A Scaling Function for the Particle Entanglement Entropy of Fermions

Harini Radhakrishnan, Matthias Thamm, Hatem Barghathi, Bernd Rosenow, Adrian Del Maestro

Abstract

Entanglement entropy under a particle bipartition provides complementary information to mode entanglement as it is sensitive to interactions and particle statistics at leading order and does not depend on any externally imposed length scale. In this paper, we investigate the particle entanglement entropy in a system of $N$ interacting spinless lattice fermions in one spatial dimension by combining bosonization techniques with exact and approximate numerical methods. We introduce a general scaling form for the fermionic particle entanglement entropy captured by a shape function that enters as a extensive interaction induced correction to a known free fermion result. A general asymptotic expansion in the total number of particles demonstrates that its form is robust for different values of the Rényi index and highlights how quantum correlations are encoded in the $n$-particle density matrix of a pure many-body quantum state.

Introduction: Redefining Quantum Entanglement

In quantum many-body physics, entanglement is typically quantified through mode entanglement, which involves partitioning a system into two spatial regions. However, a more fundamental perspective is offered by particle entanglement. Instead of dividing space, this approach partitions the particles themselves—for instance, measuring the entanglement between $n$ specific fermions and the remaining $N-n$ particles in a system.

Visualizing particle partitions for n=1, 2, and 3 in a one-dimensional system.

Particle entanglement is uniquely sensitive to particle statistics and interactions without the need for an arbitrary spatial boundary. While the behavior of "free" (non-interacting) fermions has been well-documented, the impact of interactions on this entropy has remained a significant theoretical challenge. This research identifies a universal scaling law that describes how interactions boost particle entanglement across varying system sizes and interaction strengths.

Methodology and the J-V Model

The researchers investigated a system of spinless fermions on a 1D lattice, governed by the $J-V$ model, where $J$ represents the hopping amplitude and $V$ the nearest-neighbor interaction strength. The study focused on the Luttinger Liquid phase, a critical state where the system's behavior is dominated by collective excitations.

Phase diagram of the spinless fermion model, highlighting the Luttinger Liquid regime between the Clustered Solid and Charged Density Wave phases.

To analyze this model, the team employed a multi-pronged approach:

  1. Analytical Bosonization: Used to derive exact asymptotic expansions for the entanglement entropy in the $1/N$ limit.
  2. Numerical Simulations: High-precision data was generated using Exact Diagonalization (ED) for small systems and Density Matrix Renormalization Group (DMRG) for larger systems (up to 80 sites), utilizing the ITensors.jl library.

The Universal Scaling Law

The core discovery of this work is a general scaling form for the fermionic particle entanglement entropy ($S_\alpha$):

$$S_\alpha = \ln \binom{N}{n} + N\Phi\left(\sin \frac{n\pi}{N}\right)$$

In this equation, $\ln \binom{N}{n}$ represents the known entropy for free fermions. The second term, $N\Phi$, is an extensive interaction-induced correction. The "shape function" $\Phi$ captures how quantum correlations grow with the system size $N$ at a fixed ratio of $n/N$.

Key findings regarding this scaling law include:

  • Universality: The functional form of the scaling remains robust across different Rényi indices ($\alpha$), indicating that the structure of particle entanglement is a fundamental property of the quantum state.
  • Linear Growth: For small particle subsets ($n \ll N$), the interaction-induced entanglement increases linearly with $n$.
  • Saddle-Point Geometry: The shape function $\Phi$ exhibits a "saddle" geometry when plotted against interaction strength and particle ratio, reflecting the underlying competition between attractive and repulsive forces.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research provides a definitive mathematical recipe for understanding how interactions shape the entanglement of fermions. By extracting coefficients for the $1/N$ expansion with precision up to $10^{-7}$, the team has established a new benchmark for many-body theory.

While currently limited to 1D Luttinger liquids, the extensive nature of this scaling suggests potential applicability in higher dimensions. Future work may explore non-integrable systems or the more complex "boson problem," where the leading terms of particle entanglement are less universal. This progress in quantifying quantum information packaging is essential for the future design of quantum materials and information processing protocols.

Summary updated

Abstract

Entanglement entropy under a particle bipartition provides complementary information to mode entanglement as it is sensitive to interactions and particle statistics at leading order and does not depend on any externally imposed length scale. In this paper, we investigate the particle entanglement entropy in a system of $N$ interacting spinless lattice fermions in one spatial dimension by combining bosonization techniques with exact and approximate numerical methods. We introduce a general scaling form for the fermionic particle entanglement entropy captured by a shape function that enters as a extensive interaction induced correction to a known free fermion result. A general asymptotic expansion in the total number of particles demonstrates that its form is robust for different values of the Rényi index and highlights how quantum correlations are encoded in the $n$-particle density matrix of a pure many-body quantum state.
BibTeX
@article{radhakrishnan2023scaling,
  author = {Harini Radhakrishnan and Matthias Thamm and Hatem Barghathi and Bernd Rosenow and Adrian Del Maestro},
  title = {{A Scaling Function for the Particle Entanglement Entropy of Fermions}},
  journal = {Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1088/1742-5468/ace430},
}
Figure