A Simple High-Resolution Near-Field Probe for Microwave Non-Destructive Test and Imaging

Zipeng Xie, Yongjie Li, Liguo Sun, Wentao Wu, Rui Cao, Xiaohui Tao

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a simple, single-port microwave probe that achieves high-resolution non-destructive testing (NDT) and imaging at a lower frequency (390 MHz). This probe utilizes a novel complementary spiral resonator (CSR) structure, enabling it to detect very small defects in both metallic and non-metallic materials with improved sensitivity and resolution compared to existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Microwave non-destructive testing (NDT) offers advantages like material penetration and contactless operation, but lower frequencies, which are better for penetration, typically lead to reduced resolution. Existing high-resolution probes often operate at higher frequencies or require complex matching circuits and are typically two-port devices, limiting their ease of use and arraying capabilities. This paper aims to bridge this gap by creating a simple, single-port probe that delivers high resolution at a lower, more penetrative frequency.

Methods

The core of the probe's design is a Complementary Spiral Resonator (CSR). The researchers meticulously analyzed the CSR's structure (spiral width, slot width, start angle) using eigenmode simulations in HFSS to optimize its field confinement properties. This led to a design that minimizes electric field dips and maximizes near-field confinement, crucial for high resolution.

The probe itself is a single-port planar circuit, ingeniously designed with a microstrip ring fed by a short microstrip. This structure eliminates the need for external matching circuits, simplifying its implementation and making it ideal for sensor array applications. The probe's performance was evaluated through numerical analysis and experimental measurements, focusing on sensitivity and resolution as a function of standoff distance (SOD) between the probe and the material under test.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments involved custom-machined test samples (POM boards and aluminum boards) with intentionally introduced defects (cracks and vias) of varying dimensions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CSRs for High Resolution at Low Frequencies: The study demonstrates that carefully designed CSRs can achieve high near-field confinement, enabling high resolution even at lower microwave frequencies (around 390 MHz), which are typically associated with poorer resolution.
  • Single-Port Simplicity: The innovative microstrip ring and short microstrip feeding mechanism for the CSR creates a single-port probe that requires no external matching circuits. This significantly simplifies fabrication and integration, especially for sensor arrays.
  • Standoff Distance (SOD) Optimization: The research highlights the critical role of SOD in balancing sensitivity and resolution. They found an optimal SOD of 2.5 mm for maximizing resolution, while acknowledging that a compromise (e.g., 1 mm SOD) might be necessary for practical imaging applications.
  • Defect Detection Versatility: The probe proved effective in detecting a wide range of defects, from sub-millimeter cracks to vias, in both dielectric (POM) and metallic (aluminum) materials, as well as subsurface defects in composite materials and corrosion on steel.

Key Results

  • High Resolution: The probe achieved a spatial resolution of 2.5 mm, which is approximately $\lambda/308$ at its operating frequency of 390 MHz.
  • Smallest Detectable Defects:
    • Non-metal materials: 0.5 mm width crack ($\lambda/1538$) and 1.5 mm diameter via ($\lambda/513$).
  • Metal materials: 0.2 mm width crack ($\lambda/3846$) and 1.5 mm diameter via ($\lambda/513$).
  • Effective Imaging: The probe successfully imaged defects under skin layers in multilayer composites and corrosion on carbon steel.
  • Good Dynamic Range: Imaging of defects in rusted steel showed high dynamic ranges (7 dB for magnitude, 60° for phase), indicating strong signal variations from defects.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Imaging Efficiency: The authors acknowledge that while the probe offers high resolution, the imaging efficiency of a single probe is not as high as that of an array.
  • Future Work: The paper explicitly states that studies on probe arraying, which would improve imaging efficiency, are planned for the future. This suggests a natural next step for this technology.

Summary updated

Abstract

Non-destructive tests working at lower microwave frequencies have large advantages of dielectric material penetrability, lower equipment cost, and lower implementation complexity. However, the resolution will become worse as the work frequencies become lower. Relying on designing the structure of high field confinement, this study realizes a simple complementary spiral resonators (CSRs)-based near-field probe for microwave non-destructive testing (NDT) and imaging around 390 MHz (λ = 769 mm) whereby very high resolution (λ/308, 2.5 mm) is achieved. By applying an ingenious structure where a short microstrip is connected to a microstrip ring to feed the CSR, the probe, that is a single-port microwave planar circuit, does not need any extra matching circuits, which has more application potential in sensor arraying compared with other microwave probes. The variation of the electric field distribution with the standoff distance (SOD) between the material under test and the probe are analyzed to reveal the operation mechanisms behind the improved sensitivity and resolution of the proposed probe. Besides, the detection abilities of the tiny defects in metal and non-metal materials are demonstrated by the related experiments. The smallest detectable crack and via in the non-metal materials and the metal materials are of a λ/1538 (0.5 mm) width, a λ/513 (1.5 mm) diameter, a λ/3846 (0.2 mm) width and a λ/513 (1.5 mm) diameter, respectively. Moreover, to further evaluate the performance of the proposed probe, the defects under skin layer in the multilayer composite materials and the defects under corrosion in the carbon steel are inspected and imaged. Due to lower work frequency, high resolution, outstanding detection abilities of tiny defects, and large potentials in sensor arraying, the proposed probe would be a good candidate for microwave NDT and imaging.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xie2020simple,
  author = {Zipeng Xie and Yongjie Li and Liguo Sun and Wentao Wu and Rui Cao and Xiaohui Tao},
  title = {{A Simple High-Resolution Near-Field Probe for Microwave Non-Destructive Test and Imaging}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=DrxEsyLnh5},
}
Figure