A novel quantitative method via the degree of transverse colon ptosis for chronic constipation assessment

Kongliang Sun, Qun Qian, Jinxiang Hu, Weicheng Liu, Yuntian Hong, Wenwen Zhang, Huixuan Xie, Bo Liu, Xianghai Ren, Changlei Xi, Hong Yan, Congqing Jiang, Xiaoyu XiemedRxiv 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Assessment of colonic transit has historically been subjective and qualitative. This study introduces the Luojia score, a quantitative metric derived from abdominal X-rays (AXR) to measure transverse colon ptosis (sagging). In a retrospective cohort of 368 patients, the Luojia score demonstrated high sensitivity and specificity in distinguishing between slow transit constipation (STC), obstructed defecation syndrome (ODS), and normal transit. Furthermore, the score correlates significantly with clinical symptom severity and psychological distress, suggesting it is a robust tool for objective constipation assessment.

Introduction

Chronic constipation affects approximately 18% of the global population, significantly impacting quality of life. Clinical management relies on distinguishing between subtypes, primarily Slow Transit Constipation (STC) and Obstructed Defecation Syndrome (ODS). However, current diagnostic "gold standards"—such as radiopaque marker tests, scintigraphy, or MRI—are often expensive, time-consuming, or provide only qualitative data.

There is a clinical need for a simple, inexpensive, and quantitative anatomical marker. This study proposes the Luojia score, which utilizes standard standing abdominal X-rays to quantify the degree of transverse colon ptosis as a proxy for functional impairment.

Methodology: The Luojia Score

The Luojia score is defined by the vertical displacement of the transverse colon. Using a standing AXR after barium ingestion, researchers identified fixed bony landmarks (the iliac crest and spine) to ensure reproducibility.

Two primary measurements are taken:

  1. SI: The vertical distance from the splenic flexure to the iliac crest.
  2. TI: The vertical distance from the lowest point of the transverse colon to the iliac crest.

The Luojia score is calculated as SI minus TI. A higher score indicates a greater degree of ptosis (sagging). This measurement captures the "Deep V" morphology often seen in chronic constipation patients.

Study Design and Population

The researchers conducted a retrospective cohort study at Zhongnan Hospital of Wuhan University, analyzing 368 adult patients treated between 2012 and 2019. The cohort was categorized into four groups based on established diagnostic criteria:

  • STC: 139 patients
  • ODS: 52 patients
  • Mixed: 52 patients
  • Normal Control: 125 patients

Clinical severity was assessed using the Wexner Constipation Scale (WCS), while psychological state was measured via the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS).

Key Results and Diagnostic Performance

The Luojia score proved to be a highly effective diagnostic differentiator:

  • Distinguishing STC: Patients with slow transit exhibited significantly higher Luojia scores (mean ~241 mm) compared to the normal group (mean ~118 mm). An optimal cut-off of 195 mm was identified, yielding a sensitivity of 93.7% and a specificity of 91.5% (AUC = 0.964).
  • Distinguishing ODS: For ODS, a cut-off of 140 mm was identified to differentiate patients from the normal group (AUC = 0.925).
  • Clinical Correlation: Among STC patients, the Luojia score showed a strong positive correlation with the Wexner Constipation Scale (r=0.618). This indicates that the physical degree of colon sagging directly reflects the severity of the patient's reported symptoms.
  • Psychological Correlation: A moderate correlation was found between the Luojia score and HADS-Anxiety (r=0.507), suggesting that physical gastrointestinal displacement may be linked to the patient's psychological well-being.

Discussion: Anatomy as a Functional Proxy

The study suggests a bidirectional relationship between colonic anatomy and transit function. Chronic stool retention increases the weight within the transverse colon, leading to progressive ptosis. This anatomical change creates a "Deep V" shape with sharp angles at the splenic flexure, which in turn increases the static energy required to move stool upward, creating a feedback loop that worsens constipation.

Furthermore, the correlation with anxiety scores highlights the "brain-gut" connection. The physical burden of severe ptosis and the resulting chronic symptoms appear to contribute significantly to patient psychological distress.

Conclusion

The Luojia score offers a precise, quantitative, and reproducible method for assessing chronic constipation. By utilizing standard X-ray technology, it provides a low-cost alternative to more complex transit tests while offering high diagnostic accuracy. While further multi-center prospective trials are necessary to validate these findings across broader populations, the Luojia score represents a significant step toward objective clinical assessment in gastroenterology.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT BACKGROUND Assessment of colonic transit tend to be more subjective and qualitative. This study aimed to evaluate the capability of our new quantitative scale to predict the subtypes of constipation and assess symptom severity of patients with slow transit constipation. METHODS A retrospective cohort population was assembled, consisting of adult patients with chronic constipation who underwent both colonic transit test and defecography between 2012 and 2019. Radiological parameters were measured on AXRs. The Luojia score was introduced to convey the vertical distance from the splenic flexure to the lowest point of the transverse colon, representing the degree of transverse colon ptosis. Patients with slow transit constipation only were especially required to complete the Wexner Constipation Scale (WCS) and Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) for clinical severity assessment. FINDINGS Of 368 patients, 191 patients (51·9%) showed slow colonic transit, and patients with slow colonic transit were more likely to have severe ptosis of the transverse colon on AXRs. Patients with slow colonic transit had a significantly higher Luojia score than those with normal colonic transit (p˂0·001). A cut-off of 195 mm was used to distinguish slow colonic transit. A significant difference in Luojia score was also found between patients with obstructed defecation syndrome and normal patients, and a cut-off of 140 mm was identified. In patients with slow transit constipation, there was a strong correlation between Luojia score and WCS (r=0·618) and a moderate correlation between Luojia score and HADS-Anxiety (r=0·507). These results indicated that the Luojia score is a reliable predictor of symptom severity and psychological condition in patients with slow transit constipation. INTERPRETATION The Luojia score might be a new quantitative, precise method in the assessment of constipation. FUNDING The National Natural Science Foundation of China and the Clinical Research Special Fund of Wu Jieping Medical Foundation. Research in context Evidence before this study We searched PubMed for papers published between Feb 1, 2000, and Jan 1, 2019, with the keywords “transverse colonic ptosis” OR “abdominal x-ray” AND “constipation” OR “colonic transit”. No restrictions on study type or language were implemented. Our search retrieved studies on the use of stool burden score on AXR in the assessment of constipation but no studies to use transverse colonic ptosis to evaluate colonic transit. Added value of this study We established a Luojia score which was defined as the vertical distance from the splenic flexure to the lowest point of transverse colon on the abdominal x-ray (AXR) that representing the degree of transverse colon ptosis. A retrospective cohort study of 368 patients proved that Luojia score has high sensitivity and specificity in distinguishing slow colonic transit and normal colonic transit as well as obstructed defecation syndrome and normal group. We were satisfied to found that in patients with slow transit constipation, there was a strong correlation between Luojia score and WCS (r=0·618) and a mediate correlation between Luojia score and HADS-A (r=0·507). Implications of all the available evidence Precise assessment and evaluation of colonic transit play an important role in clinical diagnosis and treatment of constipation patients. Our result proved that Luojia Score is a simple and effective assessment system of certain clinic value in in identifying patients with constipation and is a potential predictor of symptom severity.
BibTeX
@misc{sun2020novel,
  author = {Kongliang Sun and Qun Qian and Jinxiang Hu and Weicheng Liu and Yuntian Hong and Wenwen Zhang and Huixuan Xie and Bo Liu and Xianghai Ren and Changlei Xi and Hong Yan and Congqing Jiang and Xiaoyu Xie},
  title = {{A novel quantitative method via the degree of transverse colon ptosis for chronic constipation assessment}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.04.09.20059527},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure