A real-time analysis of rock fragmentation using UAV technology

Thomas Bamford, Kamran Esmaeili, Angela P. SchoelligarXiv 2016 · arXiv

Introduction

In the mining industry, the size distribution of rocks following a blast—known as fragmentation—is a critical Key Performance Indicator (KPI). Proper fragmentation is essential for operational efficiency; oversized rocks can damage hauling equipment and cause bottlenecks at primary crushers, while excessive "fines" (very small particles) indicate wasted explosive energy and increased processing costs. Traditionally, measuring this distribution has been a choice between the highly accurate but labor-intensive sieve analysis and manual 2D image analysis, which is faster but often lacks spatial resolution and exposes technicians to hazardous environments.

This paper presents a proof-of-concept system designed to automate rock fragmentation analysis using quadrotor Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs). By integrating an autonomous aerial pipeline with industry-standard analysis software, the researchers achieved a significant reduction in data collection time while maintaining accuracy levels suitable for industrial application.

System Architecture and Methodology

The proposed system leverages a sophisticated software and hardware stack to move from image capture to data output in near real-time. The core of the flight control and data management is built on the Robot Operating System (ROS), which coordinates the UAV's movements and image streaming.

The integrated system architecture, illustrating the data flow between the Global Positioning System, ROS, MATLAB, and Image Analysis Software.

The experimental setup utilized a Parrot Bebop 2 quadrotor. To simulate a reliable positioning environment indoors, a Vicon motion capture system consisting of ten cameras was employed to track reflective markers on the UAV, effectively serving as an "indoor GPS." The workflow follows a structured path:

  1. Autonomous Flight: The UAV follows a predefined path, capturing high-resolution images at varying altitudes with a 50% overlap to ensure comprehensive coverage.
  2. Data Streaming: Images are streamed to a ground workstation.
  3. Automated Processing: Using MATLAB for data management and Split-Desktop for image processing, the system automatically delineates particle boundaries.
  4. Statistical Analysis: The resulting data is fitted to a Swebrec function to generate particle size distribution curves.

Experimental Results

The system was validated in a laboratory setting using a custom-built rock pile of known composition. A ground truth was established through traditional sieve analysis, against which the UAV-based results (16 automated photos) and a manual "fixed-camera" baseline (11 manual photos) were compared.

UAV image acquisition at different altitudes (a, c) and the resulting rock fragmentation segmentation (b, d) used for size distribution analysis.

Efficiency and Speed

The most striking result was the gain in operational efficiency. The manual image collection and analysis process took approximately 55 minutes and 52 seconds. In contrast, the automated UAV pipeline completed the entire cycle—from setup to the final export of distribution data—in just 10 minutes and 2 seconds. This represents an ~82% reduction in time effort, or a 5x speedup in data throughput.

Accuracy and Consistency

The UAV method demonstrated high accuracy, predicting the rock size distribution within 17% of the sieve analysis ground truth. Furthermore, it remained within 6% of the results obtained via manual image analysis. While individual frames from the UAV showed higher variance than curated manual shots—likely due to the lack of human "curation" of the angles—the system's ability to aggregate a larger volume of data quickly allowed the cumulative results to stabilize and provide a reliable statistical representation of the muck pile.

Discussion and Key Insights

The research highlights several advantages of an autonomous aerial approach:

  • Data Aggregation: The "more is better" effect suggests that the speed of UAV collection allows for a higher sampling frequency, which can compensate for the lack of human curation in individual images.
  • Safety: By utilizing "expendable" UAV hardware, mining operations can remove human technicians from the "muck pile," a high-risk zone characterized by unstable ground and proximity to heavy machinery.
  • Real-Time Feedback: The rapid turnaround of fragmentation data enables "on-the-fly" adjustments to downstream milling operations or future blast designs, a capability currently hindered by the lag in manual reporting.

Conclusion and Future Work

While successful as a proof-of-concept, the system faces challenges in transitioning to full-scale mining environments. The researchers noted "edge effects" where the boundaries of the laboratory bin were occasionally misidentified as large fragments. Future iterations will focus on replacing physical scale objects with onboard sensors such as LiDAR or stereo cameras for calibration. Additionally, implementing Simultaneous Localization and Mapping (SLAM) will be necessary for operation in GPS-denied or high-dust environments typical of active mine sites.

Summary updated

Abstract

Accurate measurement of blast-induced rock fragmentation is of great importance for many mining operations. The post-blast rock size distribution can significantly influence the efficiency of all the downstream mining and comminution processes. Image analysis methods are one of the most common methods used to measure rock fragment size distribution in mines regardless of criticism for lack of accuracy to measure fine particles and other perceived deficiencies. The current practice of collecting rock fragmentation data for image analysis is highly manual and provides data with low temporal and spatial resolution. Using UAVs for collecting images of rock fragments can not only improve the quality of the image data but also automate the data collection process. Ultimately, real-time acquisition of high temporal- and spatial-resolution data based on UAV technology will provide a broad range of opportunities for both improving blast design without interrupting the production process and reducing the cost of the human operator. This paper presents the results of a series of laboratory-scale rock fragment measurements using a quadrotor UAV equipped with a camera. The goal of this work is to highlight the benefits of aerial fragmentation analysis in terms of both prediction accuracy and time effort. A pile of rock fragments with different fragment sizes was placed in a lab that is equipped with a motion capture camera system for precise UAV localization and control. Such an environment presents optimal conditions for UAV flight and thus, is well-suited for conducting proof-of-concept experiments before testing them in large-scale field experiments. The pile was photographed by a camera attached to the UAV, and the particle size distribution curves were generated in almost real-time. The pile was also manually photographed and the results of the manual method were compared to the UAV method.
BibTeX
@misc{bamford2016real,
  author = {Thomas Bamford and Kamran Esmaeili and Angela P. Schoellig},
  title = {{A real-time analysis of rock fragmentation using UAV technology}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1607.04243},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1607.04243},
}
Figure