A scaling law describes the spin-glass response in theory, experiments and simulations

I. Paga, Qiang Zhai, Marco Baity‐Jesi, Enrico Calore, J. M. Gil-Narvion, A. Gordillo-Guerrero, D. Íñiguez, A. Maiorano, Enzo Marinari, V. Martı́n-Mayor, J. Moreno-Gordo, A. Muñoz Sudupe, D. Navarro, R. Orbach, Giorgio Parisi, S. Pérez-Gaviro, Federico Ricci‐Tersenghi, J. J. Ruiz-Lorenzo, Sebastiano Fabio Schifano, Beatriz Seoane, A. Tarancón, R. Tripiccione, David Yllanes, A. Cruz, L. A. FernándezLibrary 2021

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new scaling law that unifies the description of spin-glass dynamics across experiments and simulations, resolving long-standing discrepancies observed at high magnetic fields or near the glass transition temperature. By successfully testing this law on both a CuMn single crystal and large-scale simulations, the authors provide a powerful new tool for understanding glassy behavior.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The slowing down of dynamics as materials approach their glass transition temperature ($T_g$) is a fundamental puzzle in condensed matter physics. For spin glasses, this phenomenon is often described by a growing correlation length ($\xi$), which represents the size of cooperative regions. While theorists often study correlation functions, experimentalists typically measure the system's response to an applied magnetic field. Historically, these approaches have yielded conflicting results, particularly when dealing with strong magnetic fields or temperatures very close to $T_g$. Existing analysis methods, even those attempting to bridge theory and experiment, break down in these critical regimes. This paper aims to resolve this discrepancy by proposing a universal scaling law that accurately describes the spin-glass response across a wide range of conditions.

Methods

The core of this work is the development and validation of a new scaling law for the spin-glass response. The authors derive this law by considering the magnetic field's influence on the free-energy barriers that govern glassy dynamics. They then test this law using two primary approaches:

  • Experimental Measurements: They performed measurements on a single crystal of Cu$_{94}$Mn$_6$ using a DC SQUID magnetometer. The use of a single crystal is crucial as it allows for a much larger correlation length compared to polycrystalline samples, enabling them to probe the critical regime more effectively.
  • Large-Scale Numerical Simulations: They conducted extensive simulations of the Ising-Edwards-Anderson (IEA) model on the custom-built Janus II supercomputer. This model is a simplified representation of spin glasses, and the large-scale simulations allow for the exploration of dynamics over long time scales and in various magnetic field strengths.

The key innovation lies in the proposed scaling law itself, which incorporates both the magnetic field and the time-dependent correlation length. They also employ dimensional analysis to relate experimental and simulation units, and a polynomial fit to experimental data to extract relevant coefficients.

Datasets

The paper utilizes two main sources of data:

  • Experimental Data: Measurements from a Cu$_{94}$Mn$_6$ single crystal. The specific experimental parameters (temperature, waiting time, magnetic field range) are detailed in Table I.
  • Numerical Simulation Data: Results from large-scale simulations of the Ising-Edwards-Anderson model. The parameters for these simulations, including the effective replicon exponent and a key constant $C_{peak}$, are provided in Table II.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the paper focuses on unifying existing experimental and simulation data under a single theoretical framework.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Unified Scaling Law: The most significant insight is the development of a scaling law that successfully describes the spin-glass response across a broad range of magnetic fields and temperatures, including the previously problematic regimes near $T_g$.
  • Beyond the $H^2$ Approximation: The paper highlights that simpler models, which only consider the $H^2$ dependence of the magnetic field's effect, fail in critical regimes. The new scaling law accounts for higher-order terms, which become dominant when the correlation length is large.
  • Bridging Theory and Experiment: The work demonstrates a remarkable agreement between experimental results from a real material and simulations of a simplified theoretical model, underscoring the universality of the observed scaling behavior.
  • Importance of Single Crystals: The use of a single crystal in experiments was crucial for achieving a large correlation length, which is necessary to test the scaling law in the regime where it differs most significantly from previous approximations.

Key Results

  • The proposed scaling law provides a striking data collapse for both experimental and numerical data, as visualized in Figures 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8. This collapse indicates that the law accurately captures the underlying physics.
  • The authors show that previous analyses, which relied on approximate scaling laws, deteriorate significantly when tested against the full range of data, particularly in the appendix where alternative scaling laws are examined.
  • The work validates the effectiveness of large-scale simulations on custom hardware (Janus II) for tackling complex problems in statistical mechanics, enabling the generation of data that would be prohibitively expensive otherwise.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Approximation in the Scaling Law: The authors note that for simplicity, they have neglected a correction of order $\xi^{-\theta/2}$ in the $H^2$ term of Eq. (1). While this simplification allows for a good collapse, it implies that the scaling law is an approximation.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that this unified framework will allow them to address more complex phenomena in glassy systems, such as rejuvenation (temperature chaos) and memory effects. They also point out the broad applicability of their findings to other fields that utilize complex system modeling, such as econophysics, biology, and optimization.

Summary updated

Abstract

The correlation length xi, a key quantity in glassy dynamics, can now be precisely measured for spin glasses both in experiments and in simulations. However, known analysis methods lead to discrepancies either for large external fields or close to the glass temperature. We solve this problem by introducing a scaling law that takes into account both the magnetic field and the time-dependent spin-glass correlation length. The scaling law is successfully tested against experimental measurements in a CuMn single crystal and against large-scale simulations on the Janus II dedicated computer.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{paga2021scaling,
  author = {I. Paga and Qiang Zhai and Marco Baity‐Jesi and Enrico Calore and J. M. Gil-Narvion and A. Gordillo-Guerrero and D. Íñiguez and A. Maiorano and Enzo Marinari and V. Martı́n-Mayor and J. Moreno-Gordo and A. Muñoz Sudupe and D. Navarro and R. Orbach and Giorgio Parisi and S. Pérez-Gaviro and Federico Ricci‐Tersenghi and J. J. Ruiz-Lorenzo and Sebastiano Fabio Schifano and Beatriz Seoane and A. Tarancón and R. Tripiccione and David Yllanes and A. Cruz and L. A. Fernández},
  title = {{A scaling law describes the spin-glass response in theory, experiments and simulations}},
  booktitle = {Library},
  year = {2021},
}
Figure