A sensitivity study of radiative fluxes at the top of atmosphere to cloud-microphysics and aerosol parameters in the community atmosphere model CAM5

Chen Zhao, Xiaohong Liu, Yun Qian, Jin‐Ho Yoon, Zhangshuan Hou, Guang Lin, Sally McFarlane, Hailong Wang, Bowen Yang, Po‐Lun Ma, Huiping Yan, Jie Bao

TL;DR

This study quantifies how uncertainties in cloud microphysics and aerosol parameters within the CAM5 climate model affect the Earth's top-of-atmosphere radiative fluxes. They found that cloud processes, particularly ice-to-snow conversion, have a dominant influence on radiative fluxes, and that these effects are often geographically localized, offering crucial insights for improving climate model accuracy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately projecting future climate change hinges on understanding the Earth's energy balance, which is significantly influenced by clouds and aerosols. However, these components are incredibly complex and are represented in climate models using simplified parameterizations with inherent uncertainties. These uncertainties in model parameters are a major source of disagreement among climate projections. Specifically, this paper addresses the question of which specific cloud microphysics and aerosol parameters within the Community Atmosphere Model version 5 (CAM5) contribute most to the uncertainty in simulated radiative fluxes at the top of the atmosphere (TOA). Quantifying these sensitivities is a critical step towards reducing model uncertainty and improving climate predictions.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated sensitivity analysis (SA) framework. They used a quasi-Monte Carlo (QMC) sampling approach to efficiently explore the high-dimensional space of 16 selected uncertain parameters related to cloud microphysics and aerosols. This method ensures good dispersion of samples, avoiding the gaps and clumps that can occur with traditional Monte Carlo methods. For each of the 256 simulations generated by perturbing these parameters, they ran the CAM5 model to obtain output variables like net radiative flux (FNET).

The core of their analysis involved a generalized linear model (GLM). This statistical technique was used to evaluate the relationship between the input parameter perturbations and the output response variables. The GLM allows for the quantification of the contribution of each parameter (and their interactions) to the overall variance of FNET. This approach moves beyond simpler "one-at-a-time" (OAT) methods, which can miss important interactions and fail to explore the full parameter space.

Datasets

The study utilized the Community Atmosphere Model version 5 (CAM5), specifically release v5.1.02, configured for AMIP (Atmosphere Model Intercomparison Program) simulations. This configuration uses prescribed greenhouse gas concentrations and sea surface temperatures for the years 2000-2004. Emissions data from the IPCC AR5 estimates were also used. No new datasets were introduced; rather, the study focused on perturbing parameters within an existing, well-established climate model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cloud Dominance: The study strongly suggests that uncertainties in cloud processes, particularly cloud microphysics, are more influential on global mean radiative fluxes than uncertainties in aerosol emissions within the tested ranges. This highlights the critical need for improved cloud parameterizations in climate models.
  • Ice-to-Snow Conversion is Key: The "threshold size parameter related to auto-conversion of cloud ice to snow" (dcs) emerged as the single most influential parameter for global mean FNET. This points to a specific, crucial aspect of ice cloud formation that warrants further investigation and refinement.
  • Localized vs. Non-Local Impacts: Many parameters exhibit strong localized effects, meaning their influence is concentrated in specific geographic regions. However, some parameters also demonstrate non-local impacts, affecting radiative fluxes far from their primary region of influence, likely due to atmospheric transport and teleconnections.
  • Internal vs. External Parameters: While external factors like anthropogenic and natural emissions do affect regional FNET variance, the study found that internal model parameters (those related to physical processes within the model) generally have a stronger impact on the global mean FNET.
  • Interactions are Minor (for this set): For the 16 parameters studied, the interactions between them contributed a relatively small portion to the total FNET variance, suggesting that the primary drivers of uncertainty are individual parameters.

Key Results

  • Wide FNET Range: Perturbations of the 16 parameters caused the CAM5-simulated global annual mean FNET to range from -9.8 to 3.5 W m⁻², a significant deviation from the default value of 1.9 W m⁻².
  • Cloud Forcing Dominates Variance: Changes in net cloud forcing (CF) were found to dominate the global mean FNET variance, indicating that cloud processes are the primary source of uncertainty in radiative fluxes.
  • Parameter Contributions: The auto-conversion of cloud ice to snow (dcs) was the largest contributor to FNET variance (30.4%), followed by sub-grid vertical velocity (wsubmin, 26.8%) and sea-salt emissions (emis_SEAS, 12.6%).
  • GLM Accuracy: The GLM model was highly successful in reproducing CAM5 simulations, with R² values of 0.98-0.99 for FNET, FNETC, and CF, validating the statistical approach.
  • Spatial Heterogeneity: Figures 6-11 reveal substantial spatial variability in FNET variance, with some parameters showing distinct regional patterns of influence.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Perturbation Ranges: The authors acknowledge that the assigned perturbation ranges for emissions are selected for SA rather than definitive uncertainty quantification, and that different ranges could alter the results.
  • Prescribed SST: The study used prescribed sea surface temperatures (SSTs), meaning feedbacks between the ocean and atmosphere were not included in the analysis of radiative flux perturbations.
  • Focus on Specific Parameters: This study focused on 16 parameters as a first step. Other uncertain parameters in CAM5 could also influence FNET, and the framework could be extended to include them.
  • Radiative Forcing vs. Change: The study quantifies sensitivity to parameter changes, not necessarily the sensitivity of radiative forcing (i.e., the change from pre-industrial to present-day). Further investigation into this is suggested.
  • Model Dependence: While the findings are specific to CAM5, the authors suggest that such systematic studies are valuable for other GCMs and for guiding future measurement campaigns to reduce model uncertainty. They also emphasize the need for further research into cloud microphysics and sub-grid cloud variability.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study, we investigated the sensitivity of net radiative fluxes (FNET) at the top of atmosphere (TOA) to 16 selected uncertain parameters mainly related to the cloud microphysics and aerosol schemes in the Community Atmosphere Model version 5 (CAM5). We adopted a quasi-Monte Carlo (QMC) sampling approach to effectively explore the high-dimensional parameter space. The output response variables (e.g., FNET) are simulated using CAM5 for each parameter set, and then evaluated using the generalized linear model analysis. In response to the perturbations of these 16 parameters, the CAM5-simulated global annual mean FNET ranges from −9.8 to 3.5 W m−2 compared to 1.9 W m−2 with the default parameter values. Variance-based sensitivity analysis is conducted to show the relative contributions of individual parameter perturbations to the global FNET variance. The results indicate that the changes in the global mean FNET are dominated by changes in net cloud forcing (CF) within the parameter ranges being investigated. The threshold size parameter related to auto-conversion of cloud ice to snow is identified as one of the most influential parameters for FNET in CAM5 simulations. The strong heterogeneous geographic distribution of FNET variance shows that parameters have a clear localized effect over regions where they are acting. However, some parameters also have non-local impacts on FNET variance. Although external factors, such as perturbations of anthropogenic and natural emissions, largely affect FNET variance at the regional scale, their impact is weaker than that of model internal parameters in terms of simulating global mean FNET. The interactions among the 16 selected parameters contribute a relatively small portion to the total FNET variance over most regions of the globe. This study helps us better understand the parameter uncertainties in the CAM5 model, and thus provides information for further calibrating uncertain model parameters with the largest sensitivity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2013sensitivity,
  author = {Chen Zhao and Xiaohong Liu and Yun Qian and Jin‐Ho Yoon and Zhangshuan Hou and Guang Lin and Sally McFarlane and Hailong Wang and Bowen Yang and Po‐Lun Ma and Huiping Yan and Jie Bao},
  title = {{A sensitivity study of radiative fluxes at the top of atmosphere to cloud-microphysics and aerosol parameters in the community atmosphere model CAM5}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-13-10969-2013},
}
Figure