A Numerical Method for Nonlinear Simulation of 2-D Body Motions in Waves by means of B. E. M.

Katsuji Tanizawa, Hiroshi SawadaJournal of the Society of Naval Architects of Japan 1990 · DOI

Abstract

A numerical method for the two-dimensional full nonlinear Radiation-Diffraction problem is developed to simulate the motions of arbitrary shaped 2-D floating bodies in waves. The mixed Eulerian-Lagrangian method is utilized for the free surface. To calculate accurate hydrodynamic pressure on the body surface—and thus accurate body acceleration—both the velocity and acceleration fields are solved in combination with the equations of body motion. This approach maintains dynamic equilibrium between the fluid and the floating body at every time step. The Boundary Element Method (BEM) is employed to solve the field equations. Validation against experimental data for a midship section and a flare-shaped body shows excellent agreement.

Introduction: The Challenge of Nonlinear Wave Interaction

Predicting the behavior of ships in extreme sea states is a cornerstone of naval architecture. When waves are large, the traditional "small amplitude" linear assumptions fail to capture the complex physics at play. Accurately modeling these nonlinear interactions requires calculating the precise hydrodynamic pressure on the hull. However, a circular dependency exists: hydrodynamic pressure depends on the ship's acceleration, while the acceleration is driven by that same pressure.

Previous numerical approaches often decoupled these elements, solving for individual motion modes (Heave, Sway, Roll) separately. While functional, this "mode-by-mode" decomposition is computationally expensive, requiring multiple matrix inversions per time step.

Methodology: Achieving Dynamic Equilibrium

The researchers propose a more efficient "one-shot" solution using the Boundary Element Method (BEM) coupled with a Mixed Eulerian-Lagrangian (MEL) approach for free-surface tracking.

The innovation lies in the treatment of the acceleration field. Instead of relying on backward-difference approximations to estimate pressure, the authors integrate the BEM matrix for the acceleration field directly with the three-degree-of-freedom equations of motion. By solving this unified system, the model maintains a perfect "dynamic equilibrium" at every step. This ensures that the fluid forces and the body's resulting acceleration are perfectly synchronized, which is vital for simulating high-frequency or unstable motions.

The simulation assumes potential flow (inviscid and incompressible fluid) and utilizes the Adams-Bashforth method for stable time integration.

Experimental Validation

To validate the numerical model, the authors compared their results with physical towing tank experiments conducted at the Ship Research Institute in Japan. Two distinct hull geometries were tested:

  1. Midship Section: A standard rectangular-like hull with rounded corners.
  2. Flare-Shaped Model: A hull with significant outward-sloping sides, designed to test stability changes during large vertical excursions.
Geometric dimensions of the Midship and Flare sections used for validation.

Key Results and Discussion

The numerical results demonstrated a high degree of fidelity when compared to experimental measurements.

Motion Accuracy

For the midship section, the calculated amplitudes for Heave and Roll were in nearly perfect alignment with the tank test data. The model successfully captured the transient response as the incident wave reached the body.

Comparison between numerical calculations (solid line) and experimental data (dotted line) for heave, sway, and roll motions of the midship section.

Parametric Rolling

A significant achievement of this method is its ability to simulate parametric rolling. This is a dangerous phenomenon where a ship's roll angle grows exponentially in regular waves due to periodic changes in stability. The model accurately replicated the transition to "half-frequency" oscillations, a hallmark of parametric resonance that linear models typically miss.

The Sway Drift Discrepancy

The researchers noted a slight discrepancy in "Sway drift" (the lateral movement of the ship). The numerical model slightly over-predicted this drift. This is attributed to the potential flow assumption; in reality, water viscosity leads to vortex shedding at the hull's sharp corners, creating damping forces that the current model does not account for.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This coupled BEM approach provides a robust framework for nonlinear ship motion simulation. It is approximately 1.5 times slower than simpler velocity-field simulations but offers the high-fidelity pressure data necessary for safety-critical stability analysis.

While the current 2D implementation is highly effective, future work will focus on:

  • Viscous Damping: Incorporating empirical or calculated viscous terms to better model lateral drift and roll damping.
  • 3D Expansion: Extending the coupled matrix approach to three-dimensional hull forms.
  • Computational Optimization: Refining time-stepping schemes to reduce the overhead required for long-duration simulations.

Summary updated

Abstract

A numerical method for the two dimensional full nonlinear Radiation-Diffraction problem is developed to simulate the motions of arbitrary shaped 2-D floating body in waves. The mixed Eulerian-Lagrangian method is utilized for the free surface. To calculate the accurate hydrodynamic pressure on the body surface, that is to calculate the accurate acceleration of body, both the velocity field and the acceleration field combined with the equations of body motions are solved. This method enables us to keep the dynamic equilibrium of forces between fluid and floating body on every time step. The Boundary Element Method (BEM) is used to solve the field equations.For illustration, two computational examples are presented in comparison with the experimental data : (i) a transient motion of midship section body in an incident wave ; (ii) a growth of parametric oscillation of roll motion of flare shaped body in a regular wave. These examples show that the computational results are in excellent agreement with measured body motions.
BibTeX
@article{tanizawa1990numerical,
  author = {Katsuji Tanizawa and Hiroshi Sawada},
  title = {{A Numerical Method for Nonlinear Simulation of 2-D Body Motions in Waves by means of B. E. M.}},
  journal = {Journal of the Society of Naval Architects of Japan},
  year = {1990},
  doi = {10.2534/jjasnaoe1968.1990.168\_221},
}
Figure