A Review of Surface Treatments for Sliding Bearings Used at Different Temperature

Jun Cao, Liang Qin, Aibing Yu, H. Huang, Guoping Li, Zhongwei Yin, Huiyu ZhouIntechOpen 2019 · DOI

Abstract

The boundary lubrication and dry friction of plain bearings at different work temperature are unable to be avoided under the start and stop condition. The poor lubrication is one reason of bearing broken. In order to improve the tribological properties and select the best treatment for different bearings used at different temperature, the studies of different treatment technologies are reviewed in this paper. The review shows that the shortages of bonding fiber woven materials, inlaying solid lubricating materials, electro plating and magnetron sputtering are poor temperature resistance, low load capacity, environment pollution and low production efficiencies respectively. Based on the analyses and summaries, the liquid dope spraying and thermal powder spraying are suggested to deposit coating on the surface of bearing which working temperature is lower than 200 and above 800°C respectively. However, the technology processes, the mechanisms of spraying and self-lubrication materials should be studied further and deeply.

Introduction: The Critical Role of Sliding Bearings

Sliding bearings are essential components in heavy machinery, facilitating smooth motion in diverse applications ranging from marine diesel engines to aerospace propulsion systems. As shown in Figure 1, these bearings take various forms, such as split plain bearings or integral sliding bearings, depending on their specific industrial use.

Applications and types of sliding bearings in heavy machinery

Despite their ubiquity, sliding bearings face severe operational challenges. The most critical moments occur during start-up and shutdown cycles. During these phases, a protective hydrodynamic oil film has not yet formed, leading to boundary lubrication or direct metal-to-metal contact (dry friction).

The Challenge of Extreme Environments

In modern industrial settings, "serious conditions" are becoming the norm. Automobile engines can reach temperatures of 200°C, while specialized equipment like missile launching mechanisms may exceed 800°C. At these extremes, conventional lubricants fail, leading to rapid wear and catastrophic failure, often referred to as "bearing broken" scenarios (see Figure 2).

Surface damage and wear on sliding bearings due to poor lubrication

The urgent need is to identify surface treatments that provide self-lubricating properties across this wide temperature spectrum while remaining environmentally safe and commercially viable for mass production.

Comparative Analysis of Surface Treatments

This review synthesizes findings from 85 sources to categorize technologies based on their operational temperature ranges:

Room Temperature Solutions

Traditional methods include adhesive fabric liners (e.g., Kevlar/PTFE) and inlaid solid lubricants like graphite or MoS₂. While effective at low temperatures, inlaying solid lubricants requires drilling into the bearing substrate, which weakens the mechanical structure and reduces overall load capacity.

Medium Temperature (up to 200°C)

  • Electroplating: The current industry standard, but highly criticized for environmental pollution due to toxic plating solutions.
  • Magnetron Sputtering: Produces high-quality, dense films with excellent bonding. However, its low production efficiency—taking over 20 hours for a 10μm film—makes it unsuitable for high-volume automotive manufacturing.
  • Liquid Dope Spraying: Identified as a "green" and efficient alternative. It can be applied in seconds and achieves low porosity (as low as 0.35%).

High Temperature (>800°C)

At temperatures exceeding 800°C, organic binders in liquid dopes decompose.

  • Supersonic Flame Spraying (HVOF): This method stands out by launching molten alloy powders at 500 m/s. It creates exceptionally high-strength bonds (up to 72.63 MPa) and enables the use of durable ceramics like WC and SiC.

Key Results and Recommendations

The performance of these treatments varies significantly across metrics:

  • Coefficient of Friction (CoF): Liquid dope coatings (MoS₂/PTFE) achieve a CoF of approximately 0.125. In contrast, high-temperature composites at 800°C range from 0.26 to 0.8.
  • Bond Strength: Supersonic flame spraying offers superior adhesive strength (~72 MPa) compared to chemical deposition methods.
  • Porosity: Modern spraying techniques significantly outperform traditional powder metallurgy, which often suffers from oxidation and uneven microstructures.

Recommendations: The authors suggest liquid dope spraying for applications below 200°C and thermal powder spraying for those above 800°C.

Future Outlook

While progress has been made, several gaps remain:

  1. Theoretical Understanding: The "sagging and leveling" mechanisms of liquid coatings during spraying require deeper analysis.
  2. Universal Lubricants: No single material currently provides continuous self-lubrication from room temperature to 800°C.
  3. Process Optimization: Further research is needed into optimum curing temperatures and substrate preparation.
  4. Scalability: High-performance treatments like magnetron sputtering are currently limited by vacuum chamber sizes, hindering their use for large-scale marine bearings.

Summary updated

Abstract

The boundary lubrication and dry friction of plain bearings at different work temperature are unable to be avoided under the start and stop condition. The poor lubrication is one reason of bearing broken. In order to improve the tribological properties and select the best treatment for different bearings used at different temperature, the studies of different treatment technologies are reviewed in this paper. The review shows that the shortages of bonding fiber woven materials, inlaying solid lubricating materials, electro plating and magnetron sputtering are poor temperature resistance, low load capacity, environment pollution and low production efficiencies respectively. Based on the analyses and summaries, the liquid dope spraying and thermal powder spraying are suggested to deposit coating on the surface of bearing which working temperature is lower than 200 and above 800°C respectively. However, the technology processes, the mechanisms of spraying and self-lubrication materials should be studied further and deeply.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cao2019review,
  author = {Jun Cao and Liang Qin and Aibing Yu and H. Huang and Guoping Li and Zhongwei Yin and Huiyu Zhou},
  title = {{A Review of Surface Treatments for Sliding Bearings Used at Different Temperature}},
  booktitle = {IntechOpen},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.5772/intechopen.86304},
}
Figure