A review of research on STEM preservice teacher education (Work in Progress)

Yingqian Zhang, Jiabin Zhu2024 · DOI

Abstract

With the development of STEM education, various research has found that high-quality STEM teacher played an indispensable role in cultivating STEM talents. For the important role of STEM preservice teacher, it is necessary to systematically investigate the existing literature to obtain a clear understanding of the research status and trends. Based on this, systematic literature analysis was used to examine the articles that related to STEM preservice teacher education in this study. The researchers developed rigorous literature selection criteria and procedures to finally obtain 166 articles on STEM preservice teacher education which published between 2012 and 2021 from Web of Science database. CiteSpace software was used for further visualization and cluster analysis to analyze the knowledge base, research frontier, research hotspots, and research trends. Preliminary findings suggested that though the research of STEM preservice teacher education has a short history, it shows an upward trend. Although the basic theory and cutting-edge knowledge do not reflect unified conclusions, there are obvious clusters in the research hotspots, and reflect some research trends.

Introduction

High-quality STEM education serves as a critical engine for modern innovation, with teachers acting as the primary drivers. However, "STEM" is frequently utilized as a broad buzzword rather than a unified pedagogical framework. For researchers and policymakers, a significant challenge lies in understanding the current "state of the art" regarding the training of preservice teachers. Because this field is relatively nascent and inherently interdisciplinary, the existing literature is often fragmented across various journals and subject areas. This study addresses this fragmentation by systematically reviewing 166 core articles to identify key contributors, publication venues, and emerging research frontiers.

Methodology

The study employed bibliometric and content analysis, primarily utilizing the CiteSpace visualization tool. The researchers queried the Web of Science (WOS) database for terms related to "STEM" and "preservice teacher." While the initial search spanned from 1986 to 2021, the analysis revealed that the vast majority of relevant scholarly work emerged within the last decade. Consequently, the final sample was refined to 166 high-quality articles published between 2012 and 2021. CiteSpace was used to generate co-citation and keyword co-occurrence maps, providing a mathematical visualization of how research clusters have evolved over time.

Results and Analysis

The analysis reveals that research in STEM preservice teacher education is experiencing exponential growth. As shown in Figure 3, the annual publication count rose from just 2 articles in 2012 to 49 in 2021. The statistical model applied to this data ($R^2 = 0.979$) suggests a strong, continuing upward trend, indicating that the field is transitioning from a niche area to a mainstream educational research priority.

Annual growth of publications on STEM preservice teacher education (2012–2021).

The literature is concentrated in several high-impact journals. The top venues for this research include School Science and Mathematics and the Journal of Science Education and Technology, both of which have published a significant portion of the core literature in this domain.

Top journals publishing research on STEM preservice teacher education.

Research Hotspots and Frontiers

The bibliometric mapping identified several key shifts in the research landscape:

  • The "Silo" Struggle: Despite the goal of integrated STEM, research frontiers remain dominated by single-subject training (e.g., mathematics or chemistry education). Achieving true interdisciplinary integration remains a primary challenge for the field.
  • Psychological Shift: Between 2017 and 2021, there has been a notable shift toward psychological factors. Keywords such as "self-efficacy" and "perception" have become hotspots, indicating that a teacher's confidence in their STEM abilities is now considered as vital as their content knowledge.
  • Emerging Technologies: Robotics and computational thinking have emerged as major research clusters, signaling a move from traditional laboratory sciences toward the integration of computer science and engineering practices in teacher preparation.

Discussion and Limitations

As a work in progress, this study acknowledges certain limitations. The reliance on the Web of Science database may exclude relevant work found in other repositories like Scopus or ERIC. Furthermore, while the study maps what is being studied, further depth is needed to evaluate the effectiveness of the various training models identified.

Future research should aim to move beyond "single-subject" silos and focus on the microscopic aspects of classroom practice—specifically, how to transition from theoretical frameworks to actual integrated STEM teaching in real-world environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the development of STEM education, various research has found that high-quality STEM teacher played an indispensable role in cultivating STEM talents.For the important role of STEM preservice teacher, it is necessary to systematically investigate the existing literature to obtain a clear understanding of the research status and trends.Based on this, systematic literature analysis was used to examine the articles that related to STEM preservice teacher education in this study.The researchers developed rigorous literature selection criteria and procedures to finally obtain 166 articles on STEM preservice teacher education which published between 2012 and 2021 from Web of Science database.CiteSpace software was used for further visualization and cluster analysis to analyze the knowledge base, research frontier, research hotspots, and research trends.Preliminary findings suggested that though the research of STEM preservice teacher education has a short history, it shows an upward trend.Although the basic theory and cutting-edge knowledge do not reflect unified conclusions, there are obvious clusters in the research hotspots, and reflect some research trends.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2024review,
  author = {Yingqian Zhang and Jiabin Zhu},
  title = {{A review of research on STEM preservice teacher education (Work in Progress)}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.18260/1-2--41159},
}
Figure