A Signal Detection Method Based on BiGRU for FSO Communications with Atmospheric Turbulence

Zhenning Yi, Zhiyong Xu, Jianhua Li, Jingyuan Wang, Jiyong Zhao, Yang Su, Yimin WangPhotonics 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel signal detection method for Free Space Optical (FSO) communications using a Bidirectional Gated Recurrent Unit (BiGRU) neural network. By effectively capturing temporal correlations in received signals, the BiGRU-based detector significantly improves bit error rate (BER) performance, especially under atmospheric turbulence, outperforming conventional and other deep learning methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Free Space Optical (FSO) communication offers a promising solution for high-capacity, unlicensed spectrum communication, alleviating spectrum scarcity issues. However, FSO systems are highly susceptible to atmospheric turbulence, which causes fluctuations in signal intensity. These fluctuations lead to a degraded bit error rate (BER), hindering reliable communication. While existing methods like spatial diversity and adaptive optics exist, they often increase system complexity and cost. Deep learning (DL) has emerged as a powerful tool for signal detection, but many DL-based approaches treat received signals as independent samples, failing to leverage their inherent temporal correlations. This paper aims to address this limitation by proposing a DL-based detection method that explicitly accounts for these temporal dependencies to enhance FSO system performance under turbulent conditions.

Methods

The core of this paper is the proposed signal detection method based on a Bidirectional Gated Recurrent Unit (BiGRU) neural network. BiGRU is a type of recurrent neural network (RNN) that processes sequential data by considering information from both the past (forward GRU) and the future (backward GRU). This bidirectional processing allows the model to capture long-term dependencies and contextual features within the received signal sequence, which is crucial for understanding the impact of temporal signal fluctuations caused by turbulence.

The proposed detection system consists of:

  1. Feature Extraction: Two fully connected layers with ReLU activation functions are used to extract features from the sampled received signal within each symbol period.
  2. Temporal Sequence Analysis: The extracted features are then fed into the BiGRU layer, which processes the sequence of features over time, learning the temporal correlations.
  3. Classification: A third fully connected layer followed by a SoftMax function is used to classify the output of the BiGRU layer into the predicted binary symbol (0 or 1).

Crucially, this method does not require Channel State Information (CSI), which is a significant advantage over traditional Maximum Likelihood (ML) detection that relies on perfect CSI.

Datasets

The authors generated binary data sequences for training and testing. For simulating atmospheric turbulence, they utilized experimental measurements of intensity fluctuations collected from a 500m FSO link under varying weather conditions. Specifically, they selected datasets corresponding to:

  • Weak turbulence: Characterized by a lognormal distribution of intensity fluctuations.
  • Moderate turbulence: Characterized by a gamma-gamma distribution.
  • Strong turbulence: Also characterized by a gamma-gamma distribution, but with more severe fluctuations.

These experimental datasets were used to create channel models for simulation, differing from purely synthetic turbulence models by incorporating real-world environmental effects.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Temporal Correlation is Key: The most significant insight is that treating received FSO signals as independent samples is suboptimal. The temporal correlation between consecutive signal samples, influenced by atmospheric turbulence, carries valuable information that can be exploited for better detection.
  • BiGRU's Advantage: The BiGRU architecture excels at capturing these temporal dependencies due to its ability to process sequences in both forward and backward directions, providing a richer understanding of the signal's history and context.
  • CSI-Free Detection: The proposed method's ability to achieve high performance without requiring Channel State Information (CSI) is a major practical advantage, as obtaining accurate CSI in real-world FSO systems can be challenging.
  • Turbulence Impact: The study clearly demonstrates that the severity of atmospheric turbulence directly impacts BER performance, with stronger turbulence leading to worse results across all detection methods.

Key Results

The proposed BiGRU-based signal detection method demonstrated significant improvements in BER performance compared to conventional methods (fixed threshold, fast blind detection, ML with perfect CSI) and a Multilayer Perceptron (MLP)-based detector.

  • Under weak turbulence (Channel 1): The BiGRU detector achieved approximately a 2 dB Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) gain over the MLP-based detector at a target BER of 10⁻⁶.
  • Under moderate turbulence (Channel 2): The gain increased to approximately 6 dB SNR at the same target BER of 10⁻⁶.
  • Under strong turbulence (Channel 3): The detector achieved a 6 dB SNR gain at a target BER of 10⁻⁴.
  • Overall: The BiGRU method outperformed conventional methods by more than one order of magnitude in BER under identical turbulence and SNR conditions.
  • Symbol Rate Impact: Interestingly, at higher symbol rates (10 Mbps vs. 1 Mbps), the system exhibited lower BER under turbulence. This counter-intuitive result is attributed to the fact that turbulence-induced fluctuations vary more slowly than the symbol rate, meaning that for a fixed symbol size, a higher transmission rate reduces the impact of these slower fluctuations on individual symbols.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study focuses on On-Off Keying (OOK) intensity modulation. The performance of the BiGRU detector with other modulation schemes (e.g., M-ary Pulse Amplitude Modulation - M-PAM) is not explored.
  • While experimental data was used for turbulence modeling, the specific experimental setup and its limitations are not extensively detailed.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest extending this work to other modulation schemes to assess the BiGRU detector's versatility.
  • Further investigation into optimizing the BiGRU architecture and its parameters for different turbulence conditions could yield even better performance.
  • Exploring the integration of this method with other FSO enhancement techniques could lead to more robust communication systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

In free space optical (FSO) communications, signals are affected by turbulence when transmitted through the atmosphere. Fluctuations in intensity caused by atmospheric turbulence lead to an increase in the bit error rate of FSO systems. Deep learning (DL), as a current research hotspot, offers a promising approach to improve the accuracy of signal detection. In this paper, we propose a signal detection method based on a bidirectional gated recurrent unit (BiGRU) neural network for FSO communications. The proposed detection method considers the temporal correlation of received signals due to the properties of the BiGRU neural network, which is not available in existing detection methods based on DL. In addition, the proposed detection method does not require channel state information (CSI) for channel estimation, unlike maximum likelihood (ML) detection technology with perfect CSI. Numerical results demonstrate that the proposed BiGRU-based detector achieves significant improvements in bit error rate (BER) performance compared with a multilayer perceptron (MLP)-based detector. Specifically, under weak turbulence conditions, the BiGRU-based detector achieves an approximate 2 dB signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) gain at a target BER of 10−6 compared to the MLP-based detector. Under moderate turbulence conditions, it achieves an approximate 6 dB SNR gain at the same target BER of 10−6. Under strong turbulence conditions, the proposed detector obtains a 6 dB SNR gain at a target BER of 10−4. Additionally, it outperforms conventional methods by more than one order of magnitude in BER under the same turbulence and SNR conditions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yi2025signal,
  author = {Zhenning Yi and Zhiyong Xu and Jianhua Li and Jingyuan Wang and Jiyong Zhao and Yang Su and Yimin Wang},
  title = {{A Signal Detection Method Based on BiGRU for FSO Communications with Atmospheric Turbulence}},
  booktitle = {Photonics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/photonics12100980},
}
Figure