A Simple Two-stage Equalizer With Simplified Orthogonal Time Frequency Space Modulation Over Rapidly Time-varying Channels

Li Li, Wei Hua, Yao Huang, Yao Yao, Weiwei Ling, Chen Gong, Yunlong Cai

Abstract

In this work, we derive an equivalent delay-Doppler channel matrix of the Orthogonal Time Frequency Space (OTFS) modulation that has not been studied in previous literature. It has a similar structure to the banded channel matrix of OFDM systems over rapidly time-varying channels. However, the band in the equivalent channel matrix will no longer spread with the increase of the Doppler spread once the length of maximum channel delay spread and the OTFS frame duration are determined. Furthermore, the equivalent channel matrix can simplify the OTFS modulation in the transmitter side. Incorporating the equivalent channel matrix, we propose a simple two-stage equalizer in 1-dimensional operations for OTFS modulation. First, the receive signal is equalized using the conventional OFDM single-tap equalizer in the frequency domain. The multipath effects can be removed. In the second stage, another low-complexity delay-Doppler domain equalizer is employed to eliminate the effects of the residual interference caused by the Doppler spread with the equivalent channel matrix. The simulation results demonstrate that the proposed method is superior to the conventional single-tap equalizer and full minimum mean squared error (MMSE) equalizer of OFDM systems in terms of BER in high Doppler spread scenarios.

Introduction

In modern wireless communications, rapidly time-varying channels present a significant challenge. When a receiver moves at high speeds, such as on a high-speed train, the signal experiences substantial Doppler spread. This phenomenon causes Inter-Carrier Interference (ICI) in standard OFDM systems—the backbone of 4G and 5G—which traditional single-tap equalizers cannot effectively mitigate.

Orthogonal Time Frequency Space (OTFS) modulation is a leading candidate for 6G communications designed to address this by multiplexing symbols in the delay-Doppler domain. While OTFS is inherently robust, its implementation has often been mathematically complex and computationally expensive. This paper provides a simplified matrix representation of the OTFS channel and proposes a low-complexity two-stage equalization method.

Equivalent Channel Matrix and Simplified OTFS

A core contribution of this work is the derivation of a "banded" equivalent channel matrix for OTFS. Unlike OFDM, where the channel matrix band spreads as Doppler increases, the OTFS equivalent matrix remains stable. The width of this band is determined primarily by the maximum delay spread and the frame duration, rather than the Doppler frequency itself.

The equivalent delay-Doppler channel matrix exhibits a stable banded structure.

Furthermore, the authors demonstrate that the complex Discrete Symplectic Fourier Transform (DSFT) typically required for OTFS can be replaced by simpler reordering operations and standard IFFTs. By using a specific reordering matrix, the transmitter design is significantly simplified without losing the performance benefits of delay-Doppler domain multiplexing.

Proposed Two-Stage Equalizer

Leveraging the derived matrix structure, the researchers propose a two-stage equalizer that operates in one dimension:

  1. Frequency Domain Equalizer (FDE): This stage uses a standard single-tap equalizer to remove multipath effects, similar to conventional OFDM processing.
  2. Delay-Doppler Domain Equalizer (DDE): This stage utilizes the stable banded structure of the equivalent matrix to perform interference cancellation, mopping up the residual interference caused by Doppler shifts.

This decoupled approach avoids the high complexity associated with full Minimum Mean Squared Error (MMSE) equalizers, making it highly suitable for real-time hardware implementation.

Performance Evaluation

The proposed system was evaluated using numerical simulations based on the TU6 (Typical Urban 6-tap) power delay profile at a 5.8 GHz carrier frequency with 40 MHz bandwidth.

BER performance comparison across varying Doppler frequencies (fd).

As shown in the results, the proposed OTFS FDE+DDE equalizer significantly outperforms standard OFDM single-tap and full MMSE equalizers in high Doppler scenarios (e.g., $f_d > 10^3$ Hz). While OFDM's Bit Error Rate (BER) hits a floor as speed increases, the proposed OTFS method maintains performance, demonstrating superior robustness to mobility.

Conclusion

This paper presents a practical path for implementing OTFS in high-speed scenarios. By simplifying the channel representation and the modulation process, the proposed two-stage equalizer achieves high performance with complexity almost identical to current single-tap OFDM systems. Future work will focus on extending this framework to Multiple-Input Multiple-Output (MIMO) systems and investigating the impact of decision errors in iterative feedback schemes.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this work, we derive a equivalent delay-Doppler channel matrix of the Orthogonal Time Frequency Space (OTFS) modulation that has not been studied in previous literature. It has the similar structure as the banded channel matrix of OFDM systems over rapidly time-varying channels. However, the band in the equivalent channel matrix will no longer spread with the increase of the Doppler spread once the length of maximum channel delay spread and the OTFS frame duration are deter- mined. Furthermore, the equivalent channel matrix can simplify the OTFS modulation in the transmitter side. Incorporating the equivalent channel matrix, we propose a simple two-stage equal- izer in 1 dimensional operations for OTFS modulation. First, the receive signal is equalized using the conventional OFDM single- tap equalizer in the frequency domain. The multipath effects can be removed. In the second stage, another low complexity delay- Doppler domain equalizer is employed to eliminate the effects of the residual interference caused by the Doppler spread with the equivalent channel matrix. The simulation results demonstrate that the proposed method is superior to the conventional single- tap equalizer and full minimum mean squared error (MMSE) equalizer of OFDM systems in terms of BER in high Doppler spread scenarios.
BibTeX
@misc{li2017simple,
  author = {Li Li and Wei Hua and Yao Huang and Yao Yao and Weiwei Ling and Chen Gong and Peng Li and Yunlong Cai},
  title = {{A Simple Two-stage Equalizer With Simplified Orthogonal Time Frequency Space Modulation Over Rapidly Time-varying Channels}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1709.02505},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1709.02505},
}
Figure