A Median Arcuate Ligament Syndrome Could Be Re-termed as a Nutcracker Celiac Ganglion Abdominal Pain Syndrome

Ji Eun Kim, Mira Kang, Ok Soon Jeong, Poong‐Lyul RheeJournal of Neurogastroenterology and Motility 2023 · DOI

Abstract

We suggest renaming Median Arcuate Ligament Syndrome (MALS) as Nutcracker Celiac Ganglion Abdominal Pain Syndrome (NCGAPS) to better explain the mechanism of recurrent abdominal pain. Further studies on the diagnostic cutoff of clinical and radiological scores of NCGAPS are needed to avoid missing the diagnosis.

Introduction

Median Arcuate Ligament Syndrome (MALS) is a rare condition characterized by the compression of the celiac artery by the diaphragm's median arcuate ligament. Traditionally, the "ischemic hypothesis" has been used to explain the resulting chronic abdominal pain, suggesting it stems from restricted blood flow. However, this theory often fails to account for patients who exhibit anatomical compression without symptoms, or those whose pain fluctuates with posture and respiration rather than meals.

This paper proposes a shift in diagnostic focus from vascular compression to nerve entrapment, specifically the celiac ganglion. The authors suggest reclassifying the condition as Nutcracker Celiac Ganglion Abdominal Pain Syndrome (NCGAPS) to better reflect this "nutcracker" effect where the nerve center is squeezed against the artery.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective cohort study at Samsung Medical Center, focusing on patients who experienced recurrent abdominal pain even after undergoing a cholecystectomy.

Flowchart of patient selection and screening process.

The study developed the NCGAPS scoring system, which integrates clinical and radiological data using weighted values:

  • Clinical Components (Weighted 1–4): Positional or respirational pain (4 points), continuous pain (3 points), pain unrelated to meals/bowel movements (2 points), and frequent ER visits (1 point).
  • Radiological Components (Weighted 2–4): Post-stenotic dilatation (4 points) and celiac trunk indentation (2 points).

Patients were categorized into three groups based on their total score: non-suspicious (<5), weakly suspicious (6–13), and highly suspicious (≥14).

Key Insights and Ideas

The central thesis is that the pain associated with this syndrome is neuropathic rather than ischemic. The lack of tissue damage in the liver or stomach—which would typically follow chronic ischemia—supports the idea that the celiac ganglion is the primary driver of pain.

Comparison of normal anatomy versus the NCGAPS "nutcracker" mechanism.

The term NCGAPS highlights the entrapment of the ganglion between the ligament and the celiac trunk. The study found that weighting specific "pathognomonic" signs, such as pain changing with respiration or movement, was crucial for accurate differentiation.

Results

The NCGAPS scoring system demonstrated significant statistical power. Post-stenotic dilatation was significantly different across the three suspicion groups ($P < 0.001$). Clinical markers like positional/respirational pain and continuous pain were also highly effective in identifying high-risk patients ($P < 0.01$).

The median score for the "highly suspicious" group was 14, compared to a median of 1 for the "non-suspicious" group. One patient in the highly suspicious group was confirmed to have the syndrome via CT Angiography (CTA), validating the scoring approach.

Conclusion

Renaming MALS to NCGAPS provides a more descriptive and mechanistically accurate framework for both clinicians and patients. While the study is limited by a small sample size and its retrospective nature, the proposed scoring system offers a promising tool for diagnosing this elusive condition. Future prospective studies are necessary to establish a definitive diagnostic cutoff and prevent the misdiagnosis of these patients with functional or psychiatric disorders.

Summary updated

Abstract

We suggest renaming MALS as NCGAPS, nutcracker celiac ganglion abdominal pain syndrome, to better explain the mechanism of the recurrent abdominal pain. Further studies on the diagnostic cutoff of clinical and radiological scores of NCGAPS are needed not to miss the diagnosis of NCGAPS.
BibTeX
@article{kim2023median,
  author = {Ji Eun Kim and Mira Kang and Ok Soon Jeong and Poong‐Lyul Rhee},
  title = {{A Median Arcuate Ligament Syndrome Could Be Re-termed as a Nutcracker Celiac Ganglion Abdominal Pain Syndrome}},
  journal = {Journal of Neurogastroenterology and Motility},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.5056/jnm22158},
}
Figure