A SHORT REVIEW ON STRUCTURAL DEFORMITY OF ORGAN- FROM GREEK ARAB TO CONTEMPORARY SCIENCE

Azizur Rahman, Mohammad Zulkifle, Muhammad Haseeb AslamJournal of Biological and Scientific Opinion 2019 · DOI

Abstract

The Greek Arab system of medicine is one of the ancient medical systems that has served humanity for thousands of years. Early Greek and Arab physicians described diseases, causes, and symptoms in a rational way, categorizing topics such as disturbances in temperament (Sue Mizaj), structural deformity (Sue Tarkib), and dissolution of continuity (Tafarruq Ittisal). This paper aims to provide a comprehensible review of the causes of structural deformities before, during, and after birth as described by Greek-Arab physicians and their understanding in the present era.

Introduction: Bridging the Conceptual Gap

Ancient medical systems often employ philosophical terminology that can seem opaque to the modern scientific community. This review addresses the "translation" gap between the Greek-Arab (Unani) medical tradition and contemporary science regarding Fasad-e-Shakl (structural deformity). By contextualizing ancient "powers" and "qualities" within the framework of DNA, mitosis, and embryogenesis, the authors demonstrate that historical medical knowledge often aligns with modern biological observations.

Methodology

This study is a qualitative literature review synthesizing classical Unani texts—most notably Ibn al-Quf’s 13th-century work Kitabul Umda Fil Jarahat and Avicenna’s Canon of Medicine. These descriptions are compared with modern medical textbooks on pathology, embryology, and genetics to identify functional precursors to modern biological mechanisms.

Conceptual Mapping: The "Powers" of Development

A central contribution of this review is the mapping of three primary Unani "powers" to modern biological processes:

  • Quwwat-e-Mughaiyera Ula (Primary Alterative Power): This corresponds to the integrity of chromosomal and genetic material.
  • Quwwat-e-Musawwira (Formative Power): This aligns with the differentiation of the three germ layers (ectoderm, mesoderm, and endoderm) that shape tissues during the critical 3rd to 8th weeks of gestation.
  • Quwwat-e-Namiya (Power of Growth): This relates to the three-dimensional expansion of organs following their initial formation.

Quantity vs. Quality in Genetic Defects

Ancient scholars distinguished between defects of Kammiyat (quantity) and Kaifiyat (quality). The paper links quantitative defects to numerical chromosomal abnormalities, such as Trisomy 21 or Turner syndrome. Conversely, qualitative defects are linked to issues such as improper chromosome uncoiling during mitosis. The authors argue that the ancient Greek description of "coldness and dryness" in the uterus affecting genetic material conceptually matches modern observations of disturbed prophase or metaphase, where chromosomes fail to line up correctly.

Clinical Parallels and Environmental Triggers

The failure of "formative power" provides a historical explanation for modern clinical conditions like Anencephaly (failure of neural tube closure) and Spina bifida. Beyond genetics, ancient medicine recognized the role of "weak nutritive power" and mineral deficiencies (calcium, magnesium, Vitamin A) in skeletal and organ growth retardation, mirroring modern nutritional science.

Furthermore, the review categorizes post-birth deformities into four modern-aligned types:

  1. Ducts and Channels: Including dilations (e.g., bile duct) or narrowing (stenosis).
  2. Cavities and Sacs: Changes in size (hydrocele) or occlusion (ventricular obstruction).
  3. Surface Defects: Loss of mucosal roughness (atrophy) or smoothness (xerosis).
  4. Size Diseases: Conditions like splenomegaly or liver cirrhosis.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While this review is conceptual and relies on the interpretation of translated historical terms, it highlights a surprising alignment between ancient rationalism and modern embryology. The authors suggest that this knowledge should be generalized to make it accessible for modern research. Future work could investigate whether specific Unani herbal treatments for "temperamental disturbances" actually interact with the epigenetic or metabolic pathways associated with the developmental defects described.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Greek Arab system of medicine is one of the ancient medical systems. This system is serving the humanity in health care services from thousands of years. In early era, the Greek and Arab physicians described diseases, causes of diseases as well as symptoms etc in rational way. They have explicated the topic related to disease separately like causes of Sue Mizaj (disturbances in temperament), Sue Tarkib (structural deformity) and Tafarruq Ittisal (dissolution of continuity). It is the need of hour to propagate and generalize their knowledge for further research and make it easy to understand. This paper aims to provide the comprehensible literatures of causes of structural deformities before, during and after birth described by the Greek Arab physicians and its understanding in present era.
BibTeX
@article{rahman2019short,
  author = {Azizur Rahman and Mohammad Zulkifle and Muhammad Haseeb Aslam},
  title = {{A SHORT REVIEW ON STRUCTURAL DEFORMITY OF ORGAN- FROM GREEK ARAB TO CONTEMPORARY SCIENCE}},
  journal = {Journal of Biological and Scientific Opinion},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.7897/2321-6328.072103},
}
Figure