TL;DR
Researchers used the 2017 Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) data set to conduct the first-ever pulsar search at the extremely high frequency of 228 GHz (1.3 mm). While no new pulsars were discovered orbiting the Milky Way’s central black hole, the study established rigorous sensitivity limits and demonstrated that millimeter-wave observations are a viable—though currently limited—pathway to finding the "holy grail" of a pulsar-black hole binary.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Finding a pulsar in a tight orbit around Sagittarius A (Sgr A) is a top priority for observational astrophysics. Such a system would act as a precision "cosmic clock," allowing researchers to test General Relativity in the strongest gravity environment known, measuring the black hole's mass, spin, and quadrupole moment with unprecedented accuracy.
However, the Galactic Center is a "noisy" and "blurry" place. At standard radio frequencies (1–10 GHz), the dense interstellar medium causes extreme pulse scattering, smearing the signal until it's unrecognizable. Moving to higher frequencies (millimeter waves) virtually eliminates scattering, but introduces a new challenge: most pulsars have "steep spectra," meaning they become significantly fainter as the observing frequency increases. This paper explores whether the massive sensitivity of the EHT array can overcome this faintness to find the missing pulsars.
Methods
The authors analyzed data from the three most sensitive stations in the 2017 EHT campaign: ALMA (Chile), the Large Millimeter Telescope (LMT) (Mexico), and the IRAM 30m Telescope (Spain).
Because a pulsar orbiting a supermassive black hole would be moving at high velocities, its signal would be subject to significant Doppler shifts. To account for this, the team employed three distinct search pipelines:
- Fourier-domain Acceleration Search: Uses the
PRESTOsoftware to recover signals from pulsars whose period changes during the observation due to orbital motion. - Fast Folding Algorithm (FFA): Utilizing the
RIPTIDElibrary, this method is more sensitive to pulsars with longer periods or narrow duty cycles that Fourier methods might miss. - Single-Pulse Search: Designed to detect transient bursts, giant pulses, or Rotating Radio Transients (RRATs).
A key innovation was the use of simultaneity. Because the EHT observes the same target from multiple global sites, any real astrophysical candidate should appear in multiple telescopes at the same time, allowing the researchers to instantly reject local radio frequency interference (RFI).
Datasets
The study utilized the EHT 2017 Public Data Release, specifically the baseband voltage data from April 6, 7, and 11.
- Target: Sagittarius A* (the Galactic Center).
- Frequency: 228.1 GHz (1.3 mm wavelength).
- Bandwidth: 4 GHz (split into "high" and "low" 2 GHz bands).
- Phased ALMA: Acted as the primary "anchor" station due to its massive collecting area and superior sensitivity.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Scattering Trade-off: The paper confirms that at 228 GHz, scattering is negligible ($\approx 28 \mu s$), which is orders of magnitude smaller than the sampling interval. This proves that high-frequency searches are the only way to "see" through the Galactic Center's plasma.
- The Sensitivity Gap: Despite the lack of scattering, the search was only sensitive to a tiny sliver ($\lesssim 2.2\%$) of the estimated pulsar population in the Galactic Center. This is primarily due to the faintness of pulsars at 1.3 mm.
- Magnetars as Targets: While "normal" pulsars are faint at these frequencies, magnetars (like the known PSR J1745−2900) often have flatter spectra. The search was sensitive enough to detect such objects if they were in an active state.
- EHT as an RFI Filter: The global nature of the EHT provides a built-in mechanism for vetting candidates. The authors found thousands of "candidates" in individual station data that were easily dismissed because they didn't appear in the other stations.
Key Results
- No New Detections: No new pulsars or significant burst-like transients were found in the 2017 data.
- Sensitivity Limits: The search reached a minimum detectable flux density of $\sim 0.01$ mJy for phased ALMA, $\sim 0.4$ mJy for IRAM 30m, and $\sim 1$ mJy for LMT.
- Population Coverage: Simulations showed that the search could only have detected the very brightest pulsars. For a standard pulsar population model, the "detection fraction" was only 0.1% to 4.1% depending on the station and assumed spectral index.
- PSR J1745−2900: The known magnetar near Sgr A* was not detected, likely because it was in a "weak-emission" state during the 2017 observations.
Limitations and Future Work
The primary limitation was the limited sensitivity of the 2017 array compared to the intrinsic faintness of pulsars at 1.3 mm. Additionally, the Field of View of phased ALMA is extremely small (1"–2"), meaning any pulsars slightly further from Sgr A* would have been missed.
Future Directions: * Increased Bandwidth: Future EHT iterations (next-generation EHT or ngEHT) will record at much higher data rates and wider bandwidths, significantly lowering the detection threshold. * Coherent Summing: Instead of searching stations individually, future work could coherently sum the signals from the entire EHT array to create a "tied-array beam" with the sensitivity of a 100-meter-class telescope. * Lower Frequencies: The authors suggest that the "sweet spot" for Galactic Center pulsar searches might be between 20 and 80 GHz, where scattering is still manageable but pulsars are naturally brighter.
Summary updated