term profitability.
  2. Profitability Threshold: Prices fall below the level of sustainable industry profitability.
  3. Supplier Direction: The downward price pressure is primarily driven by suppliers' aggressive actions rather than shifts in consumer demand.

Behavioral Drivers: The Elasticity and Commodity Traps

A primary driver of price wars is the "Elasticity Trap." Managers often overestimate price elasticity, assuming a small price reduction will trigger a massive volume increase. However, this logic fails if competitors match the cut; the volume gain vanishes while the margin loss remains.

Furthermore, the "Commodity Trap" affects roughly 60% of managers who feel their products—even complex services—are perceived as interchangeable by consumers. In such environments, price becomes the only perceived competitive lever, leading to a race to the bottom.

Figure 1: Simulation of profit destruction across four scenarios, showing how a 10% price cut met by competitor reactions can lead to an 86% profit collapse.

Case Study: The German Intercity Bus Market

The 2013 liberalization of the German long-distance bus market provides a stark real-world example.

Methods and Data

The study utilized a multi-source-multi-method approach, including:

  • Behavioral Modeling: Dynamic simulations of price-volume interactions.
  • Empirical Survey: The "MobilityTrends 2015" survey of 4,500 individuals to gauge consumer price perception.
  • Price Monitoring: Longitudinal tracking of 10 major travel routes comparing market leaders (FlixBus), new entrants (Megabus), and rail (Deutsche Bahn).

Key Results

  • Ruinous Entry: Megabus entered the market with fares as low as €1. Their average yield (0.82–1.35 cents/km) was significantly below the estimated cost-recovery limit of 5–6 cents/km.
  • Incumbent Reaction: Deutsche Bahn responded with aggressive "Sparpreis" promotions, effectively signaling their willingness to defend market share at any cost. This strategic signaling reclaimed volume but further suppressed industry price levels.
  • Consumer Surplus vs. Sustainability: While consumers reported high satisfaction (89% value-for-money rating), the price war created a massive consumer surplus at the expense of provider sustainability.

Strategic Countermeasures

To exit the commodity trap, firms must focus on non-price differentiation. The paper also highlights "strategic signaling" as a tool to deter aggression. For instance, publicizing large-scale discount programs can signal to competitors that an incumbent has the resources to sustain a long-term fight, potentially discouraging further price cuts.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

Price wars often result in long-term damage to an industry's price image. Once consumers are "anchored" to abnormally low prices, their willingness to pay may be permanently suppressed. Future research should investigate the long-term impacts on Customer Relationship Management (CRM) and how industries can rebuild profitability after the cessation of hostilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

<p>The first part of this paper describes the characteristics of price wars, pointing to recent examples that have caused a stir among the public as well as in the respective industries. A new, concise definition of the term price war is suggested. In the second part drivers for price wars are discussed and explained based on behavioral economics (understanding the competitor’s strategy as well as a company’s own cost situation). Particularly in industries that are characterized by a high proportion of costs that are unchangeable in the medium-term and low variable costs there is a substantial risk for unintended price competition possibly ending in a price war. Even slight price reductions can have fatal consequences when decision makers mistakenly estimate the price elasticities too high. In the third part a case study of a price war is presented by focusing on the market of long-distance bus journeys in Germany. Since the market for intercity bus connections was liberalized in 2013, the newly created market segment faces a very strong growth and intensive competition. Using a multi-source-multi-method-approach it is shown how the market entry of UK-based company Megabus affected price levels for bus journeys und initiated competitive reactions of the German railway operator Deutsche Bahn. The interaction of various parameters (low barriers to enter the market; high similarity of products/services; fixation on market share and capacity utilization) leads to a ruinous price competition and leaves few chances for a sustainable profitability. Measures to avoid an impending or to terminate an ongoing price war are presented.</p>
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kramer2016small,
  author = {Andreas Krämer and Martin H. Jung and Thomas Burgartz},
  title = {{A Small Step from Price Competition to Price War: Understanding Causes, Effects and Possible Countermeasures}},
  booktitle = {International Business Research},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.5539/ibr.v9n3p1},
}
Figure