A novel methodology to measure waiting times for community-based specialist care in a public healthcare system

Rachel Wilf‐Miron, Ilya Novikov, Arnona Ziv, Avishai Mandelbaum, Ya’acov Ritov, Osnat Luxenburg

Abstract

Monitoring waiting times (WT) is a critical component of healthcare management, as delays are linked to adverse health outcomes and decreased patient satisfaction. This study develops a novel methodology for routine national monitoring of WT for non-urgent specialist appointments within Israel’s public healthcare system. By utilizing data from computerized scheduling systems across all national Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs), the researchers calculated "Offered Wait Times" (OWT) for two scenarios: seeking a "specific" physician versus "any" physician in a region. Analyzing five major specialties, the study found that median OWT for specific physicians ranged from 6 to 13 days, while the "any physician" option reduced wait times by 28–50%. This data-driven approach provides a scalable, low-cost solution for identifying geographic disparities and improving healthcare access.

Introduction

In public healthcare systems, timeliness is a fundamental pillar of quality. However, accurately measuring how long patients wait for care is notoriously difficult. Traditional methods, such as patient surveys, are often expensive and prone to recall bias. "Secret shopper" programs provide high-quality snapshots but are difficult to scale nationally. Furthermore, many administrative metrics focus solely on the "first available" appointment, which fails to account for patient volume or the preference for continuity of care.

This research addresses these gaps by introducing a standardized, national-level metric for Israel’s public healthcare system. The goal was to create a methodology that reflects the actual experience of a patient attempting to book a community-based specialist appointment using existing digital infrastructure.

Methodology: The Offered Wait Time (OWT)

The core of this study is the Offered Wait Time (OWT) metric. Unlike traditional metrics that look at a single data point, this algorithm analyzes the first 50 available appointments from every physician’s digital appointment book. This approach allows for a more nuanced understanding of the "queue" than a simple "next available" slot.

The Two-Scenario Model

To capture the reality of patient behavior, the researchers calculated OWT for two distinct scenarios:

  1. Specific Physician: The patient prioritizes continuity of care and requests a specific, named doctor.
  2. Any Physician: The patient prioritizes speed and is willing to see any qualified specialist within their geographical region.

Estimating Demand

A significant challenge in administrative data is that many IT systems do not track "intent-to-book" (how many people tried to find an appointment but failed). To solve this, the researchers employed a "Steady State" Assumption. They assumed that in a stable system, supply roughly equals demand. By calculating the average number of actual visits that occurred at a practice, they estimated the daily demand. The algorithm then matched this demand to the available slots in the scheduling system to calculate a realistic distribution of wait times.

Data Sources and Scope

The study utilized a massive administrative dataset from all four of Israel’s HMOs, covering December 2018. The dataset included:

  • 1,017,478 available appointments extracted daily.
  • 6,040 community-based physician practices.
  • Five high-volume specialties: Orthopedics, ophthalmology, gynecology, dermatology, and otolaryngology (ENT).
  • Geographic granularity: Analysis was conducted at the town, natural area (52 regions), district, and national levels.

Key Findings

The Price of Preference

The study revealed a significant trade-off between continuity of care and speed. Patients who insisted on a specific physician faced much longer waits. Nationally, the median OWT for a specific physician ranged from 6 days (ophthalmology) to 13 days (dermatology).

In contrast, the "any physician" scenario offered significantly faster access, with wait times 28% to 50% shorter than the specific physician scenario. For example, the median wait for a gynecology appointment dropped from 8 days to just 4 days when the patient was willing to see any available specialist in their region.

Geographic Inequity

The methodology exposed stark regional disparities, or "healthcare deserts." For instance, the 75th percentile wait time for an ophthalmologist in the Southern district was 33 days—three times longer than the 11-day wait found in the Tel Aviv district. These insights allow policymakers to identify exactly where resources are most needed.

Distributional Insights

The researchers found that mean wait times were consistently higher than medians (e.g., a mean of 21.7 days for gynecology vs. a median of 8). This indicates a "long tail" in the data, where a subset of patients waits an exceptionally long time for high-demand experts or in underserved areas.

Discussion and Limitations

This methodology provides a "common denominator" that works across different HMOs with varying IT infrastructures. It was validated against independent consumer surveys conducted during the same period, showing high accuracy at a much lower cost than traditional polling.

However, the authors note several limitations:

  • Static Demand: The model assumes demand is constant throughout the month, potentially missing spikes on certain weekdays.
  • Walk-ins and Attrition: The model does not perfectly account for walk-in patients or the approximately 19% of patients who may give up on booking entirely due to long perceived waits.
  • Data Frequency: The data was a daily snapshot; real-time streaming would better capture the impact of last-minute cancellations.

Conclusion

This novel methodology offers a scalable solution for ongoing national wait-time measurement. By integrating patient preferences and utilizing existing computerized scheduling data, healthcare systems can move beyond anecdotal evidence to data-driven interventions. This approach sets the stage for strengthening public healthcare by identifying specific specialties and regions that require urgent resource allocation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Monitoring of waiting time (WT) in healthcare systems is essential, since long WT are associated with adverse health outcomes, reduced patient satisfaction and increased private financing. Objective To develop a methodology for routine national monitoring of WT for community-based non-urgent specialist appointments, in a public healthcare system. Design Observational historical study using data from computerized appointment scheduling systems of all Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) in Israel. Data sources Data included available appointments for community-based specialists and actual number of visits. The first 50 available appointments from each specialist appointment book were collected throughout December 2018. Five most frequently visited specialties - orthopedics, ophthalmology, gynecology, dermatology and otolaryngology - were included. Data collection/extraction approach WT offered to HMO members (OWT) were calculated for two scenarios: “specific” physician and “any” physician in the clinic’s geographical region. Distribution of OWT was calculated separately for each specialty and geographical region, combined to create the nationwide distribution, and expressed as mean, standard deviation and percentiles. Principal findings Estimated national median OWT for “specific” physician, ranged from 6 days (ophthalmology) to 13 days (dermatology), with large variation between geographic regions. OWT for “any” physician were 28-50% shorter than for “specific” physician. Conclusions This novel method offers a solution for ongoing national WT measurement, using computerized scheduling systems. It integrates patient preferences for physician choice and allows identification of differences between specialties and regions, setting the ground for interventions to strengthen public healthcare systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wilfmiron2020novel,
  author = {Rachel Wilf‐Miron and Ilya Novikov and Arnona Ziv and Avishai Mandelbaum and Ya’acov Ritov and Osnat Luxenburg},
  title = {{A novel methodology to measure waiting times for community-based specialist care in a public healthcare system}},
  booktitle = {Health},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1016/j.healthpol.2020.06.006},
}
Figure