A nonlinear damped metamaterial: Wideband attenuation with nonlinear bandgap and modal dissipation

Bao Zhao, Henrik R. Thomsen, Xingbo Pu, Shitong Fang, Zhihui Lai, Bart Van Damme, Andrea Bergamini, Eleni Chatzi, Andrea Colombi

Abstract: In this paper, we incorporate the effect of nonlinear damping with the concept of locally resonant metamaterials to enable vibration attenuation beyond the conventional bandgap range. The proposed design combines a linear host cantilever beam and periodically distributed inertia amplifiers as nonlinear local resonators. The geometric nonlinearity induced by the inertia amplifiers causes an amplitude-dependent nonlinear damping effect. Through the implementation of both modal superposition and numerical harmonic methods the finite nonlinear metamaterial is accurately modelled. The resulting nonlinear frequency response reveals the bandgap is both amplitude-dependent and broadened. Furthermore, the modal frequencies are also attenuated due to the nonlinear damping effect. The theoretical results are validated experimentally. By embedding the nonlinear damping effect into locally resonant metamaterials, wideband attenuation of the proposed metamaterial is achieved, which opens new possibilities for versatile metamaterials beyond the limit of their linear counterparts.

Introduction

Mechanical vibrations pose a constant threat to structural integrity and human comfort. Engineers traditionally combat this using locally resonant metamaterials—structures with repeating attachments that create "bandgaps," or specific frequency ranges where vibrations cannot propagate. However, traditional linear metamaterials suffer from narrow, fixed bandgaps. If vibration frequencies shift or complex shock waves occur, these systems often fail.

This research introduces a significant advancement by embracing nonlinear damping. Unlike traditional systems, this metamaterial adapts to vibration intensity, broadening its protective range as the input energy increases. This approach moves beyond simple wave blocking to active energy dissipation across multiple structural modes.

Design and Methodology

The core of this innovation lies in the design of the local resonators: rotational inertia amplifiers. These amplifiers consist of two disks connected by tilted beams. When the disks move toward each other due to beam vibration, they are forced to rotate. This geometric constraint creates a "drag force" type of nonlinear damping ($c|\dot{w}_r|\dot{w}_r$), where resistance increases with the square of the velocity.

The design of the inertia amplifier resonator, showing the geometric configuration that induces nonlinear damping through tilted beams and rotating disks.

Modeling this system required advanced numerical techniques because the damping term is non-smooth. The researchers utilized Modal Superposition to simplify the beam's motion, the Harmonic Balance Method (HBM) for frequency-domain solutions, and the Alternating Frequency-Time (AFT) method to handle the non-smooth damping terms efficiently. A prototype was 3D-printed using Selective Laser Sintering (SLS) for experimental validation.

Results and Discussion

The most striking result is the amplitude-dependent bandgap. As the vibration amplitude increases, the nonlinear damping effect kicks in, effectively "stretching" the bandgap to cover a significantly wider frequency range. While high damping in linear systems often blurs the bandgap, in this nonlinear setup, it broadens the zone of protection.

Dispersion curves and frequency response showing how the bandgap broadens as the excitation amplitude (A0) increases, moving from a narrow linear gap to a wide nonlinear attenuation zone.

Key findings include:

  • Broadening Validated: Experimental tests (0.15g to 9g) confirmed that higher excitation levels significantly widened the attenuation zone.
  • Significant Attenuation: The system achieved over 20 dB of attenuation across a much wider bandwidth than comparable linear systems.
  • Shock Performance: Impact tests proved the material becomes more efficient the harder it is hit, with "strong impact" energy decaying much faster than "weak impact" energy.
  • Modal Dissipation: The nonlinear damping couples different vibration modes, allowing energy to transfer from low-frequency modes to higher frequencies where it is dissipated more effectively.

Conclusion and Future Work

This study demonstrates that geometric nonlinearity can be leveraged to create adaptive, wideband vibration protection without exotic materials. While the bandgap broadens, it also becomes slightly shallower at the center frequency, representing a trade-off between width and depth of attenuation.

Future research will focus on scaling these designs for larger applications like bridges or smaller micro-electronics, as well as optimizing resonator placement (e.g., graded or stochastic distributions) to further enhance wideband performance. This work opens new avenues for designing versatile metamaterials that exceed the physical limits of their linear predecessors.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we incorporate the effect of nonlinear damping with the concept of locally resonant metamaterials to enable vibration attenuation beyond the conventional bandgap range. The proposed design combines a linear host cantilever beam and periodically distributed inertia amplifiers as nonlinear local resonators. The geometric nonlinearity induced by the inertia amplifiers causes an amplitude-dependent nonlinear damping effect. Through the implementation of both modal superposition and numerical harmonic methods with Alternating Frequency Time and numerical continuation techniques, the finite nonlinear metamaterial is accurately modeled. The resulting nonlinear frequency response reveals the bandgap is both amplitude-dependent and broadened. Furthermore, the nonlinear interaction between the local resonators and the mode shapes of the host beam is discussed, which leads to efficient modal frequency dissipation ability. The theoretical results are validated experimentally. By embedding the nonlinear damping effect into locally resonant metamaterials, wideband and shock wave attenuation of the proposed metamaterial is achieved, which opens new possibilities for versatile metamaterials beyond the conventional bandgap ranges of their linear counterparts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2023nonlinear,
  author = {Bao Zhao and Henrik R. Thomsen and Xingbo Pu and Shitong Fang and Zhihui Lai and Bart Van Damme and Andrea Bergamini and Eleni Chatzi and Andrea Colombi},
  title = {{A nonlinear damped metamaterial: Wideband attenuation with nonlinear bandgap and modal dissipation}},
  booktitle = {Mechanical},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1016/j.ymssp.2023.111079},
}
Figure